Here is a theory that I have posted before on Harry being a Horcrux:
I have a question...
Why would Voldemort make Harry a Horcrux? Obviously, the answer would be: Harry would have to kill himself, therefore making it impossible to kill Voldemort, unless they somehow died at the same time. This, however, wouldn't make sense. Harry would have to kill himself, and then the part of the soul in Voldemort would have to be killed.
Now, again, why would Voldemort make Harry a horcrux? Making Harry a Horcrux would mean two things:
1) Voldemort would not be able to kill Harry. This is totally contradicting what Voldemort set out to do, i.e. kill Harry.
and
2) Harry would not be able to kill Voldemort. Now, this is all good for Voldie, and would make sense, but when would he be able to turn Harry into a horcrux? Obviously, it wasn't the night when he tried to kill Harry, because why would he kill Harry if he had made him a horcrux? And, also obviously, it wasn't after he attacked Harry, for he had already 'died' and become a 'spirit.'
So, in turn, making Harry a horcrux would prove to hinder Voldemort--albeit, as well as Harry--and also prove to be impossible, as I said...
UNLESS!
Unless... do you remember when Voldemort regained his body? Wormtail drew blood from Harry. Could this have made Harry a horcrux? It is possible, but once again improbable. Soon after Voldemort regains his body, he duels with Harry, obviously hoping to kill him. Why would he do this? He would be making an unneccessary move, i.e. destroying a part of his soul when killing Harry.
There is one more thing that prevents me to believe that Harry is a horcrux. Throughout the books, Voldemort has tried--on numerous occasions--to kill Harry.
In the first book as Quirrel.
In the second book with the Basilisk.
In the fourth book by dueling with him.
And in the fifth book, by once again dueling with him. (If you call him sending death curses at Harry, who didn't do much back, a duel.)
Killing Harry would destroy the part of Voldie's soul within him, if Harry was a Horcrux. If this was the case, why would Voldemort constantly be trying to kill Harry?
There, I rest my case... for Today. My head hurts.
I think the last Horcrux is Tom Riddles award for service to the school. After all he liked "TROPHIES" did he not? I think when Dumbledore told Harry that, it was a hint from JKR. Oh well I might be wrong. Just my opinion.
But to answer Hotsauce. Voldemort thinks the only one who can stop him is Harry, correct? After all thats the part of the prophecy he heard, that Harry has the power to vanquish the Dark Lord. By making Harry a Horcrux, unless Harry kills himself, Voldemort could potentially never die. Like I said before, Harry fights Voldemort, and kills the dark lord. Due to Harry being a Horcrux, Voldemort still lives. Now the other spectrum is Harry loses and dies to Voldemort. Harry being the one who had the power to vanquish Voldemort is now dead. Voldemort is now potentially immortal since no one else has the power to vanquish him. Correct? anyways Cheers to a good debate, lol and I really dont believe Harry is a Horcrux just like viewing other peoples opinions.
this is all good. But how and when did Tom made Harry horcrux? He never had a chanse to do it. and every time when they met he tried to kill Harry. Why would he try to kill his Horcrux? It doesn't make a sence. He might however, try or had tried to make someone of Harry's close friend a Horcrux, thus ensuring that Potter will not be able to destroy the Horcrux, because of the stupid thing of Love, as the Dark Lord pleases to say.
Originally posted by NightCrawler341ermm.....
It can't be Harry guys... I believe DD said it belongs to Ravenclaw or Gryffindor.... hasn't anyone thought of that? I think the sorting hat is a good idea, but to which did it belong to again?
Originally posted by Saratnoh..yeah..exactly..
Well first of all, the Sorting Hat is for all of the founding houses. They put the brains in the hat, not just Godric, and the Hat doesn't even belong to the Dark Lord. DD says his most prized possessions, meaning they belong to him. And I'm sure, DD has a way of checking if something was a horcrux or not.
and...i know it might be stupid..
but when voldy attacted harry back then first time..
the curse backfired..
so he was as if dead...
don't you think that he had to use one of the horcruxes to come back? as if there is only 6 of them? (one in voldy, 2 destroyed, and one with RAB)
Originally posted by Darth Macabre
I think the last Horcrux is Tom Riddles award for service to the school. After all he liked "TROPHIES" did he not? I think when Dumbledore told Harry that, it was a hint from JKR. Oh well I might be wrong. Just my opinion.
I like the trophy theory! Had had completely forgotten about that! Well done!
The trophy thing is a really good Idea but If Harry Really was the Horcrux it would be truly ingenious. And When Harry found out he would know he would HAVE to die to make sure Voldemort couldn't come back out of him and then Kill himself because he's obessed with ridding the world of Voldemort. Think about it. It's truly ingenious! Because by hindering himself he would berid himself of his greatest threat! Very very smart...
Originally posted by ClovieThat hat was Gryffindors.
ermm.....
Dumbledore said if i remember correctly that there is only one thing that used to belong to Griffindor..and that would be a sword 😕 so Hat it isn't 😕 oh..yeah..exactly..and...i know it might be stupid..
but when voldy attacted harry back then first time..
the curse backfired..
so he was as if dead...
don't you think that he had to use one of the horcruxes to come back? as if there is only 6 of them? (one in voldy, 2 destroyed, and one with RAB)
Originally posted by Darth MacabreSounds good.
I think the last Horcrux is Tom Riddles award for service to the school. After all he liked "TROPHIES" did he not? I think when Dumbledore told Harry that, it was a hint from JKR. Oh well I might be wrong. Just my opinion.But to answer Hotsauce. Voldemort thinks the only one who can stop him is Harry, correct? After all thats the part of the prophecy he heard, that Harry has the power to vanquish the Dark Lord. By making Harry a Horcrux, unless Harry kills himself, Voldemort could potentially never die. Like I said before, Harry fights Voldemort, and kills the dark lord. Due to Harry being a Horcrux, Voldemort still lives. Now the other spectrum is Harry loses and dies to Voldemort. Harry being the one who had the power to vanquish Voldemort is now dead. Voldemort is now potentially immortal since no one else has the power to vanquish him. Correct? anyways Cheers to a good debate, lol and I really dont believe Harry is a Horcrux just like viewing other peoples opinions.