Wonderwoman Vs. Silver Surfer

Started by Skeets24 pages

Originally posted by h1a8
Rule 1: Only feats shown in canon comics can be proof to a character's ability in a fight.
This implies that if one has never shown a power or ability in comics that is specific in a fight then that power don't exist for them.

Rule 2: The ability to travel at a certain speed through hyperspace doesn't imply that one can move and react at a similar speed in a fight.

Theorem1: SS isn't fast enough to dodge Diana's attacks.
Proof: SS has never shown faster than Diana can attack reflexes ever.
But has shown to constantly get hit by speeds that are equally fast or slower than Diana (Such as Thor, Hulk, Spiderman, thrown rocks, etc.).
Thus by rule 1 and 2 SS isn't fast enough to dodge Diana's attacks.

Theorem2: Diana can easily cut his head off.
Proof: By theorem 1 she will land a blow to him in a fight (instantly killing him due to decapitation).

Theorem3. SS cannot harm her in the process of their fight.
Prove: 1) SS can either try to blast her (for a various effect), 2) physically attack her, 3) or affect her immediate surroundings.
1) and 2) will be ineffective due to her speed and reflexes (FTL) which she has by rule 1).
3) will be ineffective to to her constant motion in the fight (she wont stay in the same place for too long).

Theorem3: Diana wins over SS
Proof: By theorem 1 and 2


What the hell?
So you're saying that WW is flat out faster the Surfer?
Your pretty funny,Surfer turns the oxygen in her lungs into rocks and she dies.

Originally posted by Skeets
What the hell?
So you're saying that WW is flat out faster the Surfer?
Your pretty funny,Surfer turns the oxygen in her lungs into rocks and she dies.

Why can't you understand the proofs above?
Yes she is faster than SS in a fight situation.
Yet you ignored the theorem on how SS can't harm WW (due to her FTL reflexes). Thus blasting (sending a beam) at her to turn the oxygen in her lungs into rocks implies that she just sits there and let SS do it (no blocking or moving but just eating popcorn and watching). She has FTL reflexes for crying out loud. The proofs are valid (just look them over again).

so I was just going to post how silver surfer mops the floor with her and everything (because he does normally) but then I took the time to see that she has godwave and all her equipment. So while surfer can mope the floor with both wonderwoman and superman at the same time he can't in my opinion handle the Godwave and all her other equipment.

Originally posted by h1a8
Rule 1: Only feats shown in canon comics can be proof to a character's ability in a fight.
This implies that if one has never shown a power or ability in comics that is specific in a fight then that power don't exist for them.

Rule 2: The ability to travel at a certain speed through hyperspace doesn't imply that one can move and react at a similar speed in a fight.

Theorem1: SS isn't fast enough to dodge Diana's attacks.
Proof: SS has never shown faster than Diana can attack reflexes ever.
But has shown to constantly get hit by speeds that are equally fast or slower than Diana (Such as Thor, Hulk, Spiderman, thrown rocks, etc.).
Thus by rule 1 and 2 SS isn't fast enough to dodge Diana's attacks.

Theorem2: Diana can easily cut his head off.
Proof: By theorem 1 she will land a blow to him in a fight (instantly killing him due to decapitation).

Theorem3. SS cannot harm her in the process of their fight.
Prove: 1) SS can either try to blast her (for a various effect), 2) physically attack her, 3) or affect her immediate surroundings.
1) and 2) will be ineffective due to her speed and reflexes (FTL) which she has by rule 1).
3) will be ineffective to to her constant motion in the fight (she wont stay in the same place for too long).

Theorem3: Diana wins over SS
Proof: By theorem 1 and 2

I disagree with rule 1. One can assume a power or ability never seen because sometimes it just makes sense. For example: I've never seen Superman superpee, but I'm sure he does it much farther than ordinary mortal men. If the power fits with the known powerset, IMO it's legit.

Rule 2: Agreed.

Now: Surfer has been shown to have nano reaction time, which implies FTL. He could no doubt amp it higher, since he is able to amp his strength and whatever else (but rarely does because direct application of energy is faster and more efficient). He might even be able to surpass her. So for the moment, let's say they're even in strength and speed. Skin-wise, Surfer is more durable than WW (you'll never see him raise his wrists to block). WW has greater h2h skill, but Surfer can wield energy up close just as easily as from afar. I don't think it's in Diana's best interest to infight.

As I see it, WW's best bet is to use her two greatest weapons: the godwave and whatever her best defense is (Aegis shield?) so she can have the few seconds to prep.

The question now becomes: how thorough is this defense? Because it's magical, do we just assume absolute impenetrability? Here I would say Rule 1 stands. Show me this Wonder defense is solid at every level: magically, cosmically, interdimensionally, timetravel-wise, etc. Because if it isn't, and given the Surfer's immense versatility, he will find a way in very, very quickly.

🥷

Originally posted by Mindship
I disagree with rule 1. One can assume a power or ability never seen because sometimes it just makes sense. For example: I've never seen Superman superpee, but I'm sure he does it much farther than ordinary mortal men. If the power fits with the known powerset, IMO it's legit.

Rule 2: Agreed.

Now: Surfer has been shown to have nano reaction time, which implies FTL. He could no doubt amp it higher, since he is able to amp his strength and whatever else (but rarely does because direct application of energy is faster and more efficient). He might even be able to surpass her. So for the moment, let's say they're even in strength and speed. Skin-wise, Surfer is more durable than WW (you'll never see him raise his wrists to block). WW has greater h2h skill, but Surfer can wield energy up close just as easily as from afar. I don't think it's in Diana's best interest to infight.

As I see it, WW's best bet is to use her two greatest weapons: the godwave and whatever her best defense is (Aegis shield?) so she can have the few seconds to prep.

The question now becomes: how thorough is this defense? Because it's magical, do we just assume absolute impenetrability? Here I would say Rule 1 stands. Show me this Wonder defense is solid at every level: magically, cosmically, interdimensionally, timetravel-wise, etc. Because if it isn't, and given the Surfer's immense versatility, he will find a way in very, very quickly.

🥷

How strong is the Aegis shield? Strong enough to complete shield her from the combined power of the DC skyfathers.

Originally posted by Mindship
I disagree with rule 1. One can assume a power or ability never seen because sometimes it just makes sense. For example: I've never seen Superman superpee, but I'm sure he does it much farther than ordinary mortal men. If the power fits with the known powerset, IMO it's legit.

Rule 2: Agreed.

Now: Surfer has been shown to have nano reaction time, which implies FTL. He could no doubt amp it higher, since he is able to amp his strength and whatever else (but rarely does because direct application of energy is faster and more efficient). He might even be able to surpass her. So for the moment, let's say they're even in strength and speed. Skin-wise, Surfer is more durable than WW (you'll never see him raise his wrists to block). WW has greater h2h skill, but Surfer can wield energy up close just as easily as from afar. I don't think it's in Diana's best interest to infight.

As I see it, WW's best bet is to use her two greatest weapons: the godwave and whatever her best defense is (Aegis shield?) so she can have the few seconds to prep.

The question now becomes: how thorough is this defense? Because it's magical, do we just assume absolute impenetrability? Here I would say Rule 1 stands. Show me this Wonder defense is solid at every level: magically, cosmically, interdimensionally, timetravel-wise, etc. Because if it isn't, and given the Surfer's immense versatility, he will find a way in very, very quickly.

🥷

Rule 1 implies the specific nature of the feat. It takes into account the idea of sets and subsets. For example, if superman lifted a mountain in battle then he certainly can lift a car in battle even if it was never shown. SS has never shown the type of speed or reflexes in a battle situation that shows that he can't get hit by WW.

And please show me where he has nanosecond second reaction in a battle. And know that nanosecond reaction is not FTL reaction time. It depends on how far the attack is thrown from and how many nanoseconds can you react.

Dodges Meteors
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/Avengers_Annual_16-18.jpg

Uses fast reflexes to hit ganymede (who fights at light speed)
http://img198.imageshack.us/img198/4546/lightpseed7fn.jpg

Breaks Free of his shackles in less than a nanosecond
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=3657953

knows what moves she'll be doing

Tells the Thing that he can see past, present and Future
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/...r_v3_138_06.jpg

The power of SS

SS creates Billions of terawatts of Power
http://img212.imageshack.us/img212/3305/ssscaniz1.th.jpg

or devolves her (here he evolves life so he could probably devolve life too)

Evolves Life
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/...r_Vol3-015b.jpg
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/...er_Vol3-016.jpg

Evolves a planet billions of year
1) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/Silver_Surfer_Vol3-015b.jpg
2) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/Silver_Surfer_Vol3-016.jpg

or just attack her internally
Internal Attack
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/...mited_03_21.jpg

WW better becareful or ss will simulate her magic also
Recreate Beta-Ray-Bill with Odin
Recreate Beta-Ray-Bill with Odin
1) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-05.jpg
2) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-06.jpg
3) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-07.jpg
4) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-08.jpg
5) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-10.jpg

Originally posted by h1a8
please show me where he has nanosecond second reaction in a battle. And know that nanosecond reaction is not FTL reaction time. It depends on how far the attack is thrown from and how many nanoseconds can you react.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=8306520
Notice that he's realizing what's happening in one nanosecond, then responding in the next nanosecond. His response consists of swinging both fists out in an arc, each fist traveling about 6 feet.

That's 6 feet in one nanosecond, equivalent to a speed of 6 billion feet in 1 second. The speed of light is about 980 million ft/sec. This means Surfer is moving his fists at about 6x lightspeed (actually, he's responding before the next nanosecond passes, so 6x cee is a minimum FTL reaction time).

If SS doesn't display this kind of reflex speed on a regular basis, again it's because he doesn't have to. He's certainly capable of it.

How strong is the Aegis shield? Strong enough to complete shield her from the combined power of the DC skyfathers.

Does it protect her on every level of existence (eg, does it extend through time, through other dimensions or through quantum fields)? Is there proof of this absolute protection (I know I'm asking a lot, but then, we're supposing a lot with WW in full arsenal).

Would Diana even be capable of properly controlling 2 of her mightest weapons (by her own admission, the strength amping compromised her control; why not this)?

i just don't see her winning this

show me scan of atleast a force of some kind that she made that was atleast a bllion jules of terrawots or equalivant.

Originally posted by HigH ScholaR
show me scan of atleast a force of some kind that she made that was atleast a bllion jules of terrawots or equalivant.

WW on her own is as strong and was able to stalemate capt marvel. Cap marvel was able to match superman. Superman was able to fly thru a planet and split it in half. irgo WW is equal to or nearly equal to superman's strength. With the guantlet of atlast, she would be somewhere in Thanos' strength class. Her invulnerablity would be so high that Surfers most powerful blast would be shrugged off. Adding in the armor and all of her other weapons kills surfer. All she needs to do is land one punch, and she would ***** him like thanos has. The lasso or sword would end the fight decisively. All this other crap about surfer transmuting the air in her lungs is a non factor since it has been proven that she can fght without the need for air in a prolongued battle. I.E. her battle with Primaid was in space.

Originally posted by HigH ScholaR
Dodges Meteors
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/Avengers_Annual_16-18.jpg

Uses fast reflexes to hit ganymede (who fights at light speed)
http://img198.imageshack.us/img198/4546/lightpseed7fn.jpg

Breaks Free of his shackles in less than a nanosecond
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=3657953

knows what moves she'll be doing

Tells the Thing that he can see past, present and Future
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/...r_v3_138_06.jpg

The power of SS

SS creates Billions of terawatts of Power
http://img212.imageshack.us/img212/3305/ssscaniz1.th.jpg

or devolves her (here he evolves life so he could probably devolve life too)

Evolves Life
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/...r_Vol3-015b.jpg
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/...er_Vol3-016.jpg

Evolves a planet billions of year
1) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/Silver_Surfer_Vol3-015b.jpg
2) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/Silver_Surfer_Vol3-016.jpg

or just attack her internally
Internal Attack
http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/...mited_03_21.jpg

WW better becareful or ss will simulate her magic also
Recreate Beta-Ray-Bill with Odin
Recreate Beta-Ray-Bill with Odin
1) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-05.jpg
2) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-06.jpg
3) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-07.jpg
4) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-08.jpg
5) http://photobucket.com/albums/b305/surfistaprateado/CosmicPowersUnlimited05-10.jpg

Meteors move nowhere near the speed of Diana.

Ganymede moves fast in fights but not light speed (traveling speed is not fighting speed)
Also you see her hitting him. Thus 1 hit from Diana is death.

The third scan shows nothing but talk. How do you if he meant that literally?
I can say I need to get out of these chains this very second but takes me actually 10 seconds to do so. Also busting out of anything takes about a nanosecond. That has nothing to do with fighting speed and reflexes.

The fourth scan doesn't work.

The fifth scan has nothing to do with his fighting speed and reflexes (even though the scan is too small to actually see).

The evolves life scans don't work. They wouldn't even help her anyway.

The evolves a planet billions of years scan doesn't show anything but talk. It also doesn't help
in this fight.

The attack her internally scan doesn't work

The last scans show him with Odins help. There is no simulation there.
There is no Odin's help here either.

Bottom line your scans are poor feats. I've seen more impressive feats for SS than these.
These do nothing to prove that he fights at speeds to avoid Diana attacks. You haven't even show n a defense for him against the Godwave.

Silver Surfer based

1. On friggen logic and

2. http://www.geocities.com/bruno_nojunk/

Originally posted by h1a8
🙄 You haven't shown a single thing to suggest "WW is faster than SS" in any way; probably because it's a ludicrous statement. You're trying to disregard Surfer's speed feats while you haven't shown a single thing to suggest WW can even catch up with him let alone connect with him. Whereas scans have been shown of both SS traveling speed and bodily movement speed as being much FTL.

You've used that Invisible Woman shields herself from lasers to say she has FTL reflexes and is faster than Thor before. I.e. imo you're full of crap.

How exactly do you dodge matter transmutation?

His speed advantage is a defense against the Godwave; as all she did with it was physical. No matter how many times things by Cronus or Ares are brought up that's all she did.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
🙄 You haven't shown a single thing to suggest "WW is faster than SS" in any way; probably because it's a ludicrous statement. You're trying to disregard Surfer's speed feats while you haven't shown a single thing to suggest WW can even catch up with him let alone connect with him. Whereas scans have been shown of both SS traveling speed and bodily movement speed as being much FTL.

You've used that Invisible Woman shields herself from lasers to say she has FTL reflexes and is faster than Thor before. I.e. imo you're full of crap.

How exactly do you dodge matter transmutation?

His speed advantage is a defense against the Godwave; as all she did with it was physical. No matter how many times things by Cronus or Ares are brought up that's all she did.

SS has no fighting speed. Those scans prove nothing. I constantly see him get hit by beings such as Hulk all day long. Show me where he has awesome enough fighting speed and reflexes to dodge diana's attacks. Because as far as I seen as that every time he is in a fight he lacks even decent reflexes and speed. Don't show any travel speed feats because these have nothing to do with fighting. And understand that is SS much weaker in an atmosphere than space. And know also that if I can travel FTL doesn't mean I have FTL reflexes too nor does it explain how long does it take me to reach a certain travel speed. That is to say, that in human perception it might seem that SS can instantly obtain FTL speed but in Diana's perception it takes a millinium for SS to gain enough speed to be beyond her perception. Thus you can't compare traveling speeds to fighting speeds.

I never claimed IW is faster than Thor. Reflexes is based off sight (such as blocking bullets) and not hearing. You can have poor hearing but great reflexes. You can only attack after the bell. While the bell is ringing then she is getting her shield up (In which she can do instantaneously). If you disagree then at least understand that hearing a bell and responding is much different than seeing something and reacting (and planning before the bell is allowed-this takes away the thought time of getting her shield up).

And Thor throwing his hammer fast has nothing to do with its startup time. He hasn't ever showned to instantly throw his hammer (without any time taking place). Most of the time he whirls it first (building up speed) before throwing. And sue blocking lasers and bullets may be PIS (It happened far too many times though) but it is feasible that this can happen since her very being (molecular) was altered. She is no longer human. So assuming that she must respond in human speed is faulty. Many people here base this solely off of her still looking human and still having human strength (Which is stupidness). Yet she has proven time and time again to have much faster reflexes than a normal human.

And lastly, for SS to manipulate matter he must first blast a beam to whatever he wants to manipulate. The power must come out of him towards the object. Even that is moot since Diana's gear and her very being has been proven to resist matter transmutation (through magic though). She is highly resistant.

I hate when people bring up fast characters getting hit by slow ones.

Did you read the DOS, or any of his comics since?

Loeb had him using his speed offensively, but he's been rocked many times by slow characters. Get that wishful thinking crap outta here!!

Originally posted by UniOmni
I hate when people bring up fast characters getting hit by slow ones.

Did you read the DOS, or any of his comics since?

Loeb had him using his speed offensively, but he's been rocked many times by slow characters. Get that wishful thinking crap outta here!!

IT stands to reason if Surfer has gotten hit by a slow character, he certainly is going to be hit by One with Superspeed, Faster than light reflexes, magical sandles that augment her speed to the nth degree, and thousands of years of training.

Originally posted by h1a8
SS has no fighting speed. Those scans prove nothing. I constantly see him get hit by beings such as Hulk all day long. Show me where he has awesome enough [B]fighting speed and reflexes to dodge diana's attacks. Because as far as I seen as that every time he is in a fight he lacks even decent reflexes and speed. Don't show any travel speed feats because these have nothing to do with fighting. And understand that is SS much weaker in an atmosphere than space. And know also that if I can travel FTL doesn't mean I have FTL reflexes too nor does it explain how long does it take me to reach a certain travel speed. That is to say, that in human perception it might seem that SS can instantly obtain FTL speed but in Diana's perception it takes a millinium for SS to gain enough speed to be beyond her perception. Thus you can't compare traveling speeds to fighting speeds.

I never claimed IW is faster than Thor. Reflexes is based off sight (such as blocking bullets) and not hearing. You can have poor hearing but great reflexes. You can only attack after the bell. While the bell is ringing then she is getting her shield up (In which she can do instantaneously). If you disagree then at least understand that hearing a bell and responding is much different than seeing something and reacting (and planning before the bell is allowed-this takes away the thought time of getting her shield up).

And Thor throwing his hammer fast has nothing to do with its startup time. He hasn't ever showned to instantly throw his hammer (without any time taking place). Most of the time he whirls it first (building up speed) before throwing. And sue blocking lasers and bullets may be PIS (It happened far too many times though) but it is feasible that this can happen since her very being (molecular) was altered. She is no longer human. So assuming that she must respond in human speed is faulty. Many people here base this solely off of her still looking human and still having human strength (Which is stupidness). Yet she has proven time and time again to have much faster reflexes than a normal human.

And lastly, for SS to manipulate matter he must first blast a beam to whatever he wants to manipulate. The power must come out of him towards the object. Even that is moot since Diana's gear and her very being has been proven to resist matter transmutation (through magic though). She is highly resistant. [/B]

I hoenstly am not even saying SS wins, but what is all this about hearing? I honestly don't know what you are trying to convey here.

And I don't think matter manipulation is truly going to come into play here, but I also don't think he has to blast what he wants to manipulate. Remember when he created life on that planet, he didn't need to blast it with anything. He can create objects such as his board through sheer use of power. I don't see why he would need to blast anything.

Originally posted by h1a8
SS has no fighting speed. Those scans prove nothing. I constantly see him get hit by beings such as Hulk all day long. Show me where he has awesome enough [B]fighting speed and reflexes to dodge diana's attacks. Because as far as I seen as that every time he is in a fight he lacks even decent reflexes and speed. Don't show any travel speed feats because these have nothing to do with fighting. And understand that is SS much weaker in an atmosphere than space. And know also that if I can travel FTL doesn't mean I have FTL reflexes too nor does it explain how long does it take me to reach a certain travel speed. That is to say, that in human perception it might seem that SS can instantly obtain FTL speed but in Diana's perception it takes a millinium for SS to gain enough speed to be beyond her perception. Thus you can't compare traveling speeds to fighting speeds.

I never claimed IW is faster than Thor. Reflexes is based off sight (such as blocking bullets) and not hearing. You can have poor hearing but great reflexes. You can only attack after the bell. While the bell is ringing then she is getting her shield up (In which she can do instantaneously). If you disagree then at least understand that hearing a bell and responding is much different than seeing something and reacting (and planning before the bell is allowed-this takes away the thought time of getting her shield up).

And Thor throwing his hammer fast has nothing to do with its startup time. He hasn't ever showned to instantly throw his hammer (without any time taking place). Most of the time he whirls it first (building up speed) before throwing. And sue blocking lasers and bullets may be PIS (It happened far too many times though) but it is feasible that this can happen since her very being (molecular) was altered. She is no longer human. So assuming that she must respond in human speed is faulty. Many people here base this solely off of her still looking human and still having human strength (Which is stupidness). Yet she has proven time and time again to have much faster reflexes than a normal human.

And lastly, for SS to manipulate matter he must first blast a beam to whatever he wants to manipulate. The power must come out of him towards the object. Even that is moot since Diana's gear and her very being has been proven to resist matter transmutation (through magic though). She is highly resistant. [/B]

Again you haven't shown Diana doing anything whatsoever fast enough to connect with Surfer. A millennium? Based on? The power of exaggeration?

So you're trying to assert that despite that Surfer has displayed the ability to move both his entire body and his limbs in a controlled manner at FTL, he doesn't have equal reactions. So when he flies at FTL speeds he's flying blind. Diana has also been hit by beings slower than her. That doesn't negate that she also has superspeed.

You claimed that Sue would attack Thor first, i.e. faster.
Reflexes is based off perceiving and reacting to sensory stimuli, be it visual or aural. I have no idea why you're trying to say hearing has nothing to do with reflexes.

What bell? The figurative "bell" that means that when a fight has no prep it just starts straight away. Even if one assumes it's a literal bell, Thor still has better reactions, can swing and throw the hammer FTL, and Mjolnir has broken through her forcefields before even if she could get it up before he did anything - which she wouldn't.
Assuming she has FTL reflexes based on "reacting to lasers" is folly; Wolverine, Spider-Man, Captain America and Daredevil do not have FTL reflexes. It's never been stated anywhere that IW gained superhuman reflexes from her transformation by cosmic radiation.

A blast is always needed? Matter manipulation is a psionic power.

All she needs to do is land one punch, and she would ***** him like thanos has.

I cant see this happening at all. Surfer has taken hits from just about everything in the Marvel Universe and survived (ok, the being knocked out by a brick was bullsh1t and I think we all agree on that) so I cant fathom how WW could one punch him. Being knocked around by Thanos isnt a good example if your trying to point out a weakness. Thanos pretty much knocks everybody around.

I just cant see WW ever beating the Surfer regardless of the arguments i've read. I cant see WW being faster than him either even if it is in h2h. Most of the fights Surfer has that are h2h, he pretty much jobs until he realizes he better take it seriously anyways.