Scarlet Witch (current) vs. Phoenix Force Jean

Started by Whirlysplatt26 pages

Originally posted by Creshosk
Why should I have to if you're not?

All you're doing is attacking GS.

not at all - I am merely pointing out Demi's arguments are sounder and better thought out 🙂

Anyway Smithers back to critically analysing GS's poor efforts at rebuttal imo 🙂 on second thoughts time for bed.

Demi you are a classic you and CC, ill adelph, Scarlet Spider, Leonidas, Zeph C ,Olympian are my best debate pics - at leat your the most logical guys and the least emotional.

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
not at all - I am merely pointing out Demi's arguments are sounder and better thought out 🙂
Only because they attack phoenix and you hate the phoenix.

After all you thought that someone calling her a testicle was a good point, and that "phoenix suxks" was a good point.

That alone destroyed your credibility in this area. You hate the character so you are ALWAYS going to say that ANY point that attacks phoenix is well thought out.

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
Anyway Smithers back to critically analysing GS's poor efforts at rebuttal imo 🙂

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

Your opinion isn't good enough herebecause you are commenting on facts beoing flung back and forth, and that's as stupid as saying in my opinion water is made out of solid carbon. . .

Originally posted by Creshosk
Only because they attack phoenix and you hate the phoenix.

After all you thought that someone calling her a testicle was a good point, and that "phoenix suxks" was a good point.

That alone destroyed your credibility in this area. You hate the character so you are ALWAYS going to say that ANY point that attacks phoenix is well thought out.

Your opinion isn't good enough herebecause you are commenting on facts beoing flung back and forth, and that's as stupid as saying in my opinion water is made out of solid carbon. . .

🙄 🙂 off to bed now🙂

Superb thread 🙂

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Demi 🍺

GS was owned Cresh

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
🙄 🙂 off to bed now🙂

Superb thread 🙂

Yeah, it attacks phoenix, of course it's "superb" in your opinion. 🙄

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt

GS was owned Cresh
The opinion of someone who hates GS doesn't count I'm affriad. . . Though I'm not commenting on this thread. I too would be pissed if someone started celebrating Jubilee going away. . .

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
Demi you are a classic you and CC, ill adelph, Scarlet Spider, Leonidas, Zeph C ,Olympian are my best debate pics - at leat your the most logical guys and the least emotional.
How very elitest of you, hypocrite. 🙂

}s

Originally posted by Creshosk
How very elitest of you, hypocrite. 🙂

not really I am leaving this forum this week 🙂

and its not in a thread about best etc. Its in a Phoenix thread so no one will read it.

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

Keep looking at those web sites Smithers 🙂

Originally posted by demigawd
I never said it wasn't multiversal. But that still doesn't mean Phoenix could stop ANY reality altering. She was able to repair the M'Kraan Crystal, which closed the door between realities, as Japh said. That's not nearly the same or as impressive as fixing reality of her own power, which she didn't do. It's similar to someone telling you to close the door to your house or a burgular will come in and kill you. You closing the door isn't the same as killing the burgular, even though you foiled the burgular by preventing him from coming in. It doesn't say anything about your power to stop the burgular, just about your power to grab a knob and push it shut. It just so happened that Phoenix had the set of keys to lock the Crystal. She gets no credit for doing her job. Sorry!

You're missing the point m'boy - Wanda's tampering unleashed a chaos wave that CIRCUMVENTED the M'Kraan Crystal. While Phoenix closed up the door to protected reality, Wanda was the burgular who came through the window and JACKED Phoenix's house. And there isn't a thing Phoenix did about it.

The bigger point here is that Wanda casually unleashed a wave that will destroy creation. Wanda isn't a broken crystal...ain't no stoppin it. Unlike the M'Kraan Crystal, which is simply an object, Wanda doesn't have to create a leak that slowly works its way up the spiral of creation. If she wanted to, she could unleash chaos waves that instantly undo everything....including the White Hot Room. The only reason it hasn't happened is because she has a very specific task in mind.

So I concede. It IS ridiculous and pointless to compare the two - Wanda is so far beyond the Crystal it's ridiculous. 😉

Sure, if that reactor switch was on your arm and you could flip it at any time and nobody can do anything about it (least of all Phoenix). It makes you one bad ass janitor.

So there are TWO different ways Phoenix can get owned?!?? Sweet!

No, according to Roma it WAS the entire 616 reality. That's why Ronan and other intergalactic beings were taking part in the thing. In the Thunderbolts, Magneto forged a relationship with the Shi'ar and the Kree and actually helped to bring some peace between the two when he joined up with them to fight, I believe, Galactus. So clearly it wasn't confined to Earth. Ronan and Genis made an appearance to confirm this.

Something she could do at any time she wants if she chose to, which is the point that still stands at the end of your essays. And that would be it. The end of everything...including Phoenix.

Uh huh.

reposted to highlight genius 🙂

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
not really I am leaving this forum this week 🙂

and its not in a thread about best etc. Its in a Phoenix thread so no one will read it.

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

Keep looking at those web sites Smithers 🙂

What websites?

Welcome to McDonald's
Corporate site for the Golden Arches serving such favorites as Egg McMuffin and
Big Mac sandwiches and french fries for lunch and dinner.
www.mcdonalds.com/ - 16k Cached - Similar pages
Search - Corporate - Countries/Markets - Privacy Policy
More results from www.mcdonalds.com »

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
jgg

Omega point

Kabbalah etc etc right..........

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

Reposted to highlight the bitterness.

Originally posted by Creshosk
What websites?

Welcome to McDonald's
Corporate site for the Golden Arches serving such favorites as Egg McMuffin and
Big Mac sandwiches and french fries for lunch and dinner.
www.mcdonalds.com/ - 16k Cached - Similar pages
Search - Corporate - Countries/Markets - Privacy Policy
More results from www.mcdonalds.com »

reposted to highlight your "friendship to GS"

Originally posted by Creshosk
Reposted to highlight the bitterness.

You know websites where the girls that look like Jubilee 😉 whatever floats your boat mate - your just full of suprises 🙂 goodnight

Keep the faith 😄

Stay Whirly 😮‍💨

Originally posted by demigawd
I never said it wasn't multiversal. But that still doesn't mean Phoenix could stop ANY reality altering. She was able to repair the M'Kraan Crystal, which closed the door between realities, as Japh said. That's not nearly the same or as impressive as fixing reality of her own power, which she didn't do. It's similar to someone telling you to close the door to your house or a burgular will come in and kill you. You closing the door isn't the same as killing the burgular, even though you foiled the burgular by preventing him from coming in. It doesn't say anything about your power to stop the burgular, just about your power to grab a knob and push it shut. It just so happened that Phoenix had the set of keys to lock the Crystal. She gets no credit for doing her job. Sorry!

You're missing the point m'boy - Wanda's tampering unleashed a chaos wave that CIRCUMVENTED the M'Kraan Crystal. While Phoenix closed up the door to protected reality, Wanda was the burgular who came through the window and JACKED Phoenix's house. And there isn't a thing Phoenix did about it.

The bigger point here is that Wanda casually unleashed a wave that will destroy creation. Wanda isn't a broken crystal...ain't no stoppin it. Unlike the M'Kraan Crystal, which is simply an object, Wanda doesn't have to create a leak that slowly works its way up the spiral of creation. If she wanted to, she could unleash chaos waves that instantly undo everything....including the White Hot Room. The only reason it hasn't happened is because she has a very specific task in mind.

So I concede. It IS ridiculous and pointless to compare the two - Wanda is so far beyond the Crystal it's ridiculous. 😉

Sure, if that reactor switch was on your arm and you could flip it at any time and nobody can do anything about it (least of all Phoenix). It makes you one bad ass janitor.

So there are TWO different ways Phoenix can get owned?!?? Sweet!

No, according to Roma it WAS the entire 616 reality. That's why Ronan and other intergalactic beings were taking part in the thing. In the Thunderbolts, Magneto forged a relationship with the Shi'ar and the Kree and actually helped to bring some peace between the two when he joined up with them to fight, I believe, Galactus. So clearly it wasn't confined to Earth. Ronan and Genis made an appearance to confirm this.

Something she could do at any time she wants if she chose to, which is the point that still stands at the end of your essays. And that would be it. The end of everything...including Phoenix.

Uh huh.

reposted to get back on topic 😄

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
reposted to highlight your "friendship to GS"

You know websites where the girls that look like Jubilee 😉 whatever floats your boat mate - your just full of suprises 🙂 goodnight

Keep the faith 😄

Stay Whirly 😮‍💨

🤨

You mean photo manipulations? or lookalikes? 😕

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
reposted to get back on topic 😄
Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
jgg

Omega point

Kabbalah etc etc right..........

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

Reposted to highlight the bitterness.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Reposted to highlight the bitterness.

you see you want this thread to be about me 🙂

Its not I know your obsessed with me - but this is Demis moment his the one who crushed GS on page 4. 🙂

Your the one who's bitter imo being in GS's shadow never getting much of a mention in best debater etc. despite trying real hard🙂

its cool🙂

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
you see you want this thread to be about me 🙂

Its not I know your obsessed with me - but this is Demis moment his the one who crushed GS on page 4.

No, I want to point out how your bais is of conflicting interest.

Originally posted by Creshosk
No, I want to point out how your bais is of conflicting interest.

Well its pretty weird because I post and you always post after me🙂

its cool so you fancy me 🙂

no biggie Smithers, GS will get jealous

conflict of interest you only want to rack up the pages past GS's defeat at Demi's hands for you master 😂

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

its cool I'll ignore you and just post the link to page 4 in answer to your personal attacks on my character 🙂

Originally posted by demigawd
I never said it wasn't multiversal. But that still doesn't mean Phoenix could stop ANY reality altering. She was able to repair the M'Kraan Crystal, which closed the door between realities, as Japh said. That's not nearly the same or as impressive as fixing reality of her own power, which she didn't do. It's similar to someone telling you to close the door to your house or a burgular will come in and kill you. You closing the door isn't the same as killing the burgular, even though you foiled the burgular by preventing him from coming in. It doesn't say anything about your power to stop the burgular, just about your power to grab a knob and push it shut. It just so happened that Phoenix had the set of keys to lock the Crystal. She gets no credit for doing her job. Sorry!

Well actually the the strands that held this multiversal effect had come apart at the seams so Jean had to knit them back together again and re-energise the strands. So while i enjoyed your analogy its really not the appropriate. Its more like a snapped cable causing a suspension bridge to fall apart and you grabbing both ends, pulling the bridge together and tying the cable up.

Originally posted by demigawd
You're missing the point m'boy - Wanda's tampering unleashed a chaos wave that CIRCUMVENTED the M'Kraan Crystal. While Phoenix closed up the door to protected reality, Wanda was the burgular who came through the window and JACKED Phoenix's house. And there isn't a thing Phoenix did about it.

No Wandas more like a gossip on the bus chatting away loudly about her rich friends who are going away for the weekend leaving the mansion unattended. As a result of her actions a lowlife on the bus turns burglar and breaks into the mansion. See the difference?

Originally posted by demigawd
The bigger point here is that Wanda casually unleashed a wave that will destroy creation. Wanda isn't a broken crystal...ain't no stoppin it. Unlike the M'Kraan Crystal, which is simply an object, Wanda doesn't have to create a leak that slowly works its way up the spiral of creation. If she wanted to, she could unleash chaos waves that instantly undo everything....including the White Hot Room. The only reason it hasn't happened is because she has a very specific task in mind.

You're still talking as if the chaos wave is Wandas power. It isnt. Its a result of Wandas tamperings so her causing chaos waves isnt impressive in terms of power. Its impressive in terms of the amount of mayhem and destruction her actions have resulted in but the fact that she set off a chain reaction makes it less impressive than a number of Phoenixes feats. Yes she could consciously disrupt a dimensional barrier to cause a chaos wave but then so could any decent reality warper by the looks of things. Its impressive but the fact that Roma says the reality warp is global in size suggests shes no more powerful than a cube being and therefore as aforementioned a number of cosmics could do the same thing.

Originally posted by demigawd
So I concede. It IS ridiculous and pointless to compare the two - Wanda is so far beyond the Crystal it's ridiculous. 😉

How so? Your level of understanding wildly fluctuates from thread to thread my friend. 😉

The crystal is a multiversal reset switch at the centre of creation. The results of Wandas actions can easily be accomplished by any old lowlife who fractures the crystal. Hence the need for a guardian. (Jahf) Wanda instead of taking the crystal route initiated the collapse of the multiversal elsewhere. As its not her own power directly collapsing the multiverse shes hardly greater than it. Thats strange logic Demi.

Originally posted by demigawd
Sure, if that reactor switch was on your arm and you could flip it at any time and nobody can do anything about it (least of all Phoenix). It makes you one bad ass janitor.

Nope if because thats still to direct. The chaos waves arent derived from Wanda. Its more like her at any given time having a bucket of water to throw over the reactor controls setting off an explosion.

Also considering Phoenix telekinetically reformed the 616 reality in issue 154 of New X-men and the fact that she makes creation cyclically i beg to differ my friend.

Originally posted by demigawd
No, according to Roma it WAS the entire 616 reality. That's why Ronan and other intergalactic beings were taking part in the thing. In the Thunderbolts, Magneto forged a relationship with the Shi'ar and the Kree and actually helped to bring some peace between the two when he joined up with them to fight, I believe, Galactus. So clearly it wasn't confined to Earth. Ronan and Genis made an appearance to confirm this.

The chaos wave wandas tamperings set off must have altered reality in its wake then as the scan below clearly states the alteration was global in scale:

Although the explanation for the alien races could be that factions were in the vicinity and therefore caught up in the reality warp. Either way Wanda outrightly altered reality on a global scale but her tamperings ruptured reality causing a chaos wave which itself not only disrupted reality in its wake but also began to collapse it.

Originally posted by demigawd
Something she could do at any time she wants if she chose to, which is the point that still stands at the end of your essays. And that would be it. The end of everything...including Phoenix.

Considering my baby cannot die id love to hear your explanation on how this could happen. Wanda is at the end of the day is merely setting off a chain reaction. Its not her own power, you're making it sound like it is. Even Legion has caused reality to disrupt like this by merely tampering with the crystal. Id understand your point if the chaos wave was inherent to Wanda but it isnt. Shes merely disrupted a dimensional barrier. So whats to stop any other cosmic from doing that? Changes nothing. As stated the alteration took place on a global scale and its botched execution resulted in chaos waves.

Originally posted by demigawd
Uh huh.

Uh huh [B ✅ /B] 😛

Originally posted by Whirlysplatt
Well its pretty weird because I post and you always post after me🙂

thats some hard on for me you have 🙂

its cool so you fancy me 🙂

no biggie Smithers, GS will get jealous

conflict of interest you only want to rack up the pages past GS's defeat at Demi's hands for you master 😂

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

its cool I'll ignore you and just post the link to page 4 in answer to your personal attacks on my character 🙂