The Missing Horcrux (spoiler alert)

im not sure if this was brought up(i only read until the 4th page) but the I distinctly remember dumbledore explkaining that scars like that come after big curses are avoided or deflected off something.(he said something along the lines of that). I think it was the 5th book....notsure

I was thinking real kind of hard, and I started wondering wether it was Fawkes because no matter how many times he died, Fawkes would still become alive, but then I slapped myself because it's a stupid idea.

.1.Slytherin's ring

2. Tom Riddle's diary

3.The real Slytherin necklace now in possesion by R.A.B.

4. The cups of Hufflepuff

5. The snake Naiobi

6. The sixth book spoke of something of Gryfidors. Harry Potter became a horcrux when he was almost killed as a baby. In order to defeat Lord Voldemort he will need to bring about his own death to destroy the part of Voldemorts soul that lives within him.

7. The part of Voldemort's soul remains within voldemort. He will need to kill Voldemort and then take his own life in order to defeat him

I thought it would be somewhat interesting if Hogwarts itself turned out to be one...

harry potter isnt a horcrux. it said somewhere that he isn't related to godric gryfindor. and besides if he was one he would have to kill himself THEN kill voldemort because dumbledore said that all the peices must be destroyed before killing the real voldemort.

I have done some careful reading of the Sixth book and come upon what i believe could be a Horcrux, but I'm not sure

pg.215 American Hardback edition

" He turned away again, and was almost at the door when he saw it. Sitting on one of the little spindle-legged tables that supported so many frail-looking silver instruments, was an ugly gold ring set with a large, cracked, black stone."

Now the ring set had Slytherin's ring which is stated by DD a few lines later and i think that the stone could be the other horcrux, I'm probably wrong but I think it's a pretty damn good idea.

after reading many of these posts (not all) a part of me do believe that there is something wit harry's scar, that it is horcrux, while the other part of me think it's not true. But think, he wouldnt need to kill himself nessecarily.....
i think maybe that after hary has killed LV (he thinks he has destroyed all horcruxes...) then the 1/7 soul left inharry's scar will try to take over harrys mind, body etc. but then harry's love would finally destroy the horcrux and remove the scar.....

anyway, I believe that the scar is the most likely horcrux, it would just explain everything

Originally posted by O0oKk
I have done some careful reading of the Sixth book and come upon what i believe could be a Horcrux, but I'm not sure

pg.215 American Hardback edition

" He turned away again, and was almost at the door when he saw it. Sitting on one of the little spindle-legged tables that supported so many frail-looking silver instruments, was an ugly gold ring set with a large, cracked, black stone."

Now the ring set had Slytherin's ring which is stated by DD a few lines later and i think that the stone could be the other horcrux, I'm probably wrong but I think it's a pretty damn good idea.

I think you read that wrong...

'The ring set with a large, cracked, black stone' means that the black stone was part of the ring itself, like if you see a gold ring with a diamond or something on top at a jewelry store, thats what they mean by 'set'.

[QUOTE=4663878]Originally posted by joe4063
[B].1.Slytherin's ring

2. Tom Riddle's diary

3.The real Slytherin necklace now in possession by R.A.B. in possession? or destroyed??

4. The cups of Hufflepuff

5. The snake Naiobi - its Nagini

6. The sixth book spoke of something of Gryffindors - or Ravenclaws? and remember that Dumbledore thinks that one of the only things known to exist of Gryffindors is the sword and NO that is not a horcrux, so its either something of Gryffindors - which we haven't met or dont no yet - or Ravenclaws

7. The part of Voldemort's soul remains within voldemort. He will need to kill Voldemort.

So in destroying of Horcruxes in the order there going to be destroyed:
1) Riddle's Diary XX
2) Marvolos Ring XX
3) I think that perhaps the Necklace is gone X
?) Hufflepuffs Cup
?) Ravenclaw or Gryffindor object
6) Nagini - shes nearly ALWAYS with Voldermort so shell be killed before Voldermort
7) Finally Voldermort

Something i read somewhere in the Leaky/Mugglenet Interview with JK they discussed Dumbledores family - or not as the case was JK wouldnt comment - this just makes me think that perhaps he was a descendant of Gryffindors
JK: 'Dumbledore's family would be a profitable line of inquiry'
MA: His family?
JK: His family, yes
MA: Should we talk about that a little more?
JKR: No but YOU can! [Laughter]

Hogwarts being a Horcrux? Then it would have to be destroyed 🙁

EDIT: Ooops 😮

Originally posted by Sir Mist
Does it specifically have had to belong to Godric himself?

Wait for it.....Harry belongs to Griffindor😱

Not in the literal sense, but since he is in the House, he 'belongs' to Griffindor...

I thought of that but then I figured that it doesn't make conclusive sense as Harry has only been in Gryffindor since he was 11 years old, when has LV had the chance to make Harry a Horcrux since then?

And I like the idea of Tom's trophy being the Horcrux... it's in Hogwart's, right in front of everyone's noses, so it would be a cool twist. LV treasures all of his possessions (such as the trophy) greatly so it's feasible.

hey, i did say i thought I would be wrong. Besides it's just a thought. Everyone else's guess is just as a good as mine, until the next book is out. But It's probably not the creepy rock.

It was a good thought though, it's totally easy to read something a little differently 😄

Voldemort would need to perform a spell on Harry that night, and the only spell he performed was 'Avada Kedavra.' The spell rebounded, and destroyed Voldemort's body... He couldn't have made Harry a horcrux on that night.

Thread Merged!

we don't really no that for sure. Not much witnesses their now are their. I don't believe in the theory, I'm just saying that no one knows what happened. Harry heard some of it and the green flash...other than that...the Dark Lord knows what happened.

Originally posted by Saratn
we don't really no that for sure. Not much witnesses their now are their. I don't believe in the theory, I'm just saying that no one knows what happened. Harry heard some of it and the green flash...other than that...the Dark Lord knows what happened.

Why would he make Harry a Horcrux, and then try to kill him?

Oh I'm against that theory...I'm just pointing out that no witnesses were their to see if the Dark Lord used any more spells on him.

OK HARY IS NOT A HORCUX!!!!!!!!!!!!! jk wouldn't end it w/ voldie all powerful! now i'm not saying that it'll be a happy ending... i think that a lot of the people harry loves most r gonna die... like the weasly's and hermione... but harry would have to kill himself first. in case none of u noticed i'll sum everything up for u! ok dd sayed that voldie made 5 horcuxes before he killed harry's parents cuz the last one was gonna be made from something at there house right? right. but that didn't work so he made nagini his last one. all that dd explains to harry so we know that. and if nagini was the last one that means that harry couldn't have been. and if he was the last horcux he would have to kill himself because wen voldie's spell backfired he stayed alive on the part of his soal that was still inside of him or else he would have had to make another one besides the one he made of nagini. so if u fallow logic all the horcuxes would have to be destroyed before u could kill the last bit of soal inside voldie. end of story!