Originally posted by starwarsfreak34I know this is weird speculation, but here goes. What if the horcrux was actually the liquid? Maybe Dumbledore becomes the horcrux and is actually pleading with Snape to kill him, to destroy part of Voldemort's soul? Dumbledore would want to die before that part became too strong. Also, all the horcruxes must be destroyed before Voldemort can be killed. He certainly wouldn't want Harry to have to kill him. Why would he freeze Harry if he didn't want to die?
i agree that snape is not on voldys side. i return to a very old theory about snape in love with lily, and i wonder i JK might just pull it off (what other reason would dumbledore have for trusting that snape was really sorry for what he did if that 'personal risk' was not that snape loved lily? maybe he hates harry and james cox he thinks harry should have been his son? (oh, and that means snape must have been acting on dds say so to kill him)
Originally posted by GodricaG
I know this is weird speculation, but here goes. What if the horcrux was actually the liquid? Maybe Dumbledore becomes the horcrux and is actually pleading with Snape to kill him, to destroy part of Voldemort's soul? Dumbledore would want to die before that part became too strong. Also, all the horcruxes must be destroyed before Voldemort can be killed. He certainly wouldn't want Harry to have to kill him. Why would he freeze Harry if he didn't want to die?
its a good idea but no, it cant be, because R.A.B said that he stole the Horcrux and repleced it with a fake one.
before i say who i think R.A.B is i have to say something. I cant believe how many people are saying that Snape is still a good guy, and that he killed Dumbledore for Harry. Come on, he killed dumbledore, he is a death eater, he tipped off voldemort about the prophecy, and everything. There is no way he did this for Harry. I admit before this book came out i was starting to believe that Snape was good. But no. I am back to hating him as much as before. I hope he dies so bad.
now for the R.A.B, i guess it could be Regulas, but i would rather it some guy entirely different that we dont know about. I've got one theory about this, but im not good at theorys so....
I think that Snape tipped off Voldemort that Dumbledore was leaving the castle to do "stuff" and probaly told Voldemort that Slughorn was in Hogwarts. Voldemort might have thought that SLughorn would tell for be forced to tell about Horcruxes, so Voldemort thought that Dumbledore was going off to find the Horcruxes. I think that maybe Voldemort went to the cave got the Horcrux and repleced it with a fake one and a fake note pretending to be someone that stole the Horcrux. I dont think Dumbledore would have died if he hadnt drunk the potion to try and the the Horcrux. I think it might have been all a setup by Voldemort to weaken Dumbledore and make it easier to kill him, and that he still has the Horcrux thats in the locket.
my theory is probaly way off, but i thought i'd just throw that out there.
Could sirius come back, if you look where JKR got the name for him ,
Sirius is also the brightest star in the sky it is also called the dog star, hence sirius tuns into a dog when he transforms into his animagus form.
astronomers have also discovered that sirus has another star with it, since sirius was so bright is outshone the other smaller star, so does sirus have another brother?
whose initials could be R.A. Black?
Originally posted by GraciePoo
i thnik its possible that regulus is the RAB. cuz lupin said that it took almost a year for karkaroff to be killed, but regulus was killed in a few days. what would regulus have to have done to make voldie want to kill him so fast?
Lupin says it's surprising how long Karkaroff lives, and that normally someone would die in a few days, not take a year.
I think Dumbledore instructed Snape to kill him, in the tower after he had drunk the potion he asks Harry to fetch Snape. I think Dumbledore wanted Snape to kill him to save Draco Malfoy, Dumbledore could see that Malfoy was innocent and didn't want to become a killer. I think Dumbledore knew his time was up soon anyway, and when he heard how Voldemort was using Malfoy, he instructed Snape to make the unbreakable bond.
Maybe Malfoy will have an important role in the next book, I honestly think there will be one final twist regarding which side snape is on before the end of the saga.
Originally posted by zombieman
I think Dumbledore instructed Snape to kill him, in the tower after he had drunk the potion he asks Harry to fetch Snape. I think Dumbledore wanted Snape to kill him to save Draco Malfoy, Dumbledore could see that Malfoy was innocent and didn't want to become a killer. I think Dumbledore knew his time was up soon anyway, and when he heard how Voldemort was using Malfoy, he instructed Snape to make the unbreakable bond.Maybe Malfoy will have an important role in the next book, I honestly think there will be one final twist regarding which side snape is on before the end of the saga.
No, he told Harry to get Snape because Snape would know how to cure him, and because Dumbledore trusted Snape to help him. I still will not believe that Snape is still good. ANd i cant wait until Harry gets too him.