Originally posted by Mizukage YodaBut a Jedi nonetheless. Your perception of what makes a Jedi is second to who was a Jedi. I suppose Obi-Wan wasn't a Jedi when he fought Maul, either.
Exacta! He should be higher that #8, but LS Anakin...I have little regard for considering he does alot of things during the Clone Wars that stray very close to the Dark Side. In almost all of his conflicts they end with him winning by strutting closely with the DS, which brings me back to the conclusion the LS Anakin without ever skirting with the DS is #8
Ex: like in his Dooku battle, he was getting pwnd b4 skirting with the DS.
Originally posted by Mizukage YodaJedi Padawn or Jedi Knight, still Jedi. Anakin skirted the Dark, he didn't fall to it, or succumb to it. And he certainly showed far more impressive duelling skills as of ROTS than Mundi, Shaak, or Koon.
A Dark Jedi more like it.
But Obi-Wan was a Padawan and doesn't skirt with the DS after becoming a knight
Originally posted by Faunus
Anakin above Yoda? No Sora Bulq? Saesee Tinn above Kit Fisto, Qui-Gon, Shaak Ti, and Agen Kolar?...
Sora Bulq became a Dark Jedi. So, he gets disqualified. You're right about Saesee. I should've put Kit over him. The rest, I probably stand by. I was distracted by Supernatural. lol
Depa went rogue, too.
And no, Saesee should be at the bottom of that list at best. His credentials come from an N-canon statement from a character who is fallible to begin with. Kit Fisto has actually demonstrated his immense skill, as has Agen Kolar, who also has the benefit of being proclaimed by the narrator to be one of the greatest "bladesbeings" ever produced by the Jedi Order.
Originally posted by Faunus
Depa went rogue, too.And no, Saesee should be at the bottom of that list at best. His credentials come from an N-canon statement from a character who is fallible to begin with. Kit Fisto has actually demonstrated his immense skill, as has Agen Kolar, who also has the benefit of being proclaimed by the narrator to be one of the greatest "bladesbeings" ever produced by the Jedi Order.
Depa came back though...didn't she? Saesee is one of the best (maybe the best) telepaths in the Order. In a duel, that's got to count for something. But like I said, I screwed up with Kit being below Saesee. Shaak Ti might also be above, simply based on her impressive speed. *shrug*
Originally posted by Faunus
Depa went rogue, too.And no, Saesee should be at the bottom of that list at best. His credentials come from an N-canon statement from a character who is fallible to begin with. Kit Fisto has actually demonstrated his immense skill, as has Agen Kolar, who also has the benefit of being proclaimed by the narrator to be one of the greatest "bladesbeings" ever produced by the Jedi Order.
Complete Visual Dictionary cites all four of those who attempted to arrest Palpatine as "celebrated swordsmen." And the official databank lauds all of their prowess.
So... um... as Kevin Spacey would say... "WRONG!"