Astonishing vs Uncanny, Big X-men battle!!

Started by willRules7 pages

BUMP

Originally posted by willRules
Cyclops and havok cancel each other out
Emma frost and Psylock do the same
Beast beats Bishop
Colossus gets beat by storm
Shadowcat vs Nightcrawler= not sure....too close to call IMO
Wolverine beats X-23

but this is just one scenario. When everyone is fighting everyone, i forsee storm causing loads of problems and shadowcat causing loads of problems. Nightcrawler is a wildcard, but Beast brings intelligence to the table. its pretty even fight IMO.................

shadowcat is hurt by heavy based electrical attacks, and wind-based attacks. she is still affected by wind in phased form, and has been knocked out by magneto by a heavy amount of electricity. and colossus has been heavily damaged by storms lightning before. it wasn't the electricity that hurt him...but the amount of heat the lightning had.

I change my response to a draw - a similar fight occurred before and it was only Cable who survived, but there's no cable

Uncanny.

I'll handle this when i aint half drunk. The arguments for Astonishing are sh*t.

You serious? the other team doesn't even have a telepath.

The only time i've seen kitty getting hurt with electricity was what stormfront said with magneto. But that is the sole time i've seen it and we don't know exactly how it would affect her when he's not phased to someone before the voltage struck.

And IIRC colossus withstand a few minutes getting charged by Storm's lightning then got passed to Cyclops for extra fuel for his optic blast. Both Cyke and Piotr can handle it well.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Uncanny.

I'll handle this when i aint half drunk. The arguments for Astonishing are sh*t.

Ok, i'll be posting on this later then.....

Originally posted by Sixth_Winged
You serious? the other team doesn't even have a telepath.

The only time i've seen kitty getting hurt with electricity was what stormfront said with magneto. But that is the sole time i've seen it and we don't know exactly how it would affect her when he's not phased to someone before the voltage struck.

And IIRC colossus withstand a few minutes getting charged by Storm's lightning then got passed to Cyclops for extra fuel for his optic blast. Both Cyke and Piotr can handle it well.

un-phased? it would still affect her, and hurt even more. and colossus can;t stand a few minutes of geting hit with something that is 50,000 degrees. he could barley stand it for the second that it hit him.

Originally posted by stormfront13
un-phased? it would still affect her, and hurt even more. and colossus can;t stand a few minutes of geting hit with something that is 50,000 degrees. he could barley stand it for the second that it hit him.

It did on one appearance. On another(that planet of Arkon arc) about another issues later, he was charged up for almost an hour. And even moreso for cyclops who withstood that total charged lightning and used it to enpower his optic blasts.

And i mean not phased into someone ala Vision's phasing to opponent trick.

Colossus could take half of that team by himself. Yeah, Astonishing takes this, easy.

Astonishing. IIRC Shadowcat has shown she can resist telekinesis while phased, and she can phase the entire Astonishing team. Phasing has also allowed her to survive at the epicentre of a nuclear explosion. Emma's telepathy can account for most of the opposite team.

Cyclops can down Storm before Storm can down Cyclops, as already exasperatingly established in another thread in which she wasn't being attacked by Emma's telepathy. Cyclops also being the better leader and the Astonishing team having the ability to coordinate via telepathy, they fair better in the teamwork department.

Besides all that. It's a far better comic, with far better characters, under the helm of a far better writer.

BTW when has Bishop shown the ability to absorb telepathy?

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Astonishing. IIRC Shadowcat has shown she can resist telekinesis while phased, and she can phase the entire Astonishing team. Phasing has also allowed her to survive at the epicentre of a nuclear explosion. Emma's telepathy can account for most of the opposite team.

Cyclops can down Storm before Storm can down Cyclops, as already exasperatingly established in another thread in which she wasn't being attacked by Emma's telepathy. Cyclops also being the better leader and the Astonishing team having the ability to coordinate via telepathy, they fair better in the teamwork department.

Besides all that. It's a far better comic, with far better characters, under the helm of a far better writer.

BTW when has Bishop shown the ability to absorb telepathy?

Dont try it X. I'll handle this 2morrow. 😉

Meh, even if they do lose this fight... it's still a far better comic, with far better characters, under the helm of a far better writer.

Case-in-point, in the same issue that Rachel says there are no alternates of her in all the omniverse, there is a male alternate from a different reality. Or Dazzler being an External and having a healing factor that surpasses even Wolverine's...

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Besides all that. It's a far better comic, with far better characters, under the helm of a far better writer.

no doubt 😖hifty:

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Meh, even if they do lose this fight... it's still a far better comic, with far better characters, under the helm of a far better writer.

Case-in-point, in the same issue that Rachel says there are no alternates of her in all the omniverse, there is a male alternate from a different reality. Or Dazzler being an External and having a healing factor that surpasses even Wolverine's...

Ok cos thats somehow relevant 😕

Nite nite X 🙂

It's not.

Nite.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
It's not.

Nite.

😕

Originally posted by stormfront13
un-phased? it would still affect her, and hurt even more. and colossus can;t stand a few minutes of geting hit with something that is 50,000 degrees. he could barley stand it for the second that it hit him.
Storm summoned all of her lightning she could muster. Colossus help up rather well.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Meh, even if they do lose this fight... it's still a far better comic, with far better characters, under the helm of a far better writer.

Case-in-point, in the same issue that Rachel says there are no alternates of her in all the omniverse, there is a male alternate from a different reality. Or Dazzler being an External and having a healing factor that surpasses even Wolverine's...

SHHHHH!! ✅

Havoks blasts are hotter than Storms lightning and Colossus has handled those on more than one occasion also.

http://www.thefreeimagehosting.com/Uploads/Images/2132115625000havok.jpg

Here is another case in which Colossus took Storms lightning once again.

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c379/Doggydogg/Colossuslightingrod.jpg