Darth Revan and Darth Malak vs. NJO Luke and Mace Windu

Revan and Luke are basically equal with Revan being a little stronger, as in 999 out of one thousand times they would draw and the one time Revan would win type stronger.

Malak and mace is hard to say, Malak has more experience more force powers and extremely long limbs with a long saber, but mace had a style that was good against darkside users, I'm still going with malak.

Now that being said what if Revan fought mace and malak fought luke, malak could hold off Luke long enough for Revan to finish off mace, Remember next to Revan malak was the most powerful force user in the galaxy, he had knowledge from some of the same sources of Revan maybe not as much but still that's a lot of knowledge.

Now all that being said we come down to one last factor, chemistry malak and Revan fought side by side for years they were the best of friends and did everything together so they fought together very well opposed to mace and luke who didn't know each other and would have trouble working together.

In the end sith win.

P.S when does malak beat kavar emperor Revan?

Originally posted by Darth_Frobo
Revan and Luke are basically equal with Revan being a little stronger, as in 999 out of one thousand times they would draw and the one time Revan would win type stronger.

Malak and mace is hard to say, Malak has more experience more force powers and extremely long limbs with a long saber, but mace had a style that was good against darkside users, I'm still going with malak.

Now that being said what if Revan fought mace and malak fought luke, malak could hold off Luke long enough for Revan to finish off mace, Remember next to Revan malak was the most powerful force user in the galaxy, he had knowledge from some of the same sources of Revan maybe not as much but still that's a lot of knowledge.

Now all that being said we come down to one last factor, chemistry malak and Revan fought side by side for years they were the best of friends and did everything together so they fought together very well opposed to mace and luke who didn't know each other and would have trouble working together.

In the end sith win.

P.S when does malak beat kavar emperor Revan?

He talks about it in KOTOR 2 I believe.

And why does everyone say that Mace's style helps against Dark Siders? I have never seen proof that it actually is better.

It doesn't. That's a myth.

Originally posted by Darth_Frobo
Revan and Luke are basically equal with Revan being a little stronger, as in 999 out of one thousand times they would draw and the one time Revan would win type stronger.

Malak and mace is hard to say, Malak has more experience more force powers and extremely long limbs with a long saber, but mace had a style that was good against darkside users, I'm still going with malak.

Now that being said what if Revan fought mace and malak fought luke, malak could hold off Luke long enough for Revan to finish off mace, Remember next to Revan malak was the most powerful force user in the galaxy, he had knowledge from some of the same sources of Revan maybe not as much but still that's a lot of knowledge.

Now all that being said we come down to one last factor, chemistry malak and Revan fought side by side for years they were the best of friends and did everything together so they fought together very well opposed to mace and luke who didn't know each other and would have trouble working together.

In the end sith win.

P.S when does malak beat kavar emperor Revan?

Zaj Kal El or whatever the name of the Master on Nar Shaddaa is, talks about about Kavar going there and losing from Malak badly just barely escaping alive.

Exactly. Vaapad uses dark feelings and practices, but in and of itself, it has no special advantages against the dark side.

Has anybody truly decided? Janus? Fishy?

Decided on what? The winner? Malak and Revan.

They work better together. Malak is more powerful then Mace, Revan can manage Luke possibly beat him, but together with Malak he sure as hell could.

I doubt Revan alone could take Luke (possible), but with Malak he could. But don't you think Luke could at least take Malak down with him? I mean he would be weakened from his battle with Mace. Just a thought.

No, actually I don't. I know he could in theory beat one of them. But then I rethink everything I ever posted about Malak and Revan and realise what a team those two would make. Think about it, they were training together for most of their lives they were best friends, they saved and destroyed the Republic together. They ended the Mandelorian threat together. Those two would help each other out in a fight, tobad Malak failed to see logic in the Dark Side and only saw the Dark Side. Together those two could have ruled the universe with ease and with perfection.

Anyways together those two make a great team and they are great fighters, I don't think there are many Master apprentice duo's that could match these two powerful Sith Lords if any. And seeing as I believe Luke would have his hands full with Revan alone and Malak knowing exactly what to do and when Luke would be screwed. Without taking anybody with him.

I can live with that. It was just a thought.

And I agree. My verdict is Revan and Malak win.

Well if you think differently feel free to share your reasons.

I too believed that Revan and Malak would win. It's just that Malak and Mace wouldn't be even, but they wouldn't be miles apart either. So I thought that Malak, after killing Windu in a challenging duel, would be somewhat weakened, and perhaps susceptible to a Force attack from Luke. But I realized that Luke would have his hands full with Revan.

I too believed that Revan and Malak would win. It's just that Malak and Mace wouldn't be even, but they wouldn't be miles apart either. So I thought that Malak, after killing Windu in a challenging duel, would be somewhat weakened, and perhaps susceptible to a Force attack from Luke. But I realized that Luke would have his hands full with Revan, too much so to protect against Malak.

Sorry for the double post.

I agree. With anybody else I would also think Luke could kill that person but Malak and Revan just know how to fight together.

I agree. So Revan and Malak it is. But after a good fight.

Oh yeah a nice fight to see.

Definetely. One of the best.

Got to get to a hundred posts!