Anti Moniter vs. Dark Pheonix

Started by bigbran24 pages

Originally posted by Basti0n
well Im off to bed for the night, feel free to keep posting we'll get this thing to 20 pages yet. I just rebutt your remarks when I wake up.

Actualy the shell as you call it can only die when dark phoenix wishies it. In Phoenix Endsong jean tried to get Logan to kill her but Dark Phoenix wouldnt allow it so he couldnt.

Anti Monitor got his ass handed to him in Crisis 12#

In the Dark Phoenix Saga the watcher says if left unchecked Dark Phoenix could consume existance. Se you would know this if you read the issues instead of just asking others to do the job for you. Read X-men 154# and x-men forever you'll understand both Phoenix and Dark Phoenix better.

Trolling?

Originally posted by Basti0n
I just rebutt your remarks when I wake up.
no you won't you'll just post the same crap over and over again.

Originally posted by bigbran
Trolling?
Yeah... spamming too.

Originally posted by Creshosk
no you won't you'll just post the same crap over and over again.

Yeah... spamming too.

He's run out of things to say, so he does this defence?
It's like making a 1 foot tall fence, when you have a great dane.

Originally posted by bigbran
He's run out of things to say, so he does this defence?
It's like making a 1 foot tall fence, when you have a great dane.
That's why I've stopped responding... I'd feel bad reporting someone like that.. it's almost like it's not their fault ... you know "innocent" like they don't really know better.because they don't have the intelectual capacity to learn it

Originally posted by Basti0n
[B]Yes it wanted to die when xorn "killed" Jean, It fulfilled the pheonix purpose.

Can you provide scans of this "fullfillment" plan.


and the ultraverse isnt canon ethier. and she wasnt even at full normal phoenix power when fighting them, no where near Dark Phoenix power.

It's canon. Marvel owned the Ultraverse when it bought Malibu Comics. It was drawned into the Ultraverse and drained. Later when it fought Ultra Force and the X-Men, it was "fresh" and the teams were "tired." In fact the X-Men were weakened when they came to the Ultraverse. A team "tired" Ultra Force and "tired" + weak X-Men drove the Force into their trap.


Actualy the shell as you call it can only die when dark phoenix wishies it. In Phoenix Endsong jean tried to get Logan to kill her but Dark Phoenix wouldnt allow it so he couldnt.

Anti Monitor got his ass handed to him in Crisis 12#

I've already addressed this.


In the Dark Phoenix Saga the watcher says if left unchecked Dark Phoenix could consume existance. Se you would know this if you read the issues instead of just asking others to do the job for you. Read X-men 154# and x-men forever you'll understand both Phoenix and Dark Phoenix better.

Already addressed this. I TOLD YOU that I HAVE READ BOTH. I also ASKED YOU where it said that Phoenix Force is unlimited in X-Men Forever.

Where in it's own bio does it say PF is second to LT? Or multiversal as your trying to say?
http://img501.imageshack.us/my.php?image=phoenixforce18cl.jpg

Her fight with Ultra Force is also referenced here.
http://img501.imageshack.us/my.php?image=phoenixforce28cr.jpg

Pfft. Fulfillment. Xorn killed Jean so she could reawaken 150 years later to stop a future from happening that never would have happened had she not died in the first place? Clever bird.

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
Can you provide scans of this "fullfillment" plan.
How is electromagnetic energy in and of itself capable of giving a person a stroke?

There's a major logical error here that practically ignores every previous example of electormagnetic energy being used against people.

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
It's canon. Marvel owned the Ultraverse when it bought Malibu Comics. It was drawned into the Ultraverse and drained. Later when it fought Ultra Force and the X-Men, it was "fresh" and the teams were "tired." In fact the X-Men were weakened when they came to the Ultraverse. A team "tired" Ultra Force and "tired" + weak X-Men drove the Force into their trap.
It was 616?

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
I've already addressed this.

Already addressed this. I TOLD YOU that I HAVE READ BOTH. I also ASKED YOU where it said that Phoenix Force is unlimited in X-Men Forever.

Where in it's own bio does it say PF is second to LT? Or multiversal as your trying to say?
http://img501.imageshack.us/my.php?image=phoenixforce18cl.jpg

Her fight with Ultra Force is also referenced here.
http://img501.imageshack.us/my.php?image=phoenixforce28cr.jpg

It's infinite power huh?

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Pfft. Fulfillment. Xorn killed Jean so she could reawaken 150 years later to stop a future from happening that never would have happened had she not died in the first place? Clever bird.
I don't think that the sentience was all that bright actually.

Originally posted by Creshosk
How is electromagnetic energy in and of itself capable of giving a person a stroke?

Would you like to explain Magneto's powers to me? Magneto's calling it a electromagnetic pulse that's giving her a stroke. She's having a stroke and died because of it. She died at his hands and referenced in Here Comes Tomorrow. That's what he says he's doing and that what happened. Maybe he's using some other energy, but we don't know. He's calling it a EM pulse and that's what I'm telling you it is.


There's a major logical error here that practically ignores every previous example of electormagnetic energy being used against people.

What examples are there? Did he try it against someone and it did not work?


It was 616?

The X-Men and the Phoenix Force were from 616. The Force was drawn into the Ultraverse universe, part of the MU after Marvel bought Malibu.


It's infinite power huh?

What are you talking about?

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
Would you like to explain Magneto's powers to me?
I think you already know them.

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
Magneto's calling it a electromagnetic pulse that's giving her a stroke. She's having a stroke and died because of it. She died at his hands and referenced in Here Comes Tomorrow. That's what he says he's doing and that what happened. Maybe he's using some other energy, but we don't know. He's calling it a EM pulse and that's what I'm telling you it is.
and I'm telling you that's ape ass stupid. There has to be something more than just electromagnetic energy. Cause electromagnetic energy by itself is used on the human brain all the time... Magnetic Resonance Imaging . . .

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
What examples are there? Did he try it against someone and it did not work?
whenever he directed his electro magnetic energy against people. in all of his various fights where he hits them directly with the energy... like a certain midget and a collossus .. or hey, even the other phoenix shell during the short time after 101 but before 137 they fought at least once I think...

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
The X-Men and the Phoenix Force were from 616. The Force was drawn into the Ultraverse universe, part of the MU after Marvel bought Malibu.
Thank you.

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
What are you talking about?
The paragraph right before the ultraverse section where the sentience traversed into another dimension . . .

"Rachel allowed necrom to posses the force gambling that it's infinite power would be too much for him."

I'm going to try and find a way to phrase this so it doesn't sound too wierd...

The sentience that often takes a bird form, but has taken on an avatar form of the replacment Jean Grey, or the host body of Jean, Rachel or Prime ... is a seperate phoenix force from the energy source that it is an embodiment of which is also called the phoenix force....

Pretty much the source of some of the conflict between phoenix fans/supporters and ... others is I think that there are two things refered to as the Phoenix Force... and they get confused quite frequently. The energy source of TOAA's creative energy and the stupid bird thingy.

Originally posted by Creshosk
[B]I think you already know them.

and I'm telling you that's ape ass stupid. There has to be something more than just electromagnetic energy. Cause electromagnetic energy by itself is used on the human brain all the time... Magnetic Resonance Imaging . . .

Magneto says it's an EM pulse. If he used some other kind of energy, I wouldn't know. What he says is an EMP and she's dying because of him. The fact is that she died and by him, which is later still referenced in Here Comes Tomorrow. As far as it goes Magneto killed her with his own power...we'll taping the Earth's magnetic energy.


whenever he directed his electro magnetic energy against people. in all of his various fights where he hits them directly with the energy... like a certain midget and a collossus .. or hey, even the other phoenix shell during the short time after 101 but before 137 they fought at least once I think...

This is energy he's been gather for a few days when he unloaded it on her. It's not the same as him pulling EM's out of the blue. Magneto also liquified admantium within seconds. It doesn't make sense that he could do it so quickly without strainning but he did. He's also dispersed Dazzler's attack into harmless light. The guy says it's an EMP. If it wasn't, it still was his own powers concentrated and directed at her that killed her. There's nothing to suggest otherwise.


The paragraph right before the ultraverse section where the sentience traversed into another dimension . . .

"Rachel allowed necrom to posses the force gambling that it's infinite power would be too much for him."

I'm going to try and find a way to phrase this so it doesn't sound too wierd...

The sentience that often takes a bird form, but has taken on an avatar form of the replacment Jean Grey, or the host body of Jean, Rachel or Prime ... is a seperate phoenix force from the energy source that it is an embodiment of which is also called the phoenix force....

Pretty much the source of some of the conflict between phoenix fans/supporters and ... others is I think that there are two things refered to as the Phoenix Force... and they get confused quite frequently. The energy source of TOAA's creative energy and the stupid bird thingy.

See what I don't understand is the TOAA and Phoenix Force connection. Where's this coming from? From what I've gathered, this is all just a speculation. Does it say anywhere that this is TOAA's creative energy?

Phoenix Force is part of a cycle; it's job is to spark the big bang every time after the universe dies. That's certain. What I don't get is where does it say PF created the VERY FIRST universe or multiverse to begin this cycle. All references and scans have been to her role in the current universe (which is part of the cycle).

My whole issue is Phoenix fans trying to claim that the Pheonix created the universe and therefore brought concepts and abstracts into being. When all is shown is the abstracts have yet to even consider the PF in any relation to them. Nor have they said she's more powerful then them.

Simply put my take is:
TOAA created LT and concepts and abstracts. It created the very first universe(s) that make up the multiverse. Beings such as Eterntiy, Death, Chaos, Order, Oblivion, and Ressurection were created by TOAA. When the first universe died, the Phoenix Force ressurrects the universe through a spark and begins the universe again.

Some Phoenix Fans:
Phoenix created the big bang and is said by Uatu to be second only to the Creator. Here's a scan that references the PF responsible for the big bang which created the universe. Whose part of the universe? Oh that's right, everything including Eterntiy, Death, and the other abstracts. There! Case close. Eternity and the other abstracts are below PF because it "created" the universe and the abstracts are part of the universe. 🙄

The funny thing about other Phoenix fans' argument is that no marvel bio has put her in such a position (TOAA's power, multiverse creator, second only to LT). In comics, there's no actual words by any of the abstracts that the Force is in a way related to them much less responsible for their creation or is the source of their power. The argument's for the Force's place in the MU also ignores X-Men Forever's universal cycle that she's a part of. No where in it does it say that Eternity and the other abstracts were related much less created by the Force. In fact Prosh says that the abstracts survives to the next universe. As for the Stranger, he referred to it as the Ressurection Force. Other things ignored by fans is also references regarding the Phoenix Force as "a child of the universe." Meaning it was born at some point in one of the universe. You only here that she sparked the big bang therefore everyone's to believe that the abstracts were created because of the Phoenix. 🙄

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
The funny thing about other Phoenix fans' argument is that no marvel bio has put her in such a position (TOAA's power, multiverse creator, second only to LT). In comics, there's no actual words by any of the abstracts that the Force is in a way related to them much less responsible for their creation or is the source of their power. The argument's for the Force's place in the MU also ignores X-Men Forever's universal cycle that she's a part of. No where in it does it say that Eternity and the other abstracts were related much less created by the Force. In fact Prosh says that the abstracts survives to the next universe. As for the Stranger, he referred to it as the Ressurection Force. Other things ignored by fans is also references regarding the Phoenix Force as "a child of the universe." Meaning it was born at some point in one of the universe. You only here that she sparked the big bang therefore everyone's to believe that the abstracts were created because of the Phoenix.

clap3 wish I had legs to give you a standing O...

Originally posted by Mr Master
clap3 wish I had legs to give you a standing O...
Huh?

Originally posted by bigbran
Huh?

Standing Ovation...

The guy deserves it after spitting that wisdom.

Originally posted by Mr Master
Standing Ovation...

The guy deserves it after spitting that wisdom.

I know, but you said, I wish I had legs.

Originally posted by bigbran
I know, but you said, I wish I had legs.

Cause the little smilie is legless. 😆

Originally posted by Mr Master
Cause the little smilie is legless. 😆
Oh.... god!

Ok, I'm going to bed.
See ya.

Phoenix takes this and Phoenix is Multiversal power.

Originally posted by bigbran
And she can also be beaten by the shiar...

Not really, DP was defeated, actully DP defeated herself, because there was no other way to defeat DP.
Nothing ever showed her to be taken down by Shiar and that she would be defeated, if she wouldn't allow it..
WPOTC is of course more powerful than DP.