Of course not, lightsnake likes to make shit up to prove his fanboyism. That was the most useful post you've ever had nebaris/planet.
However, as you mentioned, even if there WAS a defense for a technique, that doesn't at ALL mean it's guaranteed. Especially something like a force drain of an enormous magnitude.
I'm not saying Yoda cannot kill Nihilus, I believe he could, but about all this "Yoda can do this, Yoda can somehow do this" gets to me.
When the sources say Yoda has a defense for all Dark Side techniques, it doesn't mean every Force maneuver on every imaginable scale possible.
Darth Nihilus is a wound in the Force. Because of this accursed power, his appetite makes him able to suck the life out of anything in his path. Now whether you would consider this to be any type of Force Drain is entirely up to the majority of this forum.
Now let us imagine that Nihilus’s Wound is in the category of Drains. With this settled, let us proceed to the Yoda argument. Yoda has a defense against a Force Drain, but what magnitude? You don’t know! You cannot say Yoda has a defense to Nihilus’s Ultra Death Field (Death Field is a higher magnitude of Fore Drain), because by that logic, Yoda would have a defense to Luke’s Emerald Lightning.
Therefore, it’s up to Lightsnake and his supporters to prove that Yoda can form a defense against this.
Originally posted by General Kenobl
I'm not saying Yoda cannot kill Nihilus, I believe he could, but about all this "Yoda can do this, Yoda can somehow do this" gets to me.When the sources say Yoda has a defense for all Dark Side techniques, it doesn't mean every Force maneuver on every imaginable scale possible.
Darth Nihilus is a wound in the Force. Because of this accursed power, his appetite makes him able to suck the life out of anything in his path. Now whether you would consider this to be any type of Force Drain is entirely up to the majority of this forum.
Now let us imagine that Nihilus’s Wound is in the category of Drains. With this settled, let us proceed to the Yoda argument. Yoda has a defense against a Force Drain, but what magnitude? You don’t know! You cannot say Yoda has a defense to Nihilus’s Ultra Death Field (Death Field is a higher magnitude of Fore Drain), because by that logic, Yoda would have a defense to Luke’s Emerald Lightning.
Therefore, it’s up to Lightsnake and his supporters to prove that Yoda can form a defense against this.
there is no way Nihilus can take an entire Jedi order. Especially if they combined with the Wall of Light
And yet again, the Jedi might have developed defenses for said techniques, but that doesn't mean they can stop them. Guy X might know a defense for Guy Y's technique, but if Guy Y is superior to him in the force, Guy X can't stop him. That's not to say Nihilus is superior, but Nihilus eats the force, consumes it, so it's not exactly a force drain and it's not something that you can stop without being a wound yourself.
Originally posted by Lightsnake
That's what a force drain is. That's exactly what Nihilus uses, just to a different mean.Traya wasn't a wound I remind you
And Traya's technique was an old fashioned force drained supped up a little bit. She never used it to the extent Palpatine used it. However Palpatine's was a massive force drain, while Nihilus just ate/consumed everything.
And is a drain suppose to shake down buildings and completely strip human of the flesh?
Why do you think kreia stated he learnt the greatest technique, which is to consume force energies from force sensitives.
A force drain drains the life out of the victim, Nihilus drains strip them from the force, Why do you think kreia got weakened after nihilus gave her a simple push?
And believe me, if such a technique can be blocked, Wouldnt the jedi on katarr use that defence? Given that they are masters i doubt they wouldnt have techniques to block a regular force drain, This force drain technique was common during JCW and dont you think the jedi would come up with a defence?
Again it took the drain to destroy katarr in a matter of minutes, the jedi and miraluka clearly had a hell long of time to put up their defences since force shield is instant and can counter a regular drain.
I say this again, just because a bulletproof vest can block bullets can it block a RPG rocket? Hell no, the vest gets shreded.
Understand? Or not? To the logical yes...
What i just said is maybe a shield blocks the normal drain, but can it block a drain of that magnitude? Where it shatters buildings and shred humans apart?
By your logic yoda > DE sidious "B3cUz H3 c@N Bl0Ck @!! D@rK$!d3 t3Chn!Qu3s!!!!!!!!!!" As you are so fond of speaking
Originally posted by Kadesh
And is a drain suppose to shake down buildings and completely strip human of the flesh?
Why do you think kreia stated he learnt the greatest technique, which is to consume force energies from force sensitives.
A force drain drains the life out of the victim, Nihilus drains strip them from the force, Why do you think kreia got weakened after nihilus gave her a simple push?
And believe me, if such a technique can be blocked, Wouldnt the jedi on katarr use that defence? Given that they are masters i doubt they wouldnt have techniques to block a regular force drain, This force drain technique was common during JCW and dont you think the jedi would come up with a defence?
Again it took the drain to destroy katarr in a matter of minutes, the jedi and miraluka clearly had a hell long of time to put up their defences since force shield is instant and can counter a regular drain.
I say this again, just because a bulletproof vest can block bullets can it block a RPG rocket? Hell no, the vest gets shreded.<
Understand? Or not? To the logical yes...What i just said is maybe a shield blocks the normal drain, but can it block a drain of that magnitude? Where it shatters buildings and shred humans apart?
By your logic yoda > DE sidious "B3cUz H3 c@N Bl0Ck @!! D@rK$!d3 t3Chn!Qu3s!!!!!!!!!!" As you are so fond of speaking