CW Dooku and CW Grievous vs Rots Obi-Wan and Rots Anakin

Started by kamikz6 pages

Again, who says Grievous would be the one attacking? I doubt he would survive a full attack from Anakin, let alone survive when Anakin uses the force.

And Grievous arms was as agile and fast as ever, but his body was slow....

Originally posted by kamikz
Again, who says Grievous would be the one attacking? I doubt he would survive a full attack from Anakin,

Why? He has four lightsabers he can use to block with...

Originally posted by kamikz
And Grievous arms was as agile and fast as ever,

They were not. Watch the scene in RotS, and compare it to the scene in CW when he held off the 5 Jedi. The speed of the rotations is audibly slower in RotS than it was in CW (which is about twice as fast)

Originally posted by Darth Vious
Why? He has four lightsabers he can use to block with...

They were not. Watch the scene in RotS, and compare it to the scene in CW when he held off the 5 Jedi. The speed of the rotations is audibly slower in RotS than it was in CW (which is about twice as fast)

Anakin outmanuvered Dooku who is a better swordsman than Grievous, was said to be probably the best practisioner of his style and the fastest jedi that Durge had ever "killed". Besides, Anakin is much more manuverable than Grievous, jumping over his head like Obi did without him even being prepared for it. And as I said, force = Game over for GG.

Well watch the scene where Mace fights in the CW then in ROTS, about 4 times as fast.

Originally posted by kamikz
Anakin outmanuvered Dooku who is a better swordsman than Grievous, was said to be probably the best practisioner of his style and the fastest jedi that Durge had ever "killed". Besides, Anakin is much more manuverable than Grievous, jumping over his head like Obi did without him even being prepared for it. And as I said, force = Game over for GG.

I suggest you re-watch CW and re-aquiant yourself with Grievous' abilities. Anakin is nowhere near as maneuverable than Grievous.
Anakin outmaneuvered Dooku by physically overpowering him. How would he be able to overpower someone with droid strength and reflexes? Even in his weakened condition in RotS, Grievous was throwing Obi-Wan around like a ragdoll. Who came out worse when Obi-Wan tried to kick Grievous' legs out? I'd like to see Anakin try and immobilize Grievous' arms as he did Dooku's.
Also, Grievous was able to dodge Force blasts in CW, so that is not necessarily a deciding factor in the match.

Originally posted by kamikz
Well watch the scene where Mace fights in the CW then in ROTS, about 4 times as fast.

What does that have to do with anything? The only reason he wasn't fighting as fast in RotS was because Palpatine wasn't using his acrobatics. (and that it would look stupid to have a live actor moving so fast) The fact I'm talking about, is simple manipulation of objects. Something Grievous could not do as fast in RotS because of Mace's Force crush in CW.

Originally posted by Darth Vious
I suggest you re-watch CW and re-aquiant yourself with Grievous' abilities. Anakin is nowhere near as maneuverable than Grievous.
Anakin outmaneuvered Dooku by physically overpowering him. How would he be able to overpower someone with droid strength and reflexes? Even in his weakened condition in RotS, Grievous was throwing Obi-Wan around like a ragdoll. Who came out worse when Obi-Wan tried to kick Grievous' legs out? I'd like to see Anakin try and immobilize Grievous' arms as he did Dooku's.
Also, Grievous was able to dodge Force blasts in CW, so that is not necessarily a deciding factor in the match.

What does that have to do with anything? The only reason he wasn't fighting as fast in RotS was because Palpatine wasn't using his acrobatics. (and that it would look stupid to have a live actor moving so fast) The fact I'm talking about, is simple manipulation of objects. Something Grievous could not do as fast in RotS because of Mace's Force crush in CW.

The CW has a tendency to overpower people as I have said before. And Anakin was better than Dooku, this has been debated. Grievous could dodge Ki-Adi's force push, but he couldn't dodge when Dooku grabbed his leg with the force, Anakin could do the same. (As lifting a rock, you grab it with the force instead of using force to push it). And Obi easily pushed Grievous away, Anakin could do the same, as you said, he can barley rise before coughing his ass off..... And how does the crush effect his ROBOT arms? And Grievous tossed Obi-Wan around in an UNARMED duel (after he cowered and ran away), still Obi won in the end....

And in AOTC, he wasn't near that good. Mace had an army the size of the one surrounding them in AOTC, in the CW he wtfpwned them, in AOTC he knew they were about to die but they were saved by the clones. If Mace could push a whole army by himself he would have in that situation and before that..... And no, it is YOUR opinion that it would look stupid, but I have seen other movies that had people moving damn fast and it doesn't look silly....