Darth Malak Vs Luke Skywalker(ROTJ)

I like Luke, but I won't budge. ROTJ Luke wasn't ready to defeat Vader in honest combat, let alone take on Malak. Maybe in a few months from then, but not right away.

He does swing a little wildly at times, but at others he knows exactly where to swing. Like when he cut off the front of the speeder bike. He knows exactly when to dodge, when to parry, etc. And maybe Vader was giving him an advantage but do you really think he would have purposely let Luke fall to the dark side to take his place and then let Luke kill him? You can tell Vader is trying if you watch it. Besides, thats more of those what ifs. there's no proof that Vader was taking it easy on him. Like I said, Luke might have been able to defeat Sidious if he had his lightsaber but we dont know. And I have my reasons when I say Luke beat Vader with ease. Firstly, he didn't want to even fight at all. Secondly he kicked Vader down those stairs but didn't chase him down. He jumped clear over Vader's lightsaber, and then dodged Vader's lightsaber throw. Nextly he was powerful enough that Vader couldn't sense his position. Lastly he cut off Vader's hand and had him fighting for oxygen in 40 seconds. A guy like Vader wouldnt just let that happen to him.

Given dramatic neccessity, of course not.

I remain unconvinced. Sorry, man.

But kudos to sticking to your guns.

I don't think Vader was trying to take it easy on him, he was just torn with conflict, which you can't have in a fight.
On one hand, turn Luke, kill Emperor, rule together.
Other hand, turn yourself, kill Emperor and save the universe.
Last hand, Luke turns, kills you and replaces you. Not much of a Skywalker legacy.

ROTJ Luke is indeed powerful, and I don't really think Revan would kill him, as he would be too busy attempting to pursuage him, and I don't think Luke would have the necessary skill to get the job done. In a sense, it's a draw.

Originally posted by Kun-ni Habeo
2jackstain

did your momma teach you that?cuz when i saw her last time she didn't talk that dirty to me.
oh btw ur a dickhead it took 3 days for you to realise that i insulted you.

o btw thats because i have a friggin life, and i actually get vaGina, and i dont spend every waking hour on the internet, trying to insult people i dont even know, but finding it too hard because the other guy isnt even a nerd, and he's whippin my(your) @$$....and because ur constantly having to push up ur glasses, and take a time out and try and convince yourself that ur not a virgin, when in fact, you are and forever will be....you stupid homosexual poon. shut the f*ck up. 💃 😉

smiTed.

damn, the W middle finger, he's done it now...
lol

i'm not the one who masturbates on maul's picture

lol
I beat off to Vader lol

and I totally beat it to Princess Leia in the metal bikini

i beat on padme too and chewie offcourse how could i forget

you beat off to any man's picture u can get a hold of.

now really we can stop this i don't want to lower myself to your poor level,you are a ****ing id1ot

lol, u dont want to lower urself to my level, yet you started it,and you continue to insult me.....im not buyin it sh!tas$

and u dont even have the common courtesy of hitting me with a decent insult. why dont you do everyone, or just me, a favor, and shut the piss up already.

I think that if any one of you are going to argue, just use PM's or something and not use a topic...

Why the hell are they arguing about?

i honestly dont know......but i wont shut up till he does, if he changes the subject, i will....ill change it now, since i obviously smited him......alf rules

alf is sh1t and so are you mofo

Kun-ni Habeo, stop sending these f**king comments. Just end it here.