Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince - Book 2005

Started by Phoenix31 pages
Originally posted by iluvsirius
About the Unbreakable Vow thing Snape didnt have to do it at first...he could have found a way to get out of...or not help her at all...asuring Narcissa that Draco could do it....but helping him in the end if he had to... sorry i just cant accept the fact that even if he HAD to he killed him noup wont do for me

how could he have got out of it? Voldie would hve suspected him straight away

how do u make spoilers dark and u can only read them when u highlight them???

i have already finished the book (i did yesterday) it was fantastic! please pm me or tell me how to do spoilers plez!!!

🙂

Originally posted by LaLaLaGirl21
how do u make spoilers dark and u can only read them when u highlight them???

You use
Spoiler:
(type crud here)[spoiler] but with a slash iin the last tag so it looks like:

Spoilers look like this...

[ spoiler](type whatever you want to type)[ /spoiler]

Only, don't space anywhere in between the brackets.

hahaha....who would have guessed, snape, on the evil side..uh EVERYONE! i mean of course no one expected him to kill dumbledore ❌ but come on..most of us could have seen that coming..though i am a huge fan of the harry/ginny hookup, and i think that maybe...just maybe...in the end of book 7, they will somehow get back together, if that is to say..harry lives, cuz idk about all you, but i think theres a possibility, though most writers wouldnt do this, that harry will die in book 7, i mean i know it seems liek it couldnt happen but i think its very possible...oh and i also think that the 7th book will be called..."Harry Potter and the final horcrux"

HBP insight

for those who have already read the book . . .
(PLEASE DON'T READ IF YOU HAVEN'T FINISHED THE BOOK!!)

ok i just finished the book today and i was wondering what you guys thought about this. It was just a kind of daydream I had about what might happen in the 7th book ...

Harry said at the end of HBP that he probably wasnt going to return to Hogwarts and that he was going to look for the other Horcruxes and once that is accomplished, kill Voldemort. Do any of you think its possible that Harry himself could be one of Voldemort's Horcruxes? Dumbledore did tell Harry that it was possible to have a living creature or a human as a Horcrux. This would also explain why the prophecy stated "neither can live while the other survives" as both Harry and Voldemort would have to die.

please give me your opinions, i'd like to hear what some of you guys think about it. thanks 🙂

Did anyone notice the fact that dumbledore said to Draco that Lord V can not kill you if you are already dead. It is the argument going on in my house over whether that means dumbledore planed the hole thing with Snape. When you read it it is as though he is telling Draco how he could protect him, but there may be more to it. I think he is dead but....I would like to think there is still a chance. I think we all want to think he is still alive. The best way to convince Lord V. that dumbledore was dead and that Snape had turned was to tell no one of there plan. Well dose any one think that he is still alive. I think he is dead

not really look at fred and george quit in the 5th book before thier 7th year and they are quailified wizards

WOW i never thought of that...when you...but when you think about it he cant be though because voldemort did the killing cures and not the curse to perform horcuxes...

Originally posted by shadow12
not really look at fred and george quit in the 5th book before thier 7th year and they are quailified wizards

thats actually a good point i forgot about that thanks.

about what lord follen said ..

are you sure that's how it works though? couldnt he have killed harry's parents for the sacrifice so he could gain the horcrux?

no prob
he killed so many times that killing lily and james wouldn't matter for the horcrux he killed them be cause they got in the way

Harry isn't a horcrux.. because he has to kill him self first before he kills voldemort..

Originally posted by TinkrBellBaBii
about what lord follen said ..

are you sure that's how it works though? couldnt he have killed harry's parents for the sacrifice so he could gain the horcrux?

ah but in order to do so is with murder and he has dome enough that by that time he should have has his seven already wouldnt you think so?

Originally posted by daeri
Harry isn't a horcrux.. because he has to kill him self first before he kills voldemort..

There you have it. Proof positive that Harry cannot be a hocrux.

but it wud be funny tho

Originally posted by Director_Joe
There you have it. Proof positive that Harry cannot be a hocrux.

but how would that work? how would harry kill himself and THEN kill voldemort? both of them have to be killed at the same time, right?

no because if you kill yourself you cant kill some one eles when your dead...LOL