Exar Kun vs. Yoda

Sama posted before. Sabateur posted and Escape's gone for now so when he's gone, I'll GLADLY show him and ask him to post his opinion.

Ok, that's two parties....Sama said if that's what Veitch said, it's what it is even if she doesn't like it. And if Tom believes that's what Lucas wants, what else is his opinion gonna be? You're ARGUING AGAINST ONE CREATOR OF TOTJ!

I'm arguing the validity of his opinion of the author concerning the ancient sith, and 1 on 1 battles, which you haven't proven that he's stated anything..

Oh, for the love of-
He's the author, his opinion is valid. It has to do with a one on one because if he believes his characters are inferior to Yoda, chances are: They are

Oh my god you still can't comprehend something so simple. He has NOT mentioned anything comparing X to Y in combat, nor has he mentioned his opinion of the ancient sith. Fact>Your interpretation and what he "believes"

No, he put yoda above the others as a comparison. I mentioned the Ancient Sith in my question and he responded, why do you keep ignoring that? I asked how he stacked up to Kun AND THE ANCIENTS and Veitch said Yoda is definitely on top.

QED

Why do you keep ignoring the fact that Tom Veitch did NOT respond to your question with his opinion at ALL. You seriously have me wondering what is wrong with you. Your question is irrelevant, his response is somewhat relevant, which had nothing to do with his opinion but what he THOUGHT Lucas intended. Stop playing stupid because you dont have an argument, and because you want to BELIEVE that is what he said.

Oh, so giving a reaosn for what he's saying means it's not his opinion?

If he says he thinks Lucas believes it, why on earth would he go against Lucas?

Well thank you for proving my point lightsnake. You just described an opinion and the relevance of it. What do you mean why would he go against it? All of a sudden everyone is 100% agreeing with Lucas? And no, his msg the way you interpret it makes no sense, which obviously looks like he was answering another one of your questions, because the response makes little sense when goes with the question. But in no way does it mean that HE thought that Yoda>ancients, and him saying he "Believes" Lucas did this and that is speculation. I can also say that I BELIEVE Lucas wanted Palpatine to beat Yoda. What credibility does that statement warrant? None, because its speculation.

Oh, just be quiet.

I have stuff from the author, anyone with half a brain can tell you this: It's over. Stop embarrassing yourself because not ONE person has sided with you

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Considering the fact that I have provided 10 pages of argument, while you just came here, and considering the fact that you misuse the term "hyperbole", it is my assumption that you:

1. Haven't read anything on this forum and decided to chime in
2. Have no understanding of the proper usage of terms.

I remember skimming through 10 pages of this (note, exaggerations will be made):

D.Sexy: OMG KUN PWNZ YODA LIKE WHITE ON RICE!
L.S: *posts a factual argument as to how Yoda will win*
D.Sexy: No, that's incorrect because my opinion is all that matters and you're a PT fanboy and Kun will win!
L.S/Nai: *uses logical arguments against you*
Rinse, wash, and repeat right up until we get to the email:
L.S: *sigh* Since you really can't take a hint as to who will win: http://img142.imageshack.us/my.php?image=image3ix7.jpg
D.Sexy: Bullshit! *rambles about being an email marketer and crap*
L.S: That's coming from the creator-co-creator of TotJ, and Lucas even agrees with it. Hard to argue with that.
D.Sexy: *stubborn-ness* U LUUSE CUZ EYE MAID LAWGEEKUL ARGUMEHNTZ AND ALL U USD WERR EMAILZ, SO EYE WIN BY DEFULLT.

Rince, wash, and repeat this too.

And, Darth Sexy, how is Lightsnake's question irrelevant now? Because as he said, Lucas seems to be involved with this meaning that you can't argue with it. So please, just stop arguing in this thread and go for something that's a little harder to slam down than a book's cover. And Lucas' statements are 100% canon, so if he were to say "RotS Sidious was the most powerful Sith Lord ever", that'd be the final say because he's the creator of Star Wars.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
Oh, just be quiet.

I have stuff from the author, anyone with half a brain can tell you this: It's over. Stop embarrassing yourself because not ONE person has sided with you

You've had one person agree with you. How am I embarassing myself when I can provide arguments, and you can only provide quotes that again have no bearing on versus threads..

And for the last time Sabateur, he is SPECULATING that's what lucas believe, what part of "I believe" do you not understand?

In other words he believes it himself. Making it his opinion

Venificus AND Sama also side with me...if they post in my favor, will you be quiet?

Sure, if they tell you that your interpretation is correct and mine isn't? I'm sure they're credible sources that can interpret sentences correctly. My interpretation with the comma makes it one sentence, not 2 different ones.. And I will make SURE I get an answer from Tom tonight clarifying everything.

Really Sexy (tdtd) with every post you make you climb one more rung down the latter of intelligence. At this point you must be nearing the bottom, since you have quite a few posts.

Lightsnake has provided logical arguments, and proof from an AUTHOR, and yet like the brainless attention whore that you are you continue to argue with poorly thought out insults, and (excuse the language) logical ****ups.

You are a clueless bored college student who lacking anything constructive to do, comes here and trolls the hell out of these blasted forums.

Congratulations for passing the annual "Who is the Greatest Dumbass" award, I salute you.

EDIT: Oh and Sexy? Lightsnake's interpretation is correct.

Logical arguments? Hardly
Emails to support no arguments? Perhaps.. Thanks for your opinion and elementary school insults, i'll take them into consideration. Now I'm sure you have something more productive to be doing than wasting text with pointless insults. And considering in every thread I post, I post logical arguments, that would contradict your definition of troll.. Then again the majority of you completely misuse the word, which is to be expected.

Alright, I'm asking Venificus, Traya and Sama then. Friends, just say whose interpretation is right then:
Mine or his?

Where are the credible sources such as Sama, Nai, and Escape?

I'll ask Traya, she's a teacher...that credible enough? AND an antediluvian

*Sigh*

To be honest tdtd, you've effectively been out debated. Lightsnake's provided emails from the co-creator of TotJ on his opinion considering the matter, whereas you've provided what? I've not really seen anything come out from you apart from some seriously flawed premises and the inability to accept the fact that the co-creator of TotJ's opinion > your own.

Sure.. Ask her how a comma separates 2 sentences, when a colon or rather, a semicolon does that. I don't need stupidity from the other noncredible members who don't even post on this forum, but sure ask a teacher.