Captain America vs Batman(no shield-no gadgets)

Started by KillboBaggins220 pages

Batman is not smarter sorry... his bio say's he is the worlds greatest detective, Wayne technologies play's a huge part in designing his toys between mastering 127 fighting styles and fighting crime AND honing his detective skills I doubt he had time to hit the books that much. However being the worlds greatest detective should help him piece together how cap was able to WHUP his A**.

Cap, Bruce can get a few wins.

Bats is smarter in all aspects, fighting, tactics everything

Cap would most likely win in a straight up H2H fight but it would be because of his physical stats and not his actual fighting ability

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
Bats is smarter in all aspects, fighting, tactics everything

Cap would most likely win in a straight up H2H fight but it would be because of his physical stats and not his actual fighting ability

The only real advantage Cap has is endurance. Otherwise, they are physically almost equal. Any other edge is negligible.

Cap is above Bats in strenght, probably speed and reflexes

Steve Rogers ftw.

Rogers wins. SSS just means that he can basically fight defensively and wear Batman down.

Believe me I usually defend Bats when I can but Cap is flat out his superior in physical stats

Assuming they are equal in fighting ability, Bats would probably give Cap hell for a little bit but Cap is ultimatly going to outlast Bats

Not to mention he hits harder then Bats does too

Plus the fact that the SSS gives him vastly superior endurance.

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
Bats is smarter in all aspects, fighting, tactics everything

Cap would most likely win in a straight up H2H fight but it would be because of his physical stats and not his actual fighting ability

Batman is NOT smarter than Cap. In Marvel lore, it very clearly establishes that all of Cap's attributes are the maximum possible for a human including intelligence. Human perfection means the most perfect intelligence capable of humans Captain America is widely viewed as one of Earth's most brilliant tacticians.

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
Bats is smarter in all aspects, fighting, tactics everything

Prove it.

Originally posted by KillboBaggins
Batman is NOT smarter than Cap. In Marvel lore, it very clearly establishes that all of Cap's attributes are the maximum possible for a human including intelligence. Human perfection means the most perfect intelligence capable of humans Captain America is widely viewed as one of Earth's most brilliant tacticians.
Batman has better feats then Cap does

He is smarter in all aspects, that includes Martial arts, tactics and being a detective

Cap may be the best tactician on Marvel Earth, but that doesnt mean hes better then Batman, and he doesnt have the feats to back it up either

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Prove it.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Go read a comic with Batman in it or go check out a respect thread

I admit Cap wins this but Cap isnt close to Batman in intellect in any aspect

Fighting? Last I checked Batman mastered 127 styles of fighting
Cap not so much

Tactics? Steve may be the best tactician on Marvel Earth but it doesnt make him a better tactician then Bruce at all

Science? No comment

Detective work? Do I really need to go here?

Cap isnt smarter then Bats in anything PERIOD

Originally posted by KillboBaggins
Batman is NOT smarter than Cap. In Marvel lore, it very clearly establishes that all of Cap's attributes are the maximum possible for a human including intelligence. Human perfection means the most perfect intelligence capable of humans Captain America is widely viewed as one of Earth's most brilliant tacticians.
All of his physical attributes, never said anything about his intellect

Hes a top notch tactician and thats about it

Bruce has him beat in intellect, get over it

Also Black Panther has said that Cap fights more like a brawler then a martial artist

I remember a comic where Cap said The Punishers plan to infiltrate a base was better then his own

Punisher does not = Batman, not even close

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
Also Black Panther has said that Cap fights more like a brawler then a martial artist

LOL where did he say that? Also other MAs have said that Cap is a great martial artist.

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
I remember a comic where Cap said The Punishers plan to infiltrate a base was better then his own

Punisher does not = Batman, not even close

LOL ive brought that up in debates to say that Punisher is arguably better a tactics than Cap and people tell me im stroking Punisher. Anyway as far as im concerned Punisher isnt inferior to Batman in tactics but would lose in a prep war due to resources. Punisher has also been give props by Dr Doom as well. Dr Doom is defintely smarter than Batman.

Dr Doom is book smarter then Batman is, not smarter combat wise

Im not saying Cap isnt a good martial artist, im just saying Bats is a good bit better, he knows more styles

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
Dr Doom is book smarter then Batman is, not smarter combat wise

Not in terms of martial arts but we could defintely make an argument that Doom is superior to Batman tactically.

Originally posted by Xzpunisher

Im not saying Cap isnt a good martial artist, im just saying Bats is a good bit better, he knows more styles

just because he knows more styles doesnt make him better.

Originally posted by Xzpunisher
Im not saying Cap isnt a good martial artist, im just saying Bats is a good bit better, he knows more styles

Sigh.