you right, kreatcher wouldnt just give away black stuff, unless he gave it to bella. i mean shes a black, and he loves her. and she probably would have given it back to voldie, unless she wanted to like be more owerful than him and tried to destroy it so she could destroy him..... big fight....sorry im going into some serious conspiracy theory lol.
You might what to explain why it makes sense, other than his initials are R.A.B. because that's the only thing people came up with, besides the fact he was killed by the Dark Lord. Loads of people have been killed by him, so that doesn't mean iRegulus is the mysterious R.A.B. and it didn't even say his middle name. People assume the A is part of his middle name, from his father or something along the lines.
Originally posted by SaratnRegulus had an uncle Alphard, could have gotten the name from him.
You might what to explain why it makes sense, other than his initials are R.A.B. because that's the only thing people came up with, besides the fact he was killed by the Dark Lord. Loads of people have been killed by him, so that doesn't mean iRegulus is the mysterious R.A.B. and it didn't even say his middle name. People assume the A is part of his middle name, from his father or something along the lines.
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
Regulus Black is my guess too. The note did say by the time you read this I will already be dead... but then again I started thinking... Regulus would have had to drink it like Dumbledore and need help.... so what if R.A.B. is three people?Also, I don't think Snape's fully bad. I think DD wanted Snape to kill him, to help Harry.
YES!!! I totally agree with you! I mean I'm not a big fan of Snape but reading the 6th book made it look like he was evil but I couldn't feel him beeing evil maybe as others say Snape had to kill him not only to fulfill Snape's plans but Dumbledores.
This is probaly unlikely but..
What if all this was a setup by Voldemort. Maybe Snape told Voldemort that Dumbledore has been leaving the school secretly. Maybe Voldemort thought that Dumbledore might be after the horcruxes, so he went to every horcrux he has, and removed them and put them in a different place. Maybe he went to the cave took out the real one and put in the fake one. And made up some foney letter and name. Or maybe he purposely put the intials R.A.B. so everyone would think its Regulas.
who knows
Originally posted by DanZeke25
This is probaly unlikely but..What if all this was a setup by Voldemort. Maybe Snape told Voldemort that Dumbledore has been leaving the school secretly. Maybe Voldemort thought that Dumbledore might be after the horcruxes, so he went to every horcrux he has, and removed them and put them in a different place. Maybe he went to the cave took out the real one and put in the fake one. And made up some foney letter and name. Or maybe he purposely put the intials R.A.B. so everyone would think its Regulas.
who knows
thats a bit......................unliely , I mean , think about it . Its not Voldermort's way of operating his plans , its to unlikely
Originally posted by Celestialgirl
YES!!! I totally agree with you! I mean I'm not a big fan of Snape but reading the 6th book made it look like he was evil but I couldn't feel him beeing evil maybe as others say Snape had to kill him not only to fulfill Snape's plans but Dumbledores.
I disagree strongly , because it takes a great amount of hate to kill someone .
Originally posted by Phoenixjust because he's dead it does not mean that he did not exchange the lockets first! He was a death eater after all! anyway Jk Rolling might just be pretending hes dead then he suddenly becomes the new defence against the dark arts teacher in book 7!
Thats what I've been wondering! I was thinking of all the things we've had, and I think it must be someone new...RAB could be Regulus A. Black, but hes dead