RotJ Luke vs Count Dooku.

Started by DE Luke17 pages

He didn't sense it because he was concentrating on another guy before the one who shot him snuck up on him.Watch the movie again,itclearly shows this.

And you've proven yourself stupid because you misinterpret and don't listen to logic and instead use YOUR interpretaion(Which is NOT canon) when you want to prove something that you know,can't be proven and you can only assume.

Originally posted by balanced_blade
Nebaris, Mace was using Vaapad agianst Palp. Your logic doesnt even make since. Vaapad is the deadliest style, but assuming that if one uses it it MUST be offensive and doing stupid shit like that is ridiculous. Mace mastered Vaapad to use against Sith, hell yeah he is going to use it against Palp. That is what it was made for.

I'm sorry, but since when was Vaapad a defencive form. Mace was clearly on the defencive the entire fight. It has even been confirmed that Mace changed forms because he feared the unpredictable result of the clashing of two extremely overwhelming and offensive forms.

Originally posted by DE Luke
He didn't sense it because he was concentrating on another guy before the one who shot him snuck up on him.Watch the movie again,itclearly shows this.

Exactly, which furthers my point. He clearly wasn't quite that strong in the force yet to be able to sense attacks like that.

No,it hasn't been confirmed,only by your overbiased opinion it has.Yeas,he was on the defensive at first in the hallway(Because Vapaad isn't sa effective in small spaces,he was mearly blocking Palpatine's blows(Source:ROTS Novel and Commentary by Sam Jackson),but when it gets to the Main Meeting Office,then he goes offensive,the movie shows this.

And Dooku clearly wasn't as strong as Luke then,considering that if he was,he wouldn't be the one missing a head and two hands.

Why is this thread here?

Dooku obviously tools Luke, either with lightsaber or lightning.

We saw what a whiney ***** he was when Palpatine started blasting at him.

Originally posted by zephiel7
Why is this thread here?

Dooku obviously tools Luke, either with lightsaber or lightning.

We saw what a whiney ***** he was when Palpatine started blasting at him.

Hahahaha. Nice post - I couldnt have said it better myself. 😆

Originally posted by zephiel7
Why is this thread here?

Dooku obviously tools Luke, either with lightsaber or lightning.

We saw what a whiney ***** he was when Palpatine started blasting at him.

1.No,he doesn't,he defeats Luke,but he certainly doesn't 'tool' him.

2.Uh,ya' think maybe because he didn't have his lightsaber to deflect it?Shows your grasp on the movies. 🙄

@Rampant Ox:You'd say anything to support your man Dooku.Hell,you even went so far as to say he was a threat to DN Luke,which he certainly isn't.Which is exactly why I(And the other debaters who aren't n00bs) don't believe you or your word on anything Dooku anymore.

I admit,Luke loses,but he doesn't get PWNed.

Originally posted by DE Luke
1.No,he doesn't,he defeats Luke,but he certainly doesn't 'tool' him.

Is this the great DE Luke admitting defeat!?!?! I never would have thought it!!! 😱 😱

2.Uh,ya' think maybe because he didn't have his lightsaber to deflect it?Shows your grasp on the movies. 🙄

I dont want to start another argument but AOTC Anakin (who has far more experience than Luke) got wtf pwned by Dooku's lightning and he had his saber.

@Rampant Ox:You'd say anything to support your man Dooku.Hell,you even went so far as to say he was a threat to DN Luke,which he certainly isn't.Which is exactly why I(And the other debaters who aren't n00bs) don't believe you or your word on anything Dooku anymore

That was fairly obvious sarcasm. Even I know when Dooku is defeated - I just like to see how far I can piss people off before they snap. No offense was intended.

1.No,I'm admitting that he loses to Dooku,but not easily,if I said he would lose to Dooku easily,I would be admitting defeat.

2.No,he doesn't.We haven't seen anything Anakin has done prior to AOTC.And Anakin didn't deflect it because he wasn't expecting it,two different things:ROTJ Luke doesn't charge headlong into battle and gives into his emotions(Except when he was goaded by Vader),wherein Anakin let his emotions get the better of him and he let them cloud his judgement(Even before,Dooku never even goaded him in that whole fight,Anakin was just a pawn of his own emotions).


1.No,I'm admitting that he loses to Dooku,but not easily,if I said he would lose to Dooku easily,I would be admitting defeat.

Hahahaha. Thats all I have wanted to hear from the beginning. 🙂

2.No,he doesn't.We haven't seen anything Anakin has done prior to AOTC.And Anakin didn't deflect it because he didn't know Dooku would do that,two different things:ROTJ Luke doesn't charge headlong into battle and gives into his emotions(Except when he was goaded by Vader),wherein Anakin let his emotions get the better of him and he let them cloud his judgement(Even before,Dooku never even goaded him in that whole fight,Anakin was just a pawn of his own emotions).

Fair enough.

Good,we've reached a decision,now let's just let this thread die already.

Actually Anakin appears in the jedi quest series.
AOTC Anakin is far stronger in the force and far more experience and generally just more powerful than ROTJ Luke.

How aboutcha prove it?

Sorry guys.

Luke didn't even know of force lightning at the time!

Palpatine was coming towards him, his hands outstretched, taunting him. Do you think that Luke would have tossed aside his lightsaber if he knew of dark side techniques like lightning? If he knew of Palpatine's force powers, or dark side force powers at all, he would have had lightsaber in hand, ready to defend against them.

But the thing, you see, is he didn't.

That wouldnt even be a fight, Lukes fighting style is swing and hope you hit something.

This is a thread? Dooku wastes the slugger in no time

EDIT

Why are everyone picking on the actor that played Luke? Are we going to say Mace is slow and bad as hell because Samuel L Jackson can't fight with a sword`?

EDIT - I still can't watch my mouth because I'm stupid.

Originally posted by kamikz
Why are everyone picking on the actor that played Luke? Are we going to say Mace is slow and bad as hell because Samuel L Jackson can't fight with a sword`?

Exactly. Compare Luke's fighting in ESB to Mace's. Lukes is much better.