Listen 😠 Dumbeldore is not going to come back. Maybe if you read the book again you wil find out. He did not make a Horcrux.
At the bottom of page 583 'The Phoenix Lament'
In silence they ascended the moving spiral staircase and entered the circular office. He did not know what he had expected: that the room would be draped in black, perhaps, or even that Dumbledore's body might be lying there. In fact, it looked almost exactly as it had done when he and Dumbeldore had left it mere hours previously: the silver instruments whirring and puffing on their spindle-legged tables, Gryffindor's sword in it's glass case gleaming in the moonlight, the Sorting Hat on the shelf behind the desk. But Fawkes's perch stood empty: he was still crying his lament to the grounds. And a new portrait had joined the ranks of the dead headmasters and headmistresses of Hogwarts ... Dumbledore was slumbering in a golden frame over the desk, his half-moon spectacles perched upon his crooked nose, looking peaceful and untroubled.
After glancing once at this portrait, Professor McGonagall made and odd movement as though steeling herself, than rounded the desk to look at Harry, her face taut and lined.
Oh and i dont think Dumbledore will be a great use to Harry in the next book.
ok dudes. dumbledore is NOT dead.
the avada does not send you flying back into the air.
snape was sayin avada kedavra and didnt mean it. REMEMBER WHAT MOODY SAYS, AND BELLATRIX, YOU NEED TO MEAN THEM. but he was nonverbally saying something else, thats why dumbledore flew back.
fawkes probably caught him as he fell or he did a simple charm to make himself safe from the impact.
thats why nonverbal spells were mentioned so much in this book.
snape was angry because he didnt want to hurt dumbledore when he sent him flying back.,
hagrid heard them arguing that snape didnt want to do somthing but dumby said he had to.
about the unbreakable vow, who said there wasnt a time limit.
he did everything he could to "help" draco but he wouldnt let snape help him.
he obviously lied to narcissa and bellatrix after he looked into her mind since it was all she could think about and pretended voldy told him about the plan. so the plan he and dumbledore made would work, so snape would be trusted by voldy when he """"kills"""" dumbledore, remaining a spy for dumby ..
tell me if u need more convincing
horcruxes are made with the supreme act of evil i.e killing
i don't think it's a supreme act of evil to kill someone in self defence, acidentally killing someone or killing someone who is a danger to society. it's got to be spiteful, pre meditated and intended for personal gain
thats my thought
ok dudes. dumbledore is NOT dead.
the avada does not send you flying back into the air.
snape was sayin avada kedavra and didnt mean it. REMEMBER WHAT MOODY SAYS, AND BELLATRIX, YOU NEED TO MEAN THEM. but he was nonverbally saying something else, thats why dumbledore flew back.
fawkes probably caught him as he fell or he did a simple charm to make himself safe from the impact.
thats why nonverbal spells were mentioned so much in this book.
snape was angry because he didnt want to hurt dumbledore when he sent him flying back.,
hagrid heard them arguing that snape didnt want to do somthing but dumby said he had to.
about the unbreakable vow, who said there wasnt a time limit.
he did everything he could to "help" draco but he wouldnt let snape help him.
he obviously lied to narcissa and bellatrix after he looked into her mind since it was all she could think about and pretended voldy told him about the plan. so the plan he and dumbledore made would work, so snape would be trusted by voldy when he """"kills"""" dumbledore, remaining a spy for dumby ..
nice theory, i guess we'll have to see when book 7 comes out
October Debate: The Mystery Surrounding Dumbledores Death
This debate can branch off to many different parts, so I want us to explore those different avenues. So the mystery behind Dumbledores death. What did you think of Dumbeldore dying? Did he become an Horcrux? Here are a few more questions to explore provided by the lovely hhhhr:
Originally posted by hhhhr
did ddor became a horcrux? was that the curse on the ring? could it be the reason for his death by snape? since snape was the only one aware of it? and didn't ddor and snape had an argument about something snape was asked to do but he didn't want to do it? could the task be killing ddor? sorry but his death is bugging me. oh and yes i agree with the other guy, did ddor have a horcrux?
So let's get to it! I'll start off with my thoughts:
Personally, I thought Dumbeldore's death was wasted and predictable. I knew when JK killed Sirius that Dumbledore was the next to die. JK wants to kill everyone whose close to Harry to see how Harry will deal with his problems alone, Sirius his father-figure, Dumbledore his mentor and friend. Secondly, I hated that she did it! Dumbledore pleading to Snape? C'mon now! How low can we get?
I was hoping for some type of twist, like maybe Dumbledore really isn't dead and faked his death for some really good reason. As for Dumbledore being an horcrux, I'm not sure I go for that. If killing people is the only way to get an horcrux, then I'd say no, Dumbledore doesn't have one. Then again, we don't know if Dumbledore ever killed someone before. . .it could be for self denfense, I dunno.
Your thoughts?