KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by ExodusCloak485 pages
Originally posted by -Pr-
no offence, but bad example. cyclops being mid meta is ridiculous, tbh, he should be in high.

If Scott is bumped then so should Moonstone, Bishop and Ms. Marvel 😬.

Originally posted by ExodusCloak
If Scott is bumped then so should Moonstone, Bishop and Ms. Marvel 😬.

ms. marvel being in mid is silly.

cyclops > bishop. uhuh

besides, cyclops' position isn't contingent on others being bumped with him. you have to look at him individually and ask does he belong in the company of the people in high meta. i think he does.

Originally posted by -Pr-
ms. marvel being in mid is silly.

cyclops > bishop. uhuh

besides, cyclops' position isn't contingent on others being bumped with him. you have to look at him individually and ask does he belong in the company of the people in high meta. i think he does.

...I hate Bishop but some his feats are quite impressive and Claremont pimped him out in H2H and future cop crap thing as well...that nucleur powered arm adds to it. I'm not against Scott to High-Meta though...I mean if Reed can be there based on his mind then why not. And don't forget Moonstone she seems a lot more impressive in Dark Reign then I remember.

Originally posted by batdude123
Agreed on high meta.

I also agree with Cyclops to high meta.

Originally posted by ExodusCloak
...I hate Bishop but some his feats are quite impressive and Claremont pimped him out in H2H and future cop crap thing as well...that nucleur powered arm adds to it. I'm not against Scott to High-Meta though...I mean if Reed can be there based on his mind then why not. And don't forget Moonstone she seems a lot more impressive in Dark Reign then I remember.

i haven't been reading Dark Reign, so you'd know better than i would, tbh...

Originally posted by Ha Son
I also agree with Cyclops to high meta.

ha-som

Originally posted by -Pr-
i haven't been reading Dark Reign, so you'd know better than i would, tbh...

Oh and Fraction gave you what you wanted btw.

Originally posted by ExodusCloak
Oh and Fraction gave you what you wanted btw.

he did? howso?

Originally posted by -Pr-
he did? howso?

Scott now plans for everything.

Scroll down to guys post the DA stuff...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=382350&pagenumber=474

It's all Scotts idea.

Originally posted by ExodusCloak
Scott now plans for everything.

Scroll down to guys post the DA stuff...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=382350&pagenumber=474

It's all Scotts idea.

i felt completely lost reading that. what was scott's idea?

Originally posted by -Pr-
i felt completely lost reading that. what was scott's idea?
Spoiler:
Emma's Dark X-Men, Emma backstabbing Norman, and reviving and modifying Asteroid M
Originally posted by ExodusCloak
Spoiler:
Emma's Dark X-Men, Emma backstabbing Norman, and reviving and modifying Asteroid M

you mean Scott just

Spoiler:
outwitted the leader of Hammer and played the entire US government?

Originally posted by -Pr-
you mean Scott just
Spoiler:
outwitted the leader of Hammer and played the entire US government?

Yes among other things.

Originally posted by ExodusCloak
Yes among other things.

hmm... maybe i wont have to kill matt fraction after all.

though his characterisation still needs work.

outwitting

Spoiler:
norman osborn
? add that to the list of reasons he should be high meta.

Originally posted by ExodusCloak
If Scott is bumped then so should Moonstone, Bishop and Ms. Marvel 😬.

Yup, and all of those (save maybe bishop) are far more versatile.

Against Cyclops moving up.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Yup, and all of those (save maybe bishop) are far more versatile.

Against Cyclops moving up.

Originally posted by -Pr-
cyclops' position isn't contingent on others being bumped with him. you have to look at him individually and ask does he belong in the company of the people in high meta. i think he does.

Yeah, maybe people didn't get the new memo about a limit on the number of people that could be up for a vote, because that's how a lot of discussion and votes get buried unnecessarily. Cyclops isn't up for a vote. If someone wants to post updated vote counts for Wally, Batman, or Omega Red, feel free. If Cyclops interest is still present, we'll take it up once one of those three is closed.

I'll keep posting this if necessary. Not trying to be a jerk, but increased activity has made it more of an issue, and I'd like to keep things organized.

I'm not voting for anyone to move Cyclops.

Thanks for telling me Paul, but it doesn't change my opinion one way or another. He is in good company where he is and does not fit high meta imo.

Originally posted by Digi
Yeah, maybe people didn't get the new memo about a limit on the number of people that could be up for a vote, because that's how a lot of discussion and votes get buried unnecessarily. Cyclops isn't up for a vote. If someone wants to post updated vote counts for Wally, Batman, or Omega Red, feel free. If Cyclops interest is still present, we'll take it up once one of those three is closed.

I'll keep posting this if necessary. Not trying to be a jerk, but increased activity has made it more of an issue, and I'd like to keep things organized.

Heh, I almost missed this. Here are the votes so far:

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
For Wally to High Herald- Raoul/Pr (Does that count as two?), Kris, Rage, iceman24567, Philosophia, Endless Mike, Average Savage, Naija, Habinger, WarLord, Battlehammer, Leonidas, Creshosk, Enyalus

Against Wally to High Herald- Digi, kgkg, xJLxKing, darthgoober, NewJak, Batdude

That's, 14 for, and 6 against. 15 if you count Pr/Raoul as two votes

Wally needs to be moved.

I'll update it if anyone else votes when I come back, but Wally should be moved with this much votes for.

Originally posted by Digi
Yeah, maybe people didn't get the new memo about a limit on the number of people that could be up for a vote, because that's how a lot of discussion and votes get buried unnecessarily. Cyclops isn't up for a vote. If someone wants to post updated vote counts for Wally, Batman, or Omega Red, feel free. If Cyclops interest is still present, we'll take it up once one of those three is closed.

I'll keep posting this if necessary. Not trying to be a jerk, but increased activity has made it more of an issue, and I'd like to keep things organized.

Well it does seem like the Wally discussion hasn't been going for a while.

Originally posted by Digi
Yeah, maybe people didn't get the new memo about a limit on the number of people that could be up for a vote, because that's how a lot of discussion and votes get buried unnecessarily. Cyclops isn't up for a vote. If someone wants to post updated vote counts for Wally, Batman, or Omega Red, feel free. If Cyclops interest is still present, we'll take it up once one of those three is closed.

I'll keep posting this if necessary. Not trying to be a jerk, but increased activity has made it more of an issue, and I'd like to keep things organized.

i did. i just didn't know we'd passed the limit.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I'm not voting for anyone to move Cyclops.

Thanks for telling me Paul, but it doesn't change my opinion one way or another. He is in good company where he is and does not fit high meta imo.

then read some more comics. uhuh