Just a random thought i just had.....what if dumbledore knew what the potion was ..the one he drank lookin for the horcrux ...maybe it was immortality potion?? thts y he let snape kill him and the avada kedavra curse interacted with the potion an thats why dumbledore flew back but he fell from a height so he died anyway ...which makes it kinda pointless but anyway it was a quick thought that popped into my head thought i would share it even though it sucks
Originally posted by jessblack
Has anyone realised how many Pheonix references JK has put in the book? eg. Order of the Pheonix, DD's pet Pheonix and pheonixs come back from the dead, they rise from the flames and DD was cremated and harry did think that he might have seen a pheonix flying out from the fire......
Originally posted by jessblack
Has anyone realised how many Pheonix references JK has put in the book? eg. Order of the Pheonix, DD's pet Pheonix and pheonixs come back from the dead, they rise from the flames and DD was cremated and harry did think that he might have seen a pheonix flying out from the fire......
OMG, what a nice brand new original idea. And i haven't mentioned that like 5 times in this thread already!! Grrrrr
Well, at least someone else is thinking about this idea. Now maybe others will share their thoughts.....
well my opinion was that perhaps dumbledore had done something like make a double of himself...because, it was very strange situation for three reasons 1.dumbledore told harry he needed his invisibility cloak for what...just to let madame rosmerta no that he was goin somewhere alone...yeah right! 2.dumbledore froze harry while he knew that draco was the only one coming...harry could have taken him! 3.snape trust has always been a debatable isue...but i dont beleive that dumbledore is so trusting that he would not see that snape was in cohorts with the dark side...it was a scam!...so in my opinion i beleive dumbledor did this to strengthen harry's desire to desroy the dark arts and v...v..oldemorts (twitches) followers.so maybe if harry wanted to go after snape and voldy he will want to be stronger AND want to collect the horocruxes
i just thought of somthing some one was telling me that you couldent aperate in school.... ok.... i just got through reading that the kids are having lessons in school..... the reson this came up is i thought that mybe DD would still be alive... and that he aperiated out of the cofin at his funeral by taking down the aperate charm surounding the school ... the reply was y would DD let the protection of the school down, that death eaters would be all over them... but if he let it down for the students to learn how to aperate then they would have done it then.... just a radom idea.. also if death eater came to that big of a funeral it would be a death wish....
yeah the guys dead...but i think there will be references about him in the next book ...phoenix...portrait ...etc and so on..i think hes dead but i think he is still going to play a part in the next book dead or alive?? (possible harry potter 7 title) harry potter dead or alive!!(its probs not jus messin around tho)
Originally posted by Solo
That explains perfectly why Dumbledore was in his casket.
There's something strange going on for sure.
okay! DUMBLEDORE IS ****** DEAD!!!!! if your saying he faced dead cause he had a horcrux, then why does he have to know all about it in book 6? why did he and harry studied voldemort and his horcrux when he already had it on his mind? and people, maybe the reason he chose to die is yet to be revealed and im pretty sure its a good one. snape didnt betray him, he could be following orders from dumbledore since the very beggining. remember when dumbledore's PLEADING? he's pleading for snape to obey his order's and that is to KILL HIM!!!
yeah we all know that its obvious...
dumbledore let snape kill him because he knew that draco couldnt kill him... snape had to .. in order to save draco
dumbledore would not let a student die through his cause ..(even if that student is an evil ****) snape told dumbledore about dracos mission to kill dumbledore and tolt him about how he made the unbreakable vow! so dumbledore told him that if the situation arises that snape must kill him to protect draco!!