Originally posted by Quinlan_Vos
The Ten Greatest Jedi:1.) NJO Luke Skywalker
2.) Kyp Durron
3.) Jacen Solo
4.) Yoda
5.) Revan
6.) Kyle Katarn
7.) Mace Windu
8.) Vodo-Siosk Bass (WTF?)
9.) Corran Horn
10.) Obi-Wan Kenobi (WTF?)
The Ten Greatest Sith:
1.) DE Darth Sidious
2.) Marka Ragnos
3.) Exar Kun
4.) Darth Nihilus
5.) Naga Sadow
6.) Ulic Qel-Droma
7.) Ajunta Pall (WTF?)
8.) Freedon Nadd (WTF?)
9.) Ludo Kreesh (WTF?)
10.) Tulak Hord (WTF?)
What do you guys think?
Now, I'm assuming by "greatness" you're talking about power. Because Tulak Hord hasn't done anything great. And since Vader isn't on your list - it would seem you're talking about power. You're Jedi list is bad. And your Sith list is just...I'm not going to list why the list themselves are wrong completely, but the ones in bold stand out completely.
Firstly, we know jack about Tulak Hord - only he was "the best lightsaber duelist of the Ancient Sith", whom we haven't even seen use lightsabers. He's an unknown. Freedon Nadd? Another virtually unknown. Ajunta Pall? Uh, no. Ludo Kressh is one of the two strongest Sith under Ragnos (along with Naga Sadow).
Vodo Siosk-Baas? Uh, sorry, pal. He sucks the big one. Depa > Vodo easily. And there's others that would topple him. You didn't put Anakin on the list? As a Jedi, he's more powerful than Obi-Wan at the least. He's comparable to Mace Windu even. You're list is pretty flawed (Corran Horn?), so you should really re-think things.