Rouge vs. Hulk

"Did you just like, choose not to read my thing about battle ravaged suits."

Hahaha. This is getting more and more fantastical by the second.

Coz she's have a strategic rip in her suit exactly where Hulk chooses to grab won't she?

You're not doing yourself any favours with the things you're saying.

"her hands are still free."

With all due respect Hulk could tear her arms from her body, while we're doing hog wild. Because her suit is full body. He grabs her arms and she can't move, what then? He tears them off. What then?

-AC

... Her suit isn't like stuck to her body. And she'd soon realize that she would have to sacrifice some stuff like her tres chic suit in order to win this thing.

"Her suit isn't like stuck to her body. And she'd soon realize that she would have to sacrifice some stuff like her tres chic suit in order to win this thing."

Hahaha. It has come to the point of "Rogue would get naked to win".

I rest my case.

-AC

"I do know it, you know what? I agree. Where did I say Rogue is incapable of actually absorbing Hulk's power to a degree? Nowhere. She has a max, she can't absorb it all. She does it in Contest of Champions, a comic created, and I quote "For the sole purpose of having heroes fight for the sake of it. The heroes are controlled by nanities which are basically like robots." I also quote "I had a Shadowcat/Rogue storyline that I wanted to play out but I never really got the chance. This was a perfect conduit to see it through."

So now you want to change your argument since I've called your bluff and you've been proven wrong. Rogue drained hulk and knocked him out, end of story. There's nothing in your quotations from Claremont that dispute that fact.

And I agree that contest of champions was created for the sole purpose of having heroes fight for the sake of it, just like this Rogue vs hulk thread we're debating in now. You're proving my point for me. Rogue won in that fight, so she wins here too.

once again, When I finally make a valid point, ALPHA COMPLETELY ignores it.

He ignores all of the valid points. His response to everything is "Rogue's out of her league", "Hulk's too strong" but he has absolutely ZERO evidence to back up what he's saying.

Originally posted by sbo
He ignores all of the valid points. His response to everything is "Rogue's out of her league", "Hulk's too strong" but he has absolutely ZERO evidence to back up what he's saying.

I'd say the history of Marvel backs up those comments.

Then why did you have to say it? Why didnt he?

And what are you his little helper now, you two go around argueing the same point and seem to have formed a little partnership.

He? Who?

What on Earth are you talking about? Why are all your replies directed at nothing to do with the actual threads?

Helper? Why are you even replying about things like that? Listen to yourself. You need to go to Forums Anonymous or something.

"I'd say the history of Marvel backs up those comments."

I'd say you're wrong. Hulk is 0 and 1 against Rogue.

"Rogues power is applied by a simple tap of the combatant or victim, if the finger is not removed, all power would soon be absorbed, or some, making the victim much weaker, and most likely unable to fight, gripping or holding would be much quicker in absorbtion and much quicker in weakening also. Rogue could do this to even superman im betting, its not just Hulk that can be defeated by her."

IRTMU, I'm not ignoring your posts. It's just that when you are posting the same thing to me in multiple threads, I can't be at 2 places at once. I'm not the Flash.

It's got to the point where Rogue could beat Superman? Jesus.

You are saying "it takes a tap of the finger". She's never done that. She's never done anything that you just said, it's you wanting it to be true. It isn't. If it too a simple tap of skin contact, everyone who punched her in the face would have been drained, have they? No.

"So now you want to change your argument since I've called your bluff and you've been proven wrong. Rogue drained hulk and knocked him out, end of story. There's nothing in your quotations from Claremont that dispute that fact."

I mentioned way before, so what if she IS capable of draining him? It isn't gonna get her the win for many reasons. She'd have to apply it long enough because yes it does take a significant time window, it's not a tap of skin contact. Then she'd have to hold on for long enough to actually reach her max. THEN, in between battling with the multiple personalities and surviving, she'd have to damage Hulk to the point of knock out, which she couldn't do. He isn't gonna be too happy that he's been drained and all it's gonna do is piss him off more, decreasing the chances she never had in the first place.

-AC

Even if that were the case, like I said, the history of Marvel quite clearly puts Hulk about 12 leagues above Rogue.

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
"Her suit isn't like stuck to her body. And she'd soon realize that she would have to sacrifice some stuff like her tres chic suit in order to win this thing."

Hahaha. It has come to the point of "Rogue would get naked to win".

I rest my case.

-AC

If I were rogue, I'd get naked to win. I'm not some ****, but being naked isn't really that embarrasing, unless you have a bad body, in which case you shouldn't be naked. But I'm pretty sure that most of the guys would agree with me that Rogue has a pretty nice body. She'd win, and look good doing it (sorry, thats really cliche).

Cliche? Or a lie.

In fact she might beat him by being naked, but not via draining his power.

"If I were rogue, I'd get naked to win. I'm not some ****, but being naked isn't really that embarrasing, unless you have a bad body, in which case you shouldn't be naked. But I'm pretty sure that most of the guys would agree with me that Rogue has a pretty nice body. She'd win, and look good doing it (sorry, thats really cliche)."

Please don't accuse me of making you look stupid ever, ever again.

Ever.

-AC

"I mentioned way before, so what if she IS capable of draining him? It isn't gonna get her the win for many reasons. She'd have to apply it long enough because yes it does take a significant time window, it's not a tap of skin contact. Then she'd have to hold on for long enough to actually reach her max. THEN, in between battling with the multiple personalities and surviving, she'd have to damage Hulk to the point of knock out, which she couldn't do. He isn't gonna be too happy that he's been drained and all it's gonna do is piss him off more, decreasing the chances she never had in the first place."

As I've said before multiple personalities aren't anything that Rogue's not used to, she has them in her head all the time and she can handle it. And she doesn't have to max herself out to beat him, she only needs to steal enough power to incapacitate him or knock him out and that's what she did.

DON'T TELL ME WHAT TO DO. Cliche is A trite or overused expression or idea

"And she doesn't have to max herself out to beat him, she only needs to steal enough power to incapacitate him or knock him out and that's what she did."

You have nothing besides Contest of Champions, which time and time again has been proven to be a storyline vehicle. Outside of it all you can say is what she should and could do. Hence why nearly all of your posts are concerning it.

-AC

Originally posted by laydiiplayette
Cliche is A trite or overused expression or idea

...

i posted the definition because your post made me think that you didn't know what it means.