All Of Star Trek Vs All Of Star Wars

Started by Fishy76 pages

Well if its up to me I choose about 25.000 years before Kotor...

The height of the Rakatan Empire 😛

But thats not really fair. So how about Revan his time. Lets say it starts from just before the Mandelorian wars until just after Revan is Sith Lord again. That would be about 7 or 8 years or so.

but the technology would be really far behind then wouldnt it? blaster fire power.......etc...hull strengths...(just guessing that they would improve alot)

Well I cant really say much about that erra of the SW universe. I have played through KOTOR but dont remember a whole lot about it and I have not read anything from that erra... I prefer to go more forward in time than backwards. But when we get more input we can put it to a vote.

Originally posted by Jack Daniels
but the technology would be really far behind then wouldnt it? blaster fire power.......etc...hull strengths...(just guessing that they would improve alot)

Not really, the Rakatan times were 25.000 years before Kotor and their ships still managed to surpass Republic ships of that time, they were really ahead of their time of course.

I dont know how much is known about that erra of the SW timeline. I know that I dont know much about it... (thats not saying much though). I think it would be good to stick with a time period that more people are familiar with.

TR, your sig is very appropriate for this thread. Nice shot of the E.

well if fishy says so then he just needs motions on that era to back him where the hell is janus?

Well I have to put my nomination up for a Post ROTJ erra for the next thread. I belive there is more data available to support the SW side than further back in history.

Only thing is I hate post ROTJ NJO sucks balls..

And indeed there isn't a lot known about the Rakatan except for that they ruled the universe their most basic technology's weren't copied until thousands of years later. Their technology regenerates they were with billions upon billions they all have the force they use the Dark Side and that they have a powerful weapons plant that can create a ship in second with almost no resources..

Any real things about their fights we do not and can not know, we do know their force power had to be great because no races could challenge them that includes the Sith and a lot of other force sensitives, maybe those didn't get any training so that is perhaps a wrong thing to say. They also used the force to power their ships to make them fly faster then anything else at that time and they still had hyperspace engines...

Thats all we know nothing substential really but enough to convince me that they could own everybody from later ages of SW... If not by being more powerful then just by putting a droid in a ship and ramming the enemy 😛

Only thing is I hate post ROTJ/NJO sucks balls IMO..

And indeed there isn't a lot known about the Rakatan except for that they ruled the universe their most basic technology's weren't copied until thousands of years later. Their technology regenerates they were with billions upon billions they all have the force they use the Dark Side and that they have a powerful weapons plant that can create a ship in second with almost no resources..

Any real things about their fights we do not and can not know, we do know their force power had to be great because no races could challenge them that includes the Sith and a lot of other force sensitives, maybe those didn't get any training so that is perhaps a wrong thing to say. They also used the force to power their ships to make them fly faster then anything else at that time and they still had hyperspace engines...

Thats all we know nothing substantial really but enough to convince me that they could own everybody from later ages of SW... If not by being more powerful then just by putting a droid in a ship and ramming the enemy 😛

As far as action and general exitement in watching either of them, I would say Star Wars is way cooler. Who could win in a space battle, a Federation starship or a Super Star Destroyer?

Star Trek is generally superior as far as detail and technology. Granted there is no Force in Trek and that is a serious hit against its coolness. However, the deflector shield of a Federation ship can protect against the most deadly shot fired from a Star Destroyer. The small burst of energy could do nothing, except maybe lower the shields .00001%. In Trek there is little (if any) mistakes in continuity, except for the Original Series, that was a bad time. In The Next Generation, Voyager, Deep Space Nine and Enterprise (only the two former are actually good) every technological facet is explained in detail. Did Star Wars ever explain how the X foils needed to be in attack posistion to fire? Not really. Then again, Star Trek has the time to explain it when they have 5 TV series, averageing about 5 years per show, and 10 movies.

Fishy you just like the rakatans cause they are fishy type folk...lol....
as I understand they would undo themselves anyway in a battle like we speak of cause of the thing called star forge? But could you imagine if the borg got there hands on that or joined the rakata though......woof...now there is an idea the borg being non force users(so they could control it without being thrown into chaos like the rakata folk) use and control the star forge and keep the rakatan people away from it so it doesnt consume them...hmm you could be onto something... indeed you may...

Nobody but the most powerful of force users could use the Star Forge...

so they assimilate one powerful rakata and limit its connection with the collective(trying to back you on suggested era...lol...)

WTF Star Wars is so simple Star trek is so complex...Star trek would win with or without Q....to many powerful beings....jedi and sith are the limit for star wars.....to many godling like beings in trek to count.....gimme a break!

This battle would be between Q and SuperShadow.

Proton torpedoes colliding with photon torpedoes.
And borg adapting to everything eventually.

Wow, nobody cares..

Amen, noone gives a rat's ass who will win.

One non-real universe! VS. Another, slightly more realistic universe with Earth thrown in somewhere!

Debate of the century eh?

Star Wars forever will win!!!!

😄

Oh you gotta be kidding me, Star Trek vs. Star wars... THERE IS NO CONTEST... Starwars!

Star Wars. Ragnos and his twenty apostles could win on their own.