Oh no....just when we have enough major "Let's hand relief the X-Women" thread, this one gets brought back.
"With hulk at a diminisherd strength level and Rogue's strength augmented, I think it's entirely possible."
Yeah but as soon as she takes it, he'll get it back. He won't be diminished. She won't win.
-AC
I read your post, I laughed at it too. You said she can KO the Hulk.
Again I ask you: What can Rogue's punches, with or without gamma, do to the Incredible Hulk? Realistically, without felching your favourite character?
Realistically, she wouldn't/can't knock out the Hulk.
By the time she takes his power, if she even succeeds (she will be at max capacity, a flying She-Hulk essentially) he will have got it back. She cannot hit with enough power to knock him out. Juggernaut has fists the size of televisions and alot more strength than both She-Hulk and Rogue, he had enough trouble doing it. Rogue won't be able to.
This is just me toying with you now, hopefully you realise this. Continue for my amusement please.
-AC
Rogue's already drained hulk once before, so I think it's pretty easy to see that she could drain him partially and then knock him out with a physical blow. She ALMOSt did the same thing to Juggernaut.
And I don't see why you keep bringing up the flying she-hulk analogy.
It was inapt before and it is inapt now. Rogue wouldn't be draining she-hulk's strength, she'd be draining hulk's strength.
"It was inapt before and it is inapt now. Rogue wouldn't be draining she-hulk's strength, she'd be draining hulk's strength."
Read my post. I said she would be essentially LIKE a flying She-Hulk after she absorbed Hulk's strength. Hulk would have already compensated. She doesn't pack enough to knock him out.
Continue.
-AC
"No she'd be essentially LIKE a flying Hulk. Hulk wouldn't recuperate quickly enough to withstand being clobbered by his own strength."
Rogue powered by a bit of Hulk's strength isn't the same as Hulk clobbering Rogue with his own strength.
You are saying he won't regain his strength just to help you. He would, it's the nature of his power.
"I dont understand why she would be like a flying she hulk when she would be absorbing the hulks strength? Can some1 other than AC help me out. If im being stupid then giv it 2 me straight."
Seeing as I'm the one saying it, I'll explain it.
She's a woman, correct? Same as She-Hulk? Well Rogue has a max capacity. When she has reached it, she will be just a gamma empowered woman. Like She-Hulk. She-Hulk and Hulk are both fueled by Gamma.
Look at the thread title, Rogue Vs Hulk. Rogue is not going to win.
-AC
"Rogue absorbs the powers of the person she's touching, not the person's closest female analogy. If she touches hulk she gets hulk's strength not she-hulk's."
Ok. One more time for the mentally impaired.
They....are both........powered by GAMMA. She-Hulk.....does NOT increase with rage. Rogue.....when full on Gamma, will have a MAX capacity to which she cannot go beyond. Just like She-Hulk cannot go beyond. She is absorbing GAMMA POWER. Who it comes from doesn't matter. She will be a GAMMA empowered female with a max capacity that she cannot exceed. Who else is like that? Ding ding ding.
"While she has his strength Hulk won't be operating at full capacity no matter how fast he recuperates."
It takes him seconds. Not even that. Stop clinging. Rogue isn't gonna knock him DOWN in seconds. Let alone out.
Anymore? Coz you know, I'm here.
-AC
Rogue trying to absorb Hulk's power is laughable. She'd put herself into a coma, or worse.
Have you ever seen a kitchen sponge absorb an entire lake? No, because the sponge fills up before the lake runs out of water.
Kind of how it would work with Rogue and Hulk, seeing that his strength is limitless.
If the kitchen sponge has prep time it will take that lake down hard and fast.
Back to the thread at hand. How much more rage is Hulk going to be feeling as he's on the verge of passing out? Rogue will be stealing hulk's strength as he's losing it. And whatever Rogue's upper limit is you don't know it because it's never been determined so you have absolutely NO evidence to base your assumption on.
"How much more rage is Hulk going to be feeling as he's on the verge of passing out?"
Rogue's capacity is nowhere near Hulk's threshold though. You are pretending it is.
"Rogue will be stealing hulk's strength as he's losing it. And whatever Rogue's upper limit is you don't know it because it's never been determined so you have absolutely NO evidence to base your assumption on."
Hulk's strength is limitless. Rogue's isn't.
Trauma is much much much more powerful than Rogue, he tried to absorb Hulk's strength and died.
Why is a woman who has a seizure when making out with a human, gonna succeed where he failed?
Shh.
-AC
It's not assumption, it's fact. Please tell me you know what LIMITLESS means, because that last post seemed as if you didn't.
Whatever Rogue's upper limit is, IT'S NOT HIGH ENOUGH.
And Hulk's been on the verge of dying before, and still got angier to whoop ass, passing out to the Hulk would be more like just getting kind of sleepy.