KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by fangirl101485 pages

Originally posted by Red Hulk
So what are we supposed to do to figure it out? Go by your opinion?

Lulz.

This was based off of a majority, so ya, if people on KMC don't like it, then it's not going to happen.


when I want a response from you, then I'll address you.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Apparently he easily defeated Flash, GLKyle, and CaptAtom all at once. Beyond that I think Highfather or someone said that Takion had "unlimited potential/power" or something.

He's also shifted reality, manipulated anti-matter, played with time a couple of times, shielded people from the effects of the Godwave, teleported beings across the cosmos to precise locations. What herald level being can do that?

Originally posted by fangirl101
when I want a response from you, then I'll address you.
Seeing as you addressed him here in your quote, should he be responding?

Originally posted by fangirl101
He's also shifted reality, manipulated anti-matter, played with time a couple of times, shielded people from the effects of the Godwave, teleported beings across the cosmos to precise locations. What herald level being can do that?
Surfer.

Or, most of it. But for things that he might lack, like the Godwave shield, he has in replace, manipulating energies like the crunch, super duper speeds, cosmic awareness, telepathy, etc.

Originally posted by Faux Smurph
Surfer.

Or, most of it. But for things that he might lack, like the Godwave shield, he has in replace, manipulating energies like the crunch, super duper speeds, cosmic awareness, telepathy, etc.


Can surfer teleport himself and a group of others from the ends of the universe to pinpoint locations of where they all belong in one fell swoop? Can he alter reality? Shift and manipulte time?

Originally posted by fangirl101
Can surfer teleport himself and a group of others from the ends of the universe to pinpoint locations of where they all belong in one fell swoop? Can he alter reality? Shift and manipulte time?
I actually have an extreme dislike for Surfer's powers, and am not going to argue this with you.

Suffice to say, I think you're wrong.

Originally posted by Faux Smurph
I actually have an extreme dislike for Surfer's powers, and am not going to argue this with you.

Suffice to say, I think you're wrong.


I simply asked a question. You can't argue with a question. Can surfer do these things?

Originally posted by fangirl101
I simply asked a question. You can't argue with a question. Can surfer do these things?
Maybe?

I've seen Surfer do a plethora of things as extensions of his powers that make me go "ugh".

So, I don't know.

Call it argue, debate, or simply discussion.

I'll also not argue semantics with you.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Apparently he easily defeated Flash, GLKyle, and CaptAtom all at once. Beyond that I think Highfather or someone said that Takion had "unlimited potential/power" or something.

I seriously hope there is more reason that just that for having him up there.

Originally posted by Avlon
I seriously hope there is more reason that just that for having him up there.

Probably becuz he can shift reality, manipulate time, transport beings across the universe, etc, know everything about someone just by being in thier presence, etc.

Originally posted by fangirl101
when I want a response from you, then I'll address you.
You're not above being talked to by the little people, no matter how much you think you are.

If you say something, then people will answer, and my post addressed your plea, but maybe you didn't want that, did you?

Either way, the voting is as close as we'll get here, and if you don't like it, then don't post here.

Originally posted by Red Hulk
You're not above being talked to by the little people, no matter how much you think you are.

If you say something, then people will answer, and my post addressed your plea, but maybe you didn't want that, did you?

Either way, the voting is as close as we'll get here, and if you don't like it, then don't post here.


Should someone not dissent just becuz it won't make a difference? There are plenty of instances thru out history where the majority got it wrong. Bush 04 anyone?

Originally posted by fangirl101
Should someone not dissent just becuz it won't make a difference? There are plenty of instances thru out history where the majority got it wrong. Bush 04 anyone?
So you would propose we ignore the opinion of the masses because you think you're right?

K, sounds like a plan.

Originally posted by Faux Smurph
So you would propose we ignore the opinion of the masses because you think you're right?

K, sounds like a plan.


no. a dissent is just that. it's always noted. I do think that a lot of the voting here is done for spiteful reasons, or popularity. I can't see why stardust for instance is high herald, when BRB isn't. Why would orion be mid herald when we all know that his higher showings are pretty much beyond everyone except thor, surfer, and superman. I am entitled to my dissent. as is the majority entitled to thier vote.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Should someone not dissent just becuz it won't make a difference? There are plenty of instances thru out history where the majority got it wrong. Bush 04 anyone?
And there are plenty where the majority got it right.

Since this is a tier for KMC, it is only fitting that it is made by KMC, not by nvr... fangirl.

I have to sit and watch Cap, and Black Adam rot away until the right moment to strike, so suck it up. If you want to argue against it, you're more than welcome to, but saying that the majority doesn't matter, is extremely daft and bias.

Originally posted by Red Hulk
And there are plenty where the majority got it right.

Since this is a tier for KMC, it is only fitting that it is made by KMC, not by nvr... fangirl.

I have to sit and watch Cap, and Black Adam rot away until the right moment to strike, so suck it up. If you want to argue against it, you're more than welcome to, but saying that the majority doesn't matter, is extremely daft and bias.


when the hell did I say the majority doesn't matter? is that what you got out of what I said. So much for you being objective and reading what I actually wrote. I think it's daft and bias against me to actually put words in my mouth or totally misinterpret what I said. Which you did. Even after I said that No. I am not ignoring the majority.

Originally posted by Red Hulk
And there are plenty where the majority got it right.

Since this is a tier for KMC, it is only fitting that it is made by KMC, not by nvr... fangirl.

I have to sit and watch Cap, and Black Adam rot away until the right moment to strike, so suck it up. If you want to argue against it, you're more than welcome to, but saying that the majority doesn't matter, is extremely daft and bias.

There is abit of hypocrisy in your statement, but I agree that we should drop Orion at this point. And I concur with the principle behind your statement. Though, she does have the right to dissent.

Fangirl: just drop it already. Motion's obviously beaten. and the difference between mid heralds and high isn't just power, it's also status. But by the same token, the difference in fights can minimal. There are plenty of high heralds who meets the power requirement, but not the status.

Oh well Orion failed but at least Etrigan got through it seems.
I guess we'll have to wait until Final Crisis it's over until Orion goes where he belongs.
Cheers everyone

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
There are plenty of high heralds who meets the power requirement, but not the status.

Like, I wanted Captain Atom up a level because of his power and some feats. However his status in DCU is a b lister, thus he doesn't move up.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Can surfer teleport himself and a group of others from the ends of the universe to pinpoint locations of where they all belong in one fell swoop? Can he alter reality? Shift and manipulte time?
Surfer has shown to shift and manipulate time.

As to teleporting beings across the universe. He hasn't done that, but knowing precise locations of things across the vastness of space. He has done that before.

As to altering reality, Surfer has some nigh crazy feats dealing with the physical world. Some would call it vast Matter Manipulation, but suffice it to say the Surfer can change the world around him if he so chooses to.