Infinite Crisis vs. Civil War

Originally posted by Redatom65
but still, cap being killed would have been ballsy, radical, and nothing short than a perfect ending. Everyone would have stopped and said "what have we done?" Captain America needed to die

Originally posted by Big Sexy
only to return a few months later. 😉

Or just to reveal weeks later that he had conspired with Tony just to make a point.

😆 then it all be retconned

IC started off as one of the greatest things ever. Then, it ended like shit.

IC is on the same level as HOM. Horrible.

Civil War has been great the entire time. CW gets a 8.5 and IC gets a 5.0

Wow......... LP, this is the first time I'm gonna say this. you're full of shit. 😛

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Wow......... LP, this is the first time I'm gonna say this. you're full of shit. 😛

😆 Ouch.

I respect LP's opinion, but IC on the same level as HoM? No friggin way.

HOM was total crap. IC and CW were alot better than that imo.

when I red HoM I had a perfectly wonderful evening. And that evening wasn't it

Originally posted by long pig
IC started off as one of the greatest things ever. Then, it ended like shit.

IC is on the same level as HOM. Horrible.

Civil War has been great the entire time. CW gets a 8.5 and IC gets a 5.0

Am I the only one who liked the ending (minus Superman taking down Superboy)?

Well we're all in luck, Annihilation is coming back this summer 😄

*raises hand* I actually liked the ending, AND Superman beating Superboy.

You D.C fanboys all know, in your heart of hearts, that IC sucked ass. Sucked the hair right off an ass.

Convoluted crap that spend way too much time self referencing to realize it was crap. They should have known that it would be crap for the simple reason that it'd be compared to COIE, and yet have NO chance at topping it

HOM sucked worse, but IC was close behind.

Horrible.

*raises-hand*

Mr. pig? What if your a$s hair was already licked off? Like smurfs? And those of us that didn't like the ending

Conidering he said sucked off,the licked off comment is irelevant.Geez man......

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Wow......... LP, this is the first time I'm gonna say this. you're full of shit. 😛

Have to agree.

Originally posted by long pig
IC started off as one of the greatest things ever. Then, it ended like shit.

IC is on the same level as HOM. Horrible.

Civil War has been great the entire time. CW gets a 8.5 and IC gets a 5.0

I liked Infinite Crisis, but I preferred Civil War. I agree with your rating of Civil War but I'd say Infinite Crisis should be a 7 ✅

Civil War failed because Mark Millar was too ignorant to stick true to the characters

I mean Cap was to stupid to realize that people WANTED people who can blow up buildings to be kept under control?

Iron Man was to ignorant to accept that guys like Daredevil and Spider-Man aren't going to be blowing up schools?

Reed was to caught up in his work to realize that he actually stopped a hero registration more than 20 years ago?

And that Reed, Tony and Hank are to biased to comprehend that building an evil cyborg clone of Thor would be a BAD thing?!?

Hell the character that didn't fall into Civil War's pit of CIS was the Thing as he seemed to realize; Hey, heroes don't fight each other and ignore the fact that they are destroying cities and causing civilian deaths in the process just because neither side will even listen to common sense

I'd like to say you're being biased and trying to make your obvious fav look good.....,but you're right. Ben was probably the best portrayed in the whole thing. I loved how he came back and tried to stop the fighting. 🙂

Annihilation is right behind IC to me. Like someone said before, the scope of IC puts it over the top in my view but Annihilation gets props for making me care about a bunch of C and D list characters I've only heard about in online bios. I'm actually really looking forward to that Nova ongoing.

House of M doesn't even deserve a mention here.