the star wars would kill all the trek geeks i mean all the clones, imperial fighters,wookie,sith,jedi,gungons,luke,yoda,death star, second deathstar,
would lkill all of the stupid star trek losers.
Maul would wipe all of the commanders out
Vader would use the death star and destroy all the planets
Sidous would turn the star trek heroes to the dark side
Chewbacca would rip of their arms
Imperial fleet would destroy star trek base...
Pretty much the star trek is screwed and the star wars will kick ass.
Originally posted by WeskerIt didn't take me long at all. But then again I really only had to read from page 1 to page 10, then I kept reading just to see if this thread would just die already. I mean SW just decimates ST on ground battles. The only chance they have is in space.
I don't think anyone has five years to spare, really.
If you look at sheer numbers ONLY... forget about how many Jedi there are or who has the power to do what... this is the result...
SW wins in sheer numbers... why...
SW Universe covers over 10,000 years while ST Universe covers only 300 years... Humm... Yeah... I think SW wins in the numbers department. The reasons why are clear...
Go back to the first 300 years of faster than light space travel and we have a different story...
The Borg could assimilate the Death Star easily. All they have to do is approach from the side without the super laser, and beam aboard. They have transporters that can punch through Federation shields, the Death Star's defences wouldn't pose any problem. Once aboard, they would start assimilating the Storm Troopers (whos armor would be ineffective against the drone's assimilation talons, which can puncture any material) That's more troops straight away in addition to the drones they still have on their ship. Vader and Palpatine would be screwed. The Borg's shields would adapt to the blades of their lightsabers after a few swings, and then all the Sith Lords would have would be their Force Powers. At the best, they could hold the drones back till they could get to an escape pod, but if they were cornered, then ultimately they would become weary and the Borg would overwhelm them. Yes, it would definitely cost a few drones, but ultimately, they would overpower them. Resistance is Futile...
Originally posted by TRSundown
If you look at sheer numbers ONLY... forget about how many Jedi there are or who has the power to do what... this is the result...SW wins in sheer numbers... why...
SW Universe covers over 10,000 years while ST Universe covers only 300 years... Humm... Yeah... I think SW wins in the numbers department. The reasons why are clear...
Go back to the first 300 years of faster than light space travel and we have a different story...
No. This has already been done into the ground, TRS.... As of current tech, SW far outstrips ST for sheer military use and practicability. They far outnumber ST, have better propulsion systems, larger ships, better moving ships, more martial races than ST can shake a stick at, and force users to add to that. (Although realistically force users aren't even needed to conquer ST.)
ST's constant excuses of "We have random plot pseudoscience elements" doesn't pan out because they're all freak occurences and not the norm. Secondly, the idea of time travel doesn't equate because it says specifically in ST that every instance of time travel is opening up an ALTERNATE universe. Ergo, they could go back in time (Which is the pussy's way of fighting) and beat a stone age SW and win nothing, because back in the other alternate timeline SW will just conquer ST space.
Really, it's getting old with the Star Trek apologists making up excuses, exceptions, and citing one or two instances where ST might have an advantage and then building an entire case on it. SW is simply going to win this. Period. QED. It is done.
The Borg could assimilate the Death Star easily. All they have to do is approach from the side without the super laser, and beam aboard. They have transporters that can punch through Federation shields, the Death Star's defences wouldn't pose any problem. Once aboard, they would start assimilating the Storm Troopers (whos armor would be ineffective against the drone's assimilation talons, which can puncture any material) That's more troops straight away in addition to the drones they still have on their ship. Vader and Palpatine would be screwed. The Borg's shields would adapt to the blades of their lightsabers after a few swings, and then all the Sith Lords would have would be their Force Powers. At the best, they could hold the drones back till they could get to an escape pod, but if they were cornered, then ultimately they would become weary and the Borg would overwhelm them. Yes, it would definitely cost a few drones, but ultimately, they would overpower them. Resistance is Futile...
And this statement is ridiculous. The Borg aren't capable of taking over a Death Star. Hell, they get hacked up with swords...
Originally posted by Wesker
No. This has already been done into the ground, TRS.... As of current tech, SW far outstrips ST for sheer military use and practicability. They far outnumber ST, have better propulsion systems, larger ships, better moving ships, more martial races than ST can shake a stick at, and force users to add to that. (Although realistically force users aren't even needed to conquer ST.)ST's constant excuses of "We have random plot pseudoscience elements" doesn't pan out because they're all freak occurences and not the norm. Secondly, the idea of time travel doesn't equate because it says specifically in ST that every instance of time travel is opening up an ALTERNATE universe. Ergo, they could go back in time (Which is the pussy's way of fighting) and beat a stone age SW and win nothing, because back in the other alternate timeline SW will just conquer ST space.
Really, it's getting old with the Star Trek apologists making up excuses, exceptions, and citing one or two instances where ST might have an advantage and then building an entire case on it. SW is simply going to win this. Period. QED. It is done.
Again... 10,000+ years for SW vs. 300 years for ST... not really a good VS argument...
And my prime example of SW technological inferiority is the Imperial Probe Droid... what is the point... We have satellite technology today that has better imaging and sensory technology than the IPD. The design for the purpose is completely wrong. You launch satellites into orbit around a planet to scan not send something to the surface where your scanning range is limited to a few dozen kilometers at best. The Empire got lucky that the IPD landed as close as it did to the Rebel base otherwise it would have taken months to cover the surface of the planet... And to go along with that, why didn't the ISD detect the massive power output of the Rebel base when it launched the PD's... cause its sensors were inadequate to the task.
If SW cant even get their sensor technology right what makes you think that the rest of their tech is going to stack up.
I have posted this before...
You would really have to break it down to several catagories
Weapons
Shields
Sensors
Speed
Medical
Ships (standard fleet ships)
Super Weapons/Ships
and then break those down into more sub catagories.
From the reading that I have done when it comes to standard ships and weapon tech SW is on the high side while ST falls behind. Again though, after over 10,000 year of tech you better have better tech than a 300 year old (faster than light travel) civilization. But looking at the IPD, SW does not hold up.
Speed, although unfathomable as far as their capabilities, SW has the upper hand.
Sensor tech goes to ST.
Medical I call a tie but I really I lean on the ST side based on what I have seen and read.