KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by Bada's Palin485 pages

Originally posted by Battlehammer
you want me to prove he done all this?

even though you already dam well know he done it? and it in the repsect thread.......

You made the claim, now you have to back it up.

4 times of him healing from a skeleton, or Wolverine's going down.

edit

Granted Logans best time is 80s and early 90s before his God like BS. Some stories now are good like Wolverine Annual #2: Roar, where he can die etc..

http://www.comixology.com/sku/JUL082361/Wolverine-Annual-2-Roar

Either way.....he should stay at low meta.

Originally posted by Red Hulk
Black Adam and Billy are about one tier too low...

👆

Definitley.

Originally posted by Endrict Nuul
Granted Logans best time is 80s and early 90s before his God like BS. Some stories now are good like Wolverine Annual #2: Roar, where he can die etc..

http://www.comixology.com/sku/JUL082361/Wolverine-Annual-2-Roar

Either way.....he should stay at low meta.


and yet no one realizes many of his best feats came from the era......

Question, just the jobbing factor plays in to whos goes where in the tiers

Originally posted by Bada's Palin
Those are PIS events I'm afraid.

Cyclops has enough energy output to match several nukes if he wants to (as we saw in civil war), that's actually more than Black Bolt was capable of. Since Black Bolt is more versatile, I voted to put Cyclops a nudge lower.

.

no blackbolt is capable of way more power then cyclops ever could muster

Originally posted by Endrict Nuul
Is he Angel now or Archangel? because Archangel should be mid or high meta IMO.

he's archangel in x-force, i believe...

Originally posted by Bada's Palin
Cyclops to low herald

you think that's funny?

I think you're funny Raoul.

Originally posted by Bada's Palin
I think you're funny Raoul.

i think you're... you're... hmmm...

Originally posted by Raoul
i think you're... you're... hmmm...

A douche?

Adam and bill are fine where they are.

when you consider people like Flash , BRB , Gladiator . Morg are in the same tier

Originally posted by Raoul
i think you're... you're... hmmm...

You think I'm just super 😎

Originally posted by Bada's Palin
You think I'm just super 😎

if you say so...

God Jul El Sexo.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
That's kinda the point though, no? Not to spin our wheels, I mean, but to reach a point where the only changes needed are either very nuanced ones or ones that could go either way. The lack of obvious changes that need made is a sign of progress. This thread's goal hasn't been to stay active, but to reach a rough consensus. By and large, we've done that (with limited exceptions, of course).

You're misunderstanding me.

When the Sentry was moved down, it was discussed, evidence was given in the form of recent depictions, and then it was voted on. That's the way it should be and why I took issue with Metamorpho.

If you want a character moved, how about giving reasons instead of just throwing up a list of what you have an issue with?

Originally posted by Vally Doosh
You're misunderstanding me.

When the Sentry was moved down, it was discussed, evidence was given in the form of recent depictions, and then it was voted on. That's the way it should be and why I took issue with Metamorpho.

If you want a character moved, how about giving reasons instead of just throwing up a list of what you have an issue with?

Exactly the point I was trying to make.

Originally posted by Vally Doosh
You're misunderstanding me.

When the Sentry was moved down, it was discussed, evidence was given in the form of recent depictions, and then it was voted on. That's the way it should be and why I took issue with Metamorpho.

If you want a character moved, how about giving reasons instead of just throwing up a list of what you have an issue with?

Fair enough. And agreed.

Though again, I'll take it as a slight sign of progress that most of the intense debates are done, and most of our current moves are kinda like "eh, why not?" Not the best way to do business, granted, but indicative of the stability of the list.

Ilgarok, you're going to need to stop trolling. If it continues, it'll be an official warning. The behavior over the last couple pages may not be as obvious to some as it is to me (and hopefully others) but the baiting and trolling need to stop.

Originally posted by Digi
Ilgarok, you're going to need to stop trolling. If it continues, it'll be an official warning. The behavior over the last couple pages may not be as obvious to some as it is to me (and hopefully others) but the baiting and trolling need to stop.

I'm just trying to make a point here.

Technically my suggested changes aren't any worse than Endrict's, but you're giving me a warning because I was a bit more obvious than him?