Infinite Crisis vs. Civil War

Which mini-series was the better of the two?

Crisis.

I thought Civil War was going to be better, but looking back it doesn't match the pure scope of the Crisis.

They were both lackluster.
I'll go with the crisis though,it was more climatic even though I hated Superboy prime and the way Alexander was done in.

Originally posted by Skeets
They were both lackluster.
I'll go with the crisis though,it was more climatic even though I hated Superboy prime and the way Alexander was done in.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Which mini-series was the better of the two?

Annihilation.

I donno, they both had their bad moments

Crisis

-Bart becoming the Flash

-Nightwing NOT dieing when everybody knows he was supposed to

-Amazons with guns WTF?!?

-SuperEMO boy Prime

-Rann/Thanagar war was boring

-Superboy Wall punch retconning

-WAY to many pointless tie-ins

-ect..

Originally posted by Black Adam
Annihilation.

Co-Signed

The best crossover of the year and nobody even gave a crap 🙁

Crisis was most definatley the better of the two.

Originally posted by Juntai
Perhaps lackluster, but still the best comapny-wide crossovers we've seen in ages.

Originally posted by Black Adam
Annihilation.

At least DC had the balls to kill off Blue Beetle who was a hell of a lot more popular than Goliath 😬

Originally posted by Grimm22
At least DC had the balls to kill off Blue Beetle who was a hell of a lot more popular than Goliath 😬

Originally posted by Skeets
Jose123 is so smart..13

✅

Originally posted by Juntai
And Superboy, and Superman of Earth 2 - which was a huge move, imo.

Originally posted by Black Adam
✅

Co-signed. IC was better in almost every way. Yes, there were a few wtf moments, and not in a good way. Compared to the craptacular writing of Civil War, however, it's a minor thing. Yes, Superboy-Prime was way too emo, but he made for a good villain. And Alexander was a great manipulator. More low-key as a villain for most of it, but his plan was impressive in it's scale. His death was well-done. "Your 2nd mistake, was not letting the joker play." 😄

The endings of both sucked IMO.

Well, it's kind of hard to do an ending right. In IC's case, it was because Crisis on infinite earths already did it. Haven't read Civil War's yet.

Crisis was better, but Civil War still kicked ass. I saw one of the more responsible members of the forum posting some crap about comics reverting back to 80's. W.T.F. !!!! Thank god for sophisticated comics.

Crisis...a lot of deaths happen and a new villain introduced.

I still prefer the Secret Wars over Civil War.

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
Crisis...a lot of deaths happen and a new villain introduced.

I still prefer the Secret Wars over Civil War.

Secret Wars I, was bar-none one of the best comic series' to date IMO.

Yea, the first Secret Wars was really good.