KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by Newjak485 pages

Originally posted by Galan007
tony (high-meta) has stalemated Ronan (low-herald) at least 2 different times.
Meh Tony has also Koed the Hulk, Silver Surfer, Terrax, so on.

He is just gonna get his, just like Batman will.

Doesn't mean they will go up tiers for them. Ronan has better feats, has shown more power.

Originally posted by Galan007
attentionwhore

I even asked about her even before IH #119 🙁

But yes I am 😉

Originally posted by Newjak
One showing, not enough is known about the effects it had on her, or what it really did. Wait a few more issues to find out.

Actually what she did is nothing new as she has already took the form of Tanaraq before another Great Beast. I was asking where we put her before IH #119 as I don't even see her on the list.

Originally posted by Newjak
Meh Tony has also Koed the Hulk, Silver Surfer, Terrax, so on.

He is just gonna get his, just like Batman will.

Doesn't mean they will go up tiers for them.

i disagree with not moving a character 'just because.' if they've got the feats to warrant a move, then they should be moved. but meh, whatevs. 🙂

Originally posted by -K-M-
I even asked about her even before IH #119 🙁

But yes I am 😉

Actually what she did is nothing new as she has already took the form of Tanaraq before another Great Beast. I was asking where we put her before IH #119 as I don't even see her on the list.

Below Herc

😖hifty:

Originally posted by Galan007
tony (high-meta) has stalemated Ronan (low-herald) at least 2 different times - and even beaten terrax (mid-herald). he's also owned quite a few of the characters that are ranked with him, to boot.

Apocalypse (low herald) stalemated The high ev (trans) and defeated Ikaris (mid herald) he also dodged an attack from table (abstract).

Originally posted by llagrok
Apocalypse (low herald) stalemated The high ev (trans) and defeated Ikaris (mid herald) he also dodged an attack from table (abstract).
except tony is far more balanced as a character.

Originally posted by Newjak
Below Herc

😖hifty:

😱

Originally posted by Galan007
except tony is far more balanced as a character.

I don't think Apocalypse has ever lost a battle against anyone while at full power. Even while severely weakened he can take out more than a couple of x-men.

We've had the Iron Man discussion guys. He got stomped both times he was up for low herald. He's clearly among the class of the High Metas, but doesn't warrant the next tier based off of his complete set of showings and powers, which are varied and impressive, but still well below nearly all of the low heralds.

Poccy's another one we've already visited at least once. Let's let them rest.

Nimrod's a whole level lower than Ultron?

Don't see Invincible anywhere ... I'd probably put him at low herald (with Omni Man being mid-high herald)

Whoa ... de ja vu.

😐

Originally posted by Scoobless
Nimrod's a whole level lower than Ultron?

Don't see Invincible anywhere ... I'd probably put him at low herald (with Omni Man being mid-high herald)

Whoa ... de ja vu.

😐

Is he anything but a flying brick though? Invincible, that is? From what I've seen of him, someone like Wonder Man (high meta) or Iron Man might be a good fight for him. He doesn't really strike me as the type to be able to throw down with anything cosmic and have a shot at winning, but maybe I'm wrong.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Is he anything but a flying brick though? Invincible, that is? From what I've seen of him, someone like Wonder Man (high meta) or Iron Man might be a good fight for him. He doesn't really strike me as the type to be able to throw down with anything cosmic and have a shot at winning, but maybe I'm wrong.

He is a flying brick, but he a very fast and durable brick who could get at least 50% wins over a lot of your other low heralds, and frankly there are hardly any high metas on the list that could take wins off of him.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
We've had the Iron Man discussion guys. He got stomped both times he was up for low herald. He's clearly among the class of the High Metas, but doesn't warrant the next tier based off of his complete set of showings and powers, which are varied and impressive, but still well below nearly all of the low heralds.
i disagree with this, personally. but i'll respect your
Spoiler:
wrong
judgement. 😛

Originally posted by Scoobless
He is a flying brick, but he a very fast and durable brick who could get at least 50% wins over a lot of your other low heralds, and frankly there are hardly any high metas on the list that could take wins off of him.
'your' other low heralds. 😂

Originally posted by Galan007
'your' other low heralds. 😂

😎

I know Scoob reads a lot more Invincible than I have, but I figured we needed a devil's advocate. Anyone else want to weigh in on Invincible?

I looked over his respect thread, he seems to be a legit low herald. He lifted a cruise ship with a little help. Not to mention he's fast enough to dash home halfway across the world just to pick up a book, then reappear in the next panel as though nothing happened.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
I looked over his respect thread, he seems to be a legit low herald. He lifted a cruise ship with a little help. Not to mention he's fast enough to dash home halfway across the world just to pick up a book, then reappear in the next panel as though nothing happened.

Aaah, so he's pretty much like Namor? Only faster and without a decent healing factor?

Originally posted by llagrok
Aaah, so he's pretty much like Namor? Only faster and without a decent healing factor?

I don't think Namor could take a lot of the abuse Invincible has survived.

on average, low herald seems about right for invincible. his feats balance out enough to fit that tier, imo.

Ok, how about Darkhawk? I'd probably put his first incarnation in Low-mid meta and his latter (end of series) incarnation at mid-high meta.

the differences between his two forms are definitely worthy of different categories, just not sure which one to start him in.