Captain America vs Batman(no shield-no gadgets)

Originally posted by namorsubby
he's more clever. more battle savvy.

That's just it, what in feats leads anyone to believe cap has an obvious edge physically? besides a non-canon appearance and some statement from a single author I mean.

idk what he'll bring, but he has 127 different styles to choose from.

His feats are generally better because his opponents are. I'll go from them tommorrow. Also Caps rogue gallery would murde Batmans.

It might be one author but three authors obvoulsy think that Cap wins.

Originally posted by Deadline
His feats are generally better because his opponents are.

Originally posted by Deadline
Also Caps rogue gallery would murde Batmans.

no

Originally posted by namorsubby
no.

no

hahaha this is gonna be fun.

His opponents aren't generally better because Bruce fights and defeats well known grade A superhuman foes all the time.

and Yeah, I'm sure He'd have a hell of a hard time with Batroc the Leaper.lol

but seriously though, some of the most powerful villians in the DCU have been gunning for Batman for a long time. He has nothing to fear in Cap's Rogue Gallery, He plays with the Big boys.

Originally posted by namorsubby
His opponents aren't generally better because Bruce fights and defeats well known grade A superhuman foes all the time.

Stop strawmanning.

Originally posted by namorsubby

and Yeah, I'm sure He'd have a hell of a hard time with Batroc the Leaper.lol

Damn straight.

Originally posted by namorsubby

but seriously though, some of the most powerful villians in the DCU have been gunning for Batman for a long time. He has nothing to fear in Cap's Rogue Gallery, He plays with the Big boys.

*ahem* Im not arguing that he couldn't beat Caps rogues gallery im saying they are better. Red Skull is better than Ras and Joker for starters.

Zasz seems like a chump so is firefly. Two-Face and Pengun tend to use plans that revolve around goons and none of them can fight.

I hope that Batroc comment wasn't serious. If it was we can just stop right here.

BTW, how do you think cap would fair against, oh let's say, Clayface? or Grundy, who's listed as a Batman rogue.

Originally posted by namorsubby
I hope that Batroc comment wasn't serious. If it was we can just stop right here.

Damn straight it was. What Batman is going to wipe the floor with Batroc? Batroc is less skilled than Bane or Ras?

Originally posted by namorsubby

BTW, how do you think cap would fair against, oh let's say, Clayface? or Grundy, who's listed as a Batman rogue.

Note sure about Clayface and im not sure if Grundy is even a Batman villain..I don't think he is but Caps dealt with people like that before. Lets not get amensia and pretend that lots of Batman villains are weak genuises that get other people to do dirty work.

Riddler
Joker
Ventroliquist
Two-Face(not that weak)
Penguin
Scarecrow (knows a little martial arts)
Mad Hatter

Originally posted by namorsubby

idk what he'll bring, but he has 127 different styles to choose from.

this statement says ' Batman will find a way ' GTFO with that sh!t.

Do you think if Tito Ortiz went away and learned Kung-Fu, that it would help him regain the UFC title? Hell no. More styles i understand, but if im honest..how many ways can you throw a punch? And how many of those ways do you think will catch Steve by suprise? Steve can adapt. Batman is hardly going to start using Drunken Boxing..or frickin kapoeira. And even if he does, Cap has prolly seen it all before.

Originally posted by Deadline
Damn straight it was. What Batman is going to wipe the floor with Batroc? Batroc is less skilled than Bane or Ras?

but seriously though, if you believe that, there's no need to even attempt Batman related discussion with you.

Originally posted by Juk3n
this statement says ' Batman will find a way ' GTFO with that sh!t.

Do you think if Tito Ortiz went away and learned Kung-Fu, that it would help him regain the UFC title? Hell no. More styles i understand, but if im honest..how many ways can you throw a punch? And how many of those ways do you think will catch Steve by suprise? Steve can adapt. Batman is hardly going to start using Drunken Boxing..or frickin kapoeira. And even if he does, Cap has prolly seen it all before.

i love batman i mean i have like an entire shrine to him...(im 22 with a batman shrine...go ahead start with the jokes) but i don't think batman wins....although with his gadgets he wins imo no doubt.

Originally posted by namorsubby

BTW, how do you think cap would fair against, oh let's say, Clayface? or Grundy, who's listed as a Batman rogue.

Batman beats Clayface in H2H? Cos if he can , then so can Cap.
Batman beats Grundy in H2H? Cos if he can, then so can Cap.

Does Batman do the above with gear and prep? Cos if he does, GTFO!

Originally posted by BlackZero30x
i love batman i mean i have like an entire shrine to him...(im 22 with a batman shrine...go ahead start with the jokes) but i don't think batman wins....although with his gadgets he wins imo no doubt.

hehehe you are 22 with a Batman shrine.... 😛

Nothing wrong with that. I have Batman Boxers.

Pink ones, booyah!!

Originally posted by Juk3n
Batman beats Clayface in H2H? Cos if he can , then so can Cap.
Batman beats Grundy in H2H? Cos if he can, then so can Cap.

Does Batman do the above with gear and prep? Cos if he does, GTFO!

true

Originally posted by Warlord
hehehe you are 22 with a Batman shrine.... 😛

😮 i know let me paint you a picture.

at the top is an Arkhamn Asylum and dark night posters.

directly below that is my return of bruce wayne comics in plastic backings with stand up displays. at the sides i have the dark knight special collectors edition.(the one that's shaped like his mask).

and batman animated series movies lined up in the back round.
below all this i have a batman place mat the special edition arkham asylum game with batarang (which everything is centered around)

batman ring,pin and Gotham Knight movie....laying beside the arkham asylum journal. a belly washers(batman edition),batman pes and a batmobile hot wheels....all beside my Ace the Bathound........

not to mention my batman GN's

EDIT: a batman dagger to...
😮

Originally posted by Juk3n
Batman beats Clayface in H2H? Cos if he can , then so can Cap.
Batman beats Grundy in H2H? Cos if he can, then so can Cap.

Does Batman do the above with gear and prep? Cos if he does, GTFO!

If he does, so what? Can cap with his gear/prep?

Originally posted by BlackZero30x
😮 i know let me paint you a picture.

at the top is an Arkhamn Asylum and dark night posters.

directly below that is my return of bruce wayne comics in plastic backings with stand up displays. at the sides i have the dark knight special collectors edition.(the one that's shaped like his mask).

and batman animated series movies lined up in the back round.
below all this i have a batman place mat the special edition arkham asylum game with batarang (which everything is centered around)

batman ring,pin and Gotham Knight movie....laying beside the arkham asylum journal. a belly washers(batman edition),batman pes and a batmobile hot wheels....all beside my Ace the Bathound........

not to mention my batman GN's

EDIT: a batman dagger to...
😮

damn wtf... 🤣

Originally posted by Juk3n
Batman beats Clayface in H2H? Cos if he can , then so can Cap.
Batman beats Grundy in H2H? Cos if he can, then so can Cap.

Does Batman do the above with gear and prep? Cos if he does, GTFO!

Originally posted by namorsubby
Simply saying if Bats can cap can is short of an itelligent response.

If he does, so what? Can cap with his gear/prep?

Point is, you're arguing Batman and Cap rogues, well..obviously for H2H thread you gotta argue the rogues that Batman beats in MELEE for it to be relevent. Dontyerhtink? Naming rogues Batman tackled with the aid of his resources is kinda...

well, im sure you get the point.

So, Batman rogues that he's handled in Melee that Cap couldnt?