The Missing Horcrux (spoiler alert)

Originally posted by sasee tiin
let's say Harry's scar is not a horcrux.
i just thought a little bit about it....how can the aveda kedevra transfer powers? when i rebounded as on harry, how could it leave voldemort's powers, and a connection?
It just doesn't fit to me....im getting more and more sure that the scar has something to do with a hocrux.

Well, I'm glad you are, because nobody else is persuaded.

The Avada Kedavra incantation may not have transferred the powers itself, but the fact that Harry was protected by the greatest of all defenses, love, makes me believe that when Voldemort said the incantation, all elements were not as 'normal'. Therefore it's entirely feasible Voldemort transferred some of his powers into Harry.

yes but remember exactly that a horcrux is a part of Voldemorts SOUL....when we actually witnessed Voldemort sharing his soul it stuck out the back of there head..and a part of your soul is a part of you...so Harry would be part Voldemort...having his thoughts etc. Im sorry i REALLY doubt like am 99.9999999% sure harry is NOT a horcrux...i dont see it as being feasible....and i think thats a little far fetched even for JK.

Originally posted by Syren
Therefore it's entirely feasible Voldemort transferred some of his powers into Harry.

eeehhhh...NO!
we can agree that he transfered some of his powers to Harry, yes, but to his scar in form of a horcrux IMO.
But don't understand me wrong, i'm not sure, it just seems so logic to me, but iguess we will have to wait at least 2 years until we know who's right....

No. You're wrong. You've presented no valid arguments and you continually tell people they can't be right, but have no reasons.

Originally posted by air
yes but remember exactly that a horcrux is a part of Voldemorts SOUL....when we actually witnessed Voldemort sharing his soul it stuck out the back of there head..and a part of your soul is a part of you...so Harry would be part Voldemort...having his thoughts etc. Im sorry i REALLY doubt like am 99.9999999% sure harry is NOT a horcrux...i dont see it as being feasible....and i think thats a little far fetched even for JK.

I think Harry is NOT a Horcrux, just in case you read me wrong 😄

Originally posted by Syren
No. You're wrong. You've presented no valid arguments and you continually tell people they can't be right, but have no reasons.

now I actually sarted wondering how old you are....I have time after time said that it allwould fit perfect because of his connection with LV, and then I asked wether any1 could proove against that.

By the way....noone have valid proove, just to inform you, we will not know until the 7th book....

How old am I? Take a wild guess 🙄

It's not even relevant though, is it...

I guess I just get frustrated with all those members who tell their opinions, don't justify them and then have a go at other people for disagreeing.

i guess....20?
😉 just a wild guess though...

😱 You looked at my profile, cheater 😂

couldn't cross my mind...

Originally posted by sasee tiin
now I actually sarted wondering how old you are....I have time after time said that it allwould fit perfect because of his connection with LV, and then I asked wether any1 could proove against that.

By the way....noone have valid proove, just to inform you, we will not know until the 7th book....

Actually, Dumbledore explained to Harry in the fourth book why some of Voldemort's powers were transferred to him.

As Syren said:

Originally posted by Syren
Well, I'm glad you are, because nobody else is persuaded.

The Avada Kedavra incantation may not have transferred the powers itself, but the fact that Harry was protected by the greatest of all defenses, love, makes me believe that when Voldemort said the incantation, all elements were not as 'normal'. Therefore it's entirely feasible Voldemort transferred some of his powers into Harry.

There's your proof.

Originally posted by hotsauce6548
Actually, Dumbledore explained to Harry in the fourth book why some of Voldemort's powers were transferred to him.

As Syren said:

There's your proof.

yeah!! finally you find the proof!! I'm so glad!!

but seriously, i am perfectly aware of the fact that i very well might be wrong (sorry for long sentence..) It's 50/50 to me..

he can't be a horcux cuz part of his soul couldn't survive in harry. remember in ootp in the ministry of magic voldie tries to posses harry so that dumbledore would kill harry in hopes of killin him? well later dd said that voldie couldn't stand being in harry cuz he's so full of luv. so wat makes u think that his soul can stand it if he can't?

Harry can't be a horcrux because Voldemort is not stupid... It would be idiotic for him to put a part of his soul in someone he has to kill...

Originally posted by Director_Joe
Harry can't be a horcrux because Voldemort is not stupid... It would be idiotic for him to put a part of his soul in someone he has to kill...

glad to see that you have followed the discussion so closely!!

first of all, my entire theory is based upon LV making Harry's scar by an ACCIDENT!
secondly, I'm not talking about harry, but his scar!

Originally posted by polowahine4
he can't be a horcux cuz part of his soul couldn't survive in harry. remember in ootp in the ministry of magic voldie tries to posses harry so that dumbledore would kill harry in hopes of killin him? well later dd said that voldie couldn't stand being in harry cuz he's so full of luv. so wat makes u think that his soul can stand it if he can't?

That's bloody brilliant! Yet more valid proof that Harry can't be a Horcrux. Well done polo clapping

Harry can't be a horcrux, I agree!
but I have suggested that his SCAR (!!!!!) MIGHT be a horcrux.

Harry's scar being a horcrux, and Harry being a horcrux is the same thing.

Its neither of them. And theres no way Voldemort did it by accident.

Originally posted by DanZeke25
Harry's scar being a horcrux, and Harry being a horcrux is the same thing.

Its neither of them. And theres no way Voldemort did it by accident.

😠 of course it's not the same, you...never mind.
If it is the scar, harry will be able to remove it through, for instance, love or something else. If it is harry himself, he would HAVE TO sacrifice himself.

How can he remove his scar?