KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by darthgoober485 pages

Originally posted by batdude123
Batman to low meta

For: leo, batdude123, Creshosk, Battlehammer, Kris Blaze, darthgoober, Nuul, Ha Son, Blanket, Prof. Wagstaff, Badabing, Philosophia, Pr

Against: Rage.Of.Olympus, SuperiorTech, Enyalus, Original Smurph, Digi, Newjak, Endless Mike, Harbinger

13 for, 8 against


You should probably remove my "for" vote since Cap's not being discussed...

Originally posted by darthgoober
Just for the record, I'm only for Bat's getting bumped if Cap does. Bruce has definitely got some firepower and loads of versatility with his utility belt, but Cap's pulled off more "metahuman" level feats IMO. Just thought I'd clarify since at the time I talked about supporting the move I was making a point about Bat's high explosives and Cap didn't really apply in the discussion. Both have areas that they excel in, but overall the two are approximately equal and I don't support either getting bumped unless the other gets bumped too.

I don't support Bat getting bumped without Cap doing the same. But I'm just talking about abstaining, you don't have to switch my vote to "against".

Originally posted by darthgoober
You should probably remove my "for" vote since Cap's not being discussed...

I don't support Bat getting bumped without Cap doing the same. But I'm just talking about abstaining, you don't have to switch my vote to "against".

Cap will get voted on next when the tiers thread gets reopened.

There's no reason for to take your vote away.

Agreed, I will vote for Cap once this gets reopened.

Originally posted by batdude123
Cap will get voted on next when the tiers thread gets reopened.

There's no reason for to take your vote away.


"Voted on" and "voted up" aren't necessarily the same thing. If I knew for a fact that everyone voting for Bats would also vote for Cap it might be different, but I don't know they will and I don't support Bats being in a higher tier. If you counted my vote and for some reason Cap never got bumped I'd just have to come back and argue for Bat's to be bumped back down.

17 for and 10 against

Lots of people voting. 😉

Originally posted by kgkg
Lots of people voting. 😉

Indeed. I haven't seen this kind of involvement in the thread....maybe ever. Not sure what the sudden resurgence is due to.

Originally posted by Digi
Indeed. I haven't seen this kind of involvement in the thread....maybe ever. Not sure what the sudden resurgence is due to.

Batman

Originally posted by jalek moye
Batman

yep. well, that and the blurry lines that have been the subject of so much discussion . . .

Just looked through the names of what is currently in low meta, and I can honestly say I would see no problem with Batman fitting in there (or kicking many of their asses).

For batman to low meta.

👆

For Batman to low meta: 18

Against Batman to low meta: 10

Can we move him yet?

i'm against it..he is where he belong..at Street Level..

Bats=Low Meta

Where's the latest tier list?

I'dd like to view it myself.

Originally posted by ~The Wickerman~
Just looked through the names of what is currently in low meta, and I can honestly say I would see no problem with Batman fitting in there (or kicking many of their asses).

For batman to low meta.

i think it's been pretty well established that bats could take out a lot of the low meta's. at this point, i think many are saying no because if we raised him, it would seem logical to raise a few others. panther, cap and elektra are some good examples.

Originally posted by occultdestroyer
Where's the latest tier list?

I'dd like to view it myself.

original post at the start of the thread...

What makes Batman so dangerous are his prep and resources at hand. With out them, he fits competitively in the high street level.

Nay for Batman being moved up.

Bats kicks Killer Crocs ass on a regular basis. And with no prep, this is all on the fly thinking.

Against batman to be moved up

Originally posted by id369
What makes Batman so dangerous are his prep and resources at hand. With out them, he fits competitively in the high street level.

Nay for Batman being moved up.

you could say the same about iron man. shrug