The Missing Horcrux (spoiler alert)

oh...i really didn't pay attention to the Sorting Hat's song...

Yeah neither did I, but I was re reading Goblet last week. Oh well cheers.

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
That hat was Gryffindors.

Maybe its Neville.

I sincerely doubt it though

Originally posted by Clovie
but so was sword.
and Dumbledore said that there was ONE thing

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
It doesn't matter what DD said. The hat belonged to Gryffindor either way, giving it as much possibility of being the Horcrux as anything else.

and i don't see your point here to be exact.
the sorting hat has too much of brains inside it..i think it would be noticeable if there was an extra part of Voldy's soul 😖

Well, haven't you noticed all the warning lately in the songs? Maybe, just maybe, I may be just throwing this out here, the part of Voldemort in him is telling him what is going on with Voldemort. And yes, people have noticed. Also, when was the last time it gave warnings, when Voldemort was terrorizing the world before and while Harry was born till the incident.

bag i never really read those parts with Hat's song carefully bag

but what you've said had a point..though don't you think that someone has checked it if it didn't have any extra magic inside? 😕

Does it specifically have had to belong to Godric himself?

Wait for it.....Harry belongs to Griffindor😱

Not in the literal sense, but since he is in the House, he 'belongs' to Griffindor...

Why wouldn't JKR have told us what the last Horcrux was then, if it wasn't some exciting twist or something. Dumbledore didnt know what the hell the last one was, how would Harry find it without Dumbledore?

Unless Voldemort knows already that he is a Horcrux and maybe lets it slip during a duel or something...something like 'If you kill me now, I'll still have the last part inside you' etc etc...and Harry finds out then..

Or alternatively, if Harry wasnt a Horcrux, if I was Voldemort I'd tell him that he was 😛 Plant some doubt in Harry's mind..make him think he has to kill himself when he doesnt actually need to, that would be funny 😛

Everyone here keeps saying "Voldemort wouldnt make him a Horcrux' etc etc.....what if it happened by accident? If I did it by accident, I'd be thinking 'Shit, better erase that mistake' and try and kill off Harry too.

I cant remember who said it on the last few pages, but I agree....everyone expects the book to be a happy ending and 'oh no Harry cant die because he's the hero' etc etc...its not a fairy tale people. Sirius died, Dumbledore died...the heroes dont always survive.

Are we back on the Harry being a horcrux again? Oh my, I don't think I can take much more. 😱

no. we are thinking if sorting hat canbe one.

Harry ? A Horcruz ? i don't think so .

Originally posted by Clovie
no. we are thinking if sorting hat canbe one.

but don't you think that if it really was one someone would knew?

mmmmm first of all can someone fill me in on the other horcruxes ( Slytherins necklace, Hufflepuffs cup, Marvolos ring) what else is there , other than ur attempts to guess the last one,(harrys scar? doubt it, would make the book seem stupid) the sorting hat? Possibly...

1. diary
2. ring
3. slytherin's locket
4. hufflepuff's cup
5. one part in the Voldy's soul
6.
7.

i forgot 😑

ahh ya the book thing...

..6 .possibly snake 😱

nagini or watever.... dumbledore said that it could have been something of griffindors or ravenclaws too... i think its the hat... unless ravenclaw had a gold toilet bowl or somthing...

i personally thought the hats songs were a little odd/ evil