Should the VS forum be more open?

As for reasons this idea wouldn't work, see posters like 'Spidey-Dude.'

Originally posted by grey fox
That....is perhaps the STUPIDEST thing I have EVER READ !

Well it's the truth.

Originally posted by grey fox
That....is perhaps the STUPIDEST thing I have EVER READ !

Yeah . . . wow thats fuked up.

It makes more sense than continually having retcons every month

No it doesn't. Thats really more convoluted than retcons.

How so? It sets up everything in a simple hierarchy with only 4 levels, and the majority of material falls into C - canon.

Originally posted by Soljer
As for reasons this idea wouldn't work, see posters like 'Spidey-Dude.'

Originally posted by Endless Mike
How so? It sets up everything in a simple hierarchy with only 4 levels, and the majority of material falls into C - canon.

Well what do the cannonical levels even mean?

Originally posted by Validus
What do you mean?

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/450231_1-elektra-vs-chunli

Originally posted by Charlotte DeBel
Actually, an example of STUPID combined thread was created not long ago, it's "Chun Li vs Electra". No stipulations whether it's game or comics version of ChunLi, no bio of ChunLi- nothing. Such threads should be banned as examples of trolling...

Notice that Spidey-douche made this the following day. It wasn't like Charlotte was talking about that exact thread, but she might as well have been.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Well what do the cannonical levels even mean?

If something lower in the hierarchy conflicts with something above it, that which is lower is thrown out.

If something lower in the hierarchy DOESN'T conflict with anything above it, it's acceptable.

I'm not going to say I like the 'levels' of canon, but it's certainly understandable.

Originally posted by Soljer
If something lower in the hierarchy conflicts with something above it, that which is lower is thrown out.

If something lower in the hierarchy DOESN'T conflict with anything above it, it's acceptable.

I'm not going to say I like the 'levels' of canon, but it's certainly understandable.

OK that does make sense but without context is looks really ecclectic.

We can stop the name-calling Soljer. The thread was closed but that doesn't excuse the belittling.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
that doesn't excuse the belittling.

The forum really should be more open because right now it is really stale. Every thing has been done... and a lot of them have been done and more then once. Allow manga/games/books would really expand the options we have right now... and the forum fights are desperately in need of verity/creativity.

A a reboot of the VS forum would be another idea... make all the old rehashed threads feel new again! 🙁

KMC: CrisisOnInfiniteThreads

Originally posted by DigiMark007
We can stop the name-calling Soljer. The thread was closed but that doesn't excuse the belittling.

Awww, it used to! 😛.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
KMC: CrisisOnInfiniteThreads

If we allowed all genres, there really would be a crisis, and there really would be an infinite number of threads....

Originally posted by Soljer
If we allowed all genres, there really would be a crisis, and there really would be an infinite number of threads....

😂 I was responding to Srank's call for a reboot.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
KMC: CrisisOnInfiniteThreads

😎

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
😂 I was responding to Srank's call for a reboot.

I realize. Just commenting.

There was the one before- but it survived only 7 posts long and was veery ridiculous.
I can find a link for previous one- which was also created by Spidey-dude. Stubborn ass...f*ckingly stubborn....