Originally posted by Bardock42
This is a good question...especially since there is a thread like this...I think the major problem is that no one reported it (I sure as hell didn't)But for the non-believers here's the Thread .....
I know you just ignor ethis cause I don't report BUT THIS ****ING THREAD ALREADY EXISTS.......
Originally posted by Schecter
it doesnt even compare. the technology in star wars is so advanced that they can blow up planets.the end
Bah... That little Death Star was taken out by one kid in one p.o.s. [X-Wing] space-fighter. The ****ing Borg would assimilate the entire S.W. universe. Imagine an army of Borg-Wookies, pure "pwnage".
Originally posted by Robtard
Bah... That little Death Star was taken out by one kid in one p.o.s. [X-Wing] space-fighter. The ****ing Borg would assimilate the entire S.W. universe. Imagine an army of Borg-Wookies, pure "pwnage".
right, but the debate centers around the strength of the federation, not the borg. given the ability of assimilation and time travel, the borg would have been a formittable foe. however the empire would have bitchslapped the federation effortlessly.
also, retarded engineering of the deathstar doesnt take way from the superior technology behind the planet-killing laser.
Originally posted by Schecter
right, but the debate centers around the strength of the federation, not the borg. given the ability of assimilation and time travel, the borg would have been a formittable foe. however the empire would have bitchslapped the federation effortlessly.also, retarded engineering of the deathstar doesnt take way from the superior technology behind the planet-killing laser.
****ing Capt. Kirk and crew managed time travel, but lets not get into that.
The flaws of the Death Star, which is supposed to be the most powerful weapon in the S.W. world are nforgivably ridiculous. First, they leave a hole open in it where one minor shot can destroy it, then they install shields, but have the shield generator on an almost defenseless planet. ****ing retards should have installed it inside the Death Star, duh.
3 T.N.G. Sovereign Class star ships could decimate the Death Star. One warps over and take out the Death Star's shield generator and every single ****ing Ewok from orbit, the other two obliterate it with a combo on photons torpedoes and laser fire afterwards. Picard need not be commanding either ship.
Originally posted by Robtardcompletely flawed.
****ing Capt. Kirk and crew managed time travel, but lets not get into that.The flaws of the Death Star, which is supposed to be the most powerful weapon in the S.W. world are nforgivably ridiculous. First, they leave a hole open in it where one minor shot can destroy it, then they install shields, but have the shield generator on an almost defenseless planet. ****ing retards should have installed it inside the Death Star, duh.
3 T.N.G. Sovereign Class star ships could decimate the Death Star. One warps over and take out the Death Star's shield generator and every single ****ing Ewok from orbit, the other two obliterate it with a combo on photons torpedoes and laser fire afterwards. Picard need not be commanding either ship.
the shield generator was also protected (by itself more or less) from outside bombardment. thats why han and company had to find a way in to blast it from the inside. no amount of proton or even quantum torpedos would have destroyed it.
also, the deathstar's surface cannons would have easily taken out any federation ship. remember that there was a distinct advantage in a one man fighter in that it could run the trench and thus avoid said cannons. since the federation had no such fighters, they wouldnt have been able to stage the same kind of attack.
all this talk of deathstars 1 and 2. how about pitting the enterprise against a super star destroyer? pfffft yea right. tractor beam>>dock>>board>>interrogate>>execute.
Originally posted by Schecter
completely flawed.the shield generator was also protected (by itself more or less) from outside bombardment. thats why han and company had to find a way in to blast it from the inside. no amount of proton or even quantum torpedos would have destroyed it.
also, the deathstar's surface cannons would have easily taken out any federation ship. remember that there was a distinct advantage in a one man fighter in that it could run the trench and thus avoid said cannons. since the federation had no such fighters, they wouldnt have been able to stage the same kind of attack.
all this talk of deathstars 1 and 2. how about pitting the enterprise against a super star destroyer? pfffft yea right. tractor beam>>dock>>board>>interrogate>>execute.
Nein.
A top class Star Fleet craft could decimate the planet, let alone the bunker, it could make a crater where the shield gen sits.
The Super SD/Star Destroyers are extremely formidable no doubt, but like a battleship, their main shortcoming is maneuverability, they rely on sheer power. They also lack shields, correct? The tractor beams are a plus, but how do they fare on vessels ith shields? How many can they "lock" onto at once? Even the Borg with their technology had trouble on more than one occasion holding onto a S.T. vessel.
Star fleet vessels have shields on every ship, a major advantage, some also have cloaking capabilities. Transporters are also a huge plus, what would happen if 50 armed Klingons transported into a Star Destroyers command center and went apeshit like they do?
Also of note, the Federation is not only the Earth ships, they have many worlds that make up the Federation, the Vulcans and the Klingons being two heavy hitters.
If you break it down, Star Trek has more advantages in a space battle, regardless of which franchise you like, love or hate more.