srankmissingnin
VP of Comic Knowledge
Originally posted by Alfheim
1. Rapping is not just talking its more compliacted than that. To be a talented rapper you need talent. You need to make good imagery, play on words, metaphors and similies.
You need a merely adequate understanding of imagery, metaphor and simile that any public school kind would have, its not like we are talking about lyrical complexity that rivals William Blake. Its basic stuff.
Originally posted by Alfheim
2. This is the thing if your going to crticize rap at least know something about it. There are lots of rappers that dont rap about gang violence and negative stereotypes.
There are lots of innocent people in jail too... but the vast majority of them are guilty.
There are always exceptions to the rules. Mall rap, Christian rap and in a lot of cases Alt. rap (Jurassic 5 and stuff like that) steer away from the drugs/money/guns/violence "themes"... but that doesn't change the fact that the high majority of rappers fallow those blue prints.
Originally posted by Alfheim
3. Alot of producers play musical instruments and then use tech to sample it.
True enough... but how many producers rap? Not every producer is Timbaland. 😎
Originally posted by Alfheim
4. Ever heard of The Roots?
If I may quote myself...
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Your list is pretty much the embodiment of the what I described though... all though I give Mos Def some props and Kardinal has heavy reggae influenced (but still lousy even though he is Canadian). I could maybe understand listening to Kaos or The Roots or something, but that list is... is... oh never mind.
You'll notice how I mention the Roots. 😉
Originally posted by Alfheim
5. What about screaming in rock vocals? 🤨 You need very little talent for that
You'd be surprised, being able to scream without tearing the vocalcords to shreds is very difficult and you need tons of talent to transition form death growls to high pitch screaming and effortlessly back into the normal vocal range. Who here thinks they can scream for a couple of hours straight with out losing their voice?
I listen all sorts of music. Some of my friends (and my brother) listen to rap, so that means it is forced upon me in large doses when we hang out. Hell, some of the people I know fancy themselves rappers! It's not like I'm talking out of my ass here, I know what I'm talking about.