The Missing Horcrux (spoiler alert)

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
He stole it from me..... get your own stuff!

I have my own stuff, it just doesn't work well typed....

Whatever. I still think its the sorting hat.

The Hat could be one... (I posted that theory somewhere but I can't find it) But how would Riddle (Voldemort) have made it a Horcrux if it's always in Dumbledore's office??? As for the Sword... it had been inside the hat (most likely put there by Griffindor himself) and Voldemort would have never seen it before.

We need to think... Did Dumbledore ever hint at an item that Voldemort had with him that seemed out of place? As if it weren't his?

Originally posted by ~Sir Mist~
1. The same way you accidently f*ck yourself up trying to use a death curse and have it rebound at you.

2. You sure as hell know? The only way you could sure as hell know, is if it came from JKR's mouth or was written by her. Since she hasnt done either, you sure as hell dont know anything 😬

alright fine, i dont know for sure... But I would bet a lot that he isnt a Horcrux.

And i still dont see how you can accidently make someone a Horcrux. You need to use a spell. What did the words accidently slip out of his mouth? no...

and i didnt mean to offend.. sorry if i did

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
JKR said reread the book and you will find out what the missing horcrux is.

Originally posted by Director_Joe
The Hat could be one... (I posted that theory somewhere but I can't find it) But how would Riddle (Voldemort) have made it a Horcrux if it's always in Dumbledore's office??? As for the Sword... it had been inside the hat (most likely put there by Griffindor himself) and Voldemort would have never seen it before.

We need to think... Did Dumbledore ever hint at an item that Voldemort had with him that seemed out of place? As if it weren't his?

Well she actully said that she would bet that one of the careful HBP re-readers would guess correctly in the next week. And she said that a week ago.

exactly.
and someone should re-read it and tell everyone 😄

but she said a careful rereader, and im not a careful reader.. so i wouldnt

I don't think Harry is a horcrux. In HBP, Dumbledore says that when Voldemort went to kill harry and his parents, he intended to use their deaths to make another horcrux. So even if harry was one, he would have to kill himself before he could kill Voldemort, which wouldn't work because then who would kill Voldemort? Since Harry's destined to do it himself. And in response to radarman, Voldemort didn't NEED Harry's blood, he just figured that if they had the same blood in them, than he would be able to possess Harry and touch him without feeling any pain.

it could be the hat because riddle was once in dumbledores office , when he applied for a teaching staff ...dumbledore said to harry tht his image had already changed an he seemed weaker which showed tht voldemort had already split his soul atleast once....riddle could have made the hat a horcrux while he was waiting for dumbledore ...making the horcrux a hat may have been the real reason why riddle returned an not in actual fact to ask for a teaching position

Dumbledore would know if Tom did anything to the hat. I'm rereading it now, and so far I haven't found a thing. She is definitely tricky.

I dont know I still think this statement is gesturing towards Tom Riddles award.

"Lord Voldemort liked to collect trophies, and he preferred objects with a powerful magical history. His pride, his belief in his own superiority, his determination to carve for himself a startling place in magical history; these things suggest to me that Voldemort would have chosen his Horcruxes with some care, favoring objects worty of the honor.z'

I mean think about it, if JKR's going to hide something, why not hide it where it could have a double meaning.

oh well cheers.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
Snape good, Harry not horcrux because he would have to destroy himself before destroying Moldy Voldy.... ain't happenin'.
I agree on that

if sanpe was really good he would have rather killed himself than kill voldermort just like serioussaid hed rather die than betray a friend i think n e one good would do the same

Originally posted by DanZeke25
but she said a careful rereader, and im not a careful reader.. so i wouldnt

Originally posted by kaidaboo
quote: (post)
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
Snape good, Harry not horcrux because he would have to destroy himself before destroying Moldy Voldy.... ain't happenin'.
I agree on that

if sanpe was really good he would have rather killed himself than kill voldermort just like serioussaid hed rather die than betray a friend i think n e one good would do the same

DD knew everything. he kew it was Malfloy. and he did nothing. it has to be some plan 😱 *goes insane*

I'm a careful reader, but with school in less than I week i'm to overworked to have time to read it.

no.
Dumbledore told him to do it.
he didn't want to
he didn't have a choice

DD knew everything. he kew it was Malfloy. and he did nothing. it has to be some plan *goes insane*

well imm sure he new about malfoy it was pretty obvious but why would dumbldore let snape kill him knowin hes the only person voldermorts scared of...and i bet he knew harry would have to avenge his death and i bet he'd rather go and help him rather than let a teen who doesnt know all that much go off by him self to try to killl him

that last post was in responce to clovie

OK!!! wow!!! ...

1.) The hat can't be on because in Dumbledores room... there was no magic.... unless voldmort can do wandless magic??

2.) HOW IN THE WORLD CAN HARRY BE A HORCRUX??!?!?!?!?! i mean really!!!!! why would Voldy split his soul and weaken himself only to kill part of himself!!! WTF???

ok... im a very careful reader , when i want to be, and i don't have school for three weeks.... so I'll read between Band Camp... but i need someone to tell me which Horcruxes we know defintely... ill tell u when ever i get the book back and read it... im letting on of my mom's friends read it! ... ok someone OM and tell me the horcruxes and ill try to find out what the "mystery" one is

Originally posted by kaidaboo
no.
Dumbledore told him to do it.
he didn't want to
he didn't have a choice

DD knew everything. he kew it was Malfloy. and he did nothing. it has to be some plan *goes insane*

well imm sure he new about malfoy it was pretty obvious but why would dumbldore let snape kill him knowin hes the only person voldermorts scared of...and i bet he knew harry would have to avenge his death and i bet he'd rather go and help him rather than let a teen who doesnt know all that much go off by him self to try to killl him

Originally posted by daniels_baby_15
So even if harry was one, he would have to kill himself before he could kill Voldemort, which wouldn't work because then who would kill Voldemort?

Hello? Thats kinda the whole point🙄 Once Harry dies, Voldemort can rule.

Originally posted by daniels_baby_15
Since Harry's destined to do it himself.

And Voldemort heard half the prophecy. God, if someone made a prophecy saying someone was going to end up killing you, you'd want to stop them before they did too..

"Destined" to do something doesnt mean everything turns out good. Neo was 'destined' to stop the war in the Matrix, and see how he did it? Sacraficed himself. See what Agent Smith did? Tried to take over Neo. Same deal here.

Originally posted by SltherinQueenDM
OK!!! wow!!! ...

I think your name should be changed from SltherinQueen to DramaQueen🙄

Honestly, half you people are thick sometimes. This is just like the EP3 forum....stop looking at everything from one point of view 🙄