ROTJ Luke vs ANH Ben

Round1: Sabers only
Round2: Force only
Round3: Anything goes

ANH Obi. ROTJ Luke gives him some trouble.

Obi pwns.

Obi pwns.

I'd say Obi-Wan wins all three with relative ease.

Btw vpokfjdklfhlf, your sig is....... strange.

Meh, Ben takes this. He may have been generally out of practice for twenty years, but he's far more experienced than Luke, and far more powerful...

1)A tough fight. Luke could probably pierce his defences if Luke taps into the dark side. Otherwise, I'm not sure. Either way, it wouldn't be easy for either party.

2)Ben's experience would win him the fight. Luke has learned a helluva lot in a short amount of time, but not enough to deal with Ben at this point.

3)Probably Ben in a tough fight. It depends on the place and how far away they are at the beginning of the fight.

1. Saber duel: Luke may be a good duelist, but he would be no match for Obi-Wan, even the 50+ year old version.

2. Luke undoubtedly has greater Force Potential, but he lacks the experiance of Obi-Wan

3. I'm not so sure about the "Anything goes" thing. If it's a fist fight, without a doubt Luke. A space fight.... erm..... probably Luke (maybe Obi-Wan, I dont know! shock). If it's a saber and force fight together, Obi-Wan

Obi-Wan wins all three of them.

Obi-Wan destroys Luke.

Originally posted by Jabba the Hutt
Round1: Sabers only
Round2: Force only
Round3: Anything goes

Originally posted by darthsith19
1. Luke hasn't had anywhere near as much dueling experience as Obi-Wan and Obi-Wan proved in the Mosiesly Cantina that he still has alot of speed. Obi wins. Obi-Wan could have defeated Vader in ANH if he had wanted to, IMO, and Luke only beat Vader cause of the Dark Side and the fact that Vader was conflicted.
2. Obi-Wan pwns Luke. In ANH Obi-Wan is at the prime of his life as far as Force Powers go. Luke's just... not that good yet.
3. Obi-Wan wins, Luke puts up a pretty good fight, but Obi-Wan has a solid victory.

He could have beat Vader if he wanted to? That's news to me. Weren't they equal?

It's funny how that EXACT line is the opposite in the ANH novel.

"Obi-Wan would have defeated Vader if he could have"

Alas, he couldn't.

They were equally matched.

They were evenly matched, were they? What does Vader have over Kenobi? Hmm? kenobi has speed, saber skills and Force powers over Vader.

He may have the agility factor, but he's unable to overpower Vader in lightsabre combat and perhaps through the force.

Ben had absolutely no reason to train at all...

I can say with confidence that Ben wins all three pretty easily.

Originally posted by darthsith19
They were evenly matched, were they? What does Vader have over Kenobi? Hmm? kenobi has speed, saber skills and Force powers over Vader.

If you weren't wrong, I would believe you.

Speed? Probably. Saber skills? Force powers? Definitely not.

I doubt Olb Ben even has speed on Vader.

Vader has the advantage of having been very active the past twenty years, killing Jedi and subjugating planets and whatnot.

Meanwhile, Obi-Wan would manhandle Luke with the Force, and most likely with a lightsaber. Luke isn't all that great...he beat Vader because Vader was thinking "Oh my god, my son is trying to kill me! What do I do, what do I do...do I kill him? Do I turn him to the Dark Side? Do I join him?! What?!" and Luke was going "I HATE YOU!"

...

Yeah.

Originally posted by Swirly Girl
He may have the agility factor, but he's unable to overpower Vader in lightsabre combat and perhaps through the force.

Ben had absolutely no reason to train at all...