I have a couple of curious points in the book I would like to point out
Spoiler:
(-what was the potion in the thingy where the horcruxe was? was it the original potion that voldemort put in, or was it a new potion that R.A.B put in-also, did dumbledore know it was not the real horcruxe?
-did anyone else notice that dumbledore was acting extremely odd, and slightly out of character durign the whole book? was it possible that someone was impersonating him or he was under the imperius curse?
-the fact that the HBP textbook was able to write back, could it have been something similar as to what tom riddle's diary was? and if so, was it a horcruxe, making Snape immortal as well?)
anyways thats just some of my weird thoughts, so shout something back, i would liek to know what you peeps think
Originally posted by GraciePoo
I have a couple of curious points in the book I would like to point outSpoiler:
(-what was the potion in the thingy where the horcruxe was? was it the original potion that voldemort put in, or was it a new potion that R.A.B put in-also, did dumbledore know it was not the real horcruxe?
-did anyone else notice that dumbledore was acting extremely odd, and slightly out of character durign the whole book? was it possible that someone was impersonating him or he was under the imperius curse?
-the fact that the HBP textbook was able to write back, could it have been something similar as to what tom riddle's diary was? and if so, was it a horcruxe, making Snape immortal as well?)
anyways thats just some of my weird thoughts, so shout something back, i would liek to know what you peeps think
I think dumbledore knew but its a very big guess.
I doubt anyone could put dumbledore under the imperius curse, voldemort couldn't to harry.
The book didn't write back it was just an old textbook that snape put some notes in.
page 183
after hermoine tapped it with her wand.
Spoiler:
"nobody else was looking. harry bent low to retrieve the book and as he did so he saw somethign scrippled along the bottom of the back cover in the same small cramped handwriting as the instructions that had won him his bottle of felix felicis............
This book is the property of the half blood prince
so does that mean that it was always there, or that harry saw it being written on the page?
Spoiler:
plus i seriously think that somethign was wrogn with dumbledore becuase wouldnt he have known that malfoy was doing something? or that Snape was plannign something? i dont think that all of the could have gone past him without him even knowing. like for example in ss/ps he knew that harry made repeated trips to the mirror of erised. i serioulsy doubt that with all of the evidence that was put before him that he would not have even slightly suspected that somethign was up? I mean come on you seriously cannot be that daft. so i think that there is definitley more to it than has been told
Originally posted by GraciePoo
page 183
after hermoine tapped it with her wand.Spoiler:
"nobody else was looking. harry bent low to retrieve the book and as he did so he saw somethign scrippled along the bottom of the back cover in the same small cramped handwriting as the instructions that had won him his bottle of felix felicis............
This book is the property of the half blood princeso does that mean that it was always there, or that harry saw it being written on the page?
It was written as it was written along time ago not writte before there very eyes.
Also about dumbledore, he did know about malfoy, he TELLS malfoy he knew what he was doing.
mmmm i dunno, i think theres some good in him. he did say that he couldnt no do what he was doing becuz voldie would kill his family. i mean i understand why he would agree to it.and he couldnt bring himself to do it anyways.....so i think that he can redeem himself. but then again, im a forgiving person, i would forgive voldemort if he was genuinely sorry about what he did, i mean who am i to judge?