Superheroes (without powers) slug fest

Originally posted by Cap'n Happy
Again, foolish. Thor is a brute. Do me a favor pal... go into a gym in any big city, walk up to some 6'6'' dude- a guy around three hundred pounds and enough muscle on him to snap your neck like a twig...
and kick him in the balls.
Shroud be easy, right? And think of your rep... you'd be the man!
Please try to be a little realistic. Thor is a Viking War-god. Have you seen how Vikings fight? Go rent Gladiator and watch the opening battle scene. The Viking's were berserker warriors... they even scared the Roman legions. Take a look at those gigantic blood lusting warions and tell me a skinny little woman could even get a kick to the balls in, let alone stop such a fighter. It would NEVER happen. One punch from such a powerful man would shatter a woman's jaw... it's called truth.

Dude, this is comics and not real life. I am the one that's being comic realistic and your trying to be real life realistic where most of it doesn't apply here.

1. Wonder Woman
2. Colossus
3. Thing
4. Superman
5. Thor
6. Juggernaut
7. Silver Surfer
8. Flash
9. Spider-Man

Originally posted by [BAW]Endrict
Dude, this is comics and not real life. I am the one that's being comic realistic and your trying to be real life realistic where most of it doesn't apply here.

Your point is taken- in fact, I recognized this point in an earlier post. But the thread started out stripping all characters of superpower, so doesn't this fight have to reflect at least a little reality?
I grant you that Diana would get her share of wins. I have her beating Superman- depowered, he lacks the tools to beat her. She would win against a lot of non-supers... Hawkeye, Hank Pym, Peter Parker, Barry Allen... she would mop the floor with guys like this. But it's just ignorant to have her surviving, let alone winning against Thor. Even Grimm wins fairly easily. You could debate Colossus and Juggs (still think they win), but not Thor.
Love WW all you want- with powers, she's awesome, argue her merits all day long. In this (non-super, hence, non "comic"😉 fight, Thor thrashes her around like a rag doll.

Originally posted by iceman24567
I agree with you in a way Thor weighs way more than 300 pounds which makes it somewhat unfair but remember what Wonder Womans background contains. She a bloody amazon not only are they physically fit but they train to beat men in battle they use the male physique against them i wouldn't say she would win but Thor isn't one shotting any amazon that easily.

WW of Thor, WW has more skill, but without powers due to his massive build he would be much stronger.

I just thought of Rocky 4...but instead of Roco and Ivan it's Ben vs Pitor. But Pitor wins.

Originally posted by [BAW]Endrict
I just thought of Rocky 4...but instead of Roco and Ivan it's Ben vs Pitor. But Pitor wins.

Originally posted by iceman24567
I'm sure if Piotr killed Reed in a fight Ben would be like Rocky and win against Piotr.

...it's possible in that situation, yes. But other times Pitor wins.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Wonder Woman 1st Place
Thor 2nd Place
Thing 3rd

have to agree WW would win on pure knowledge and her fighting instincts. weather she fought a female or male foe me thinks.

Originally posted by Dark-Jaxx
WW of Thor, WW has more skill, but without powers due to his massive build he would be much stronger.

one thing ya gota love bout wonderwoman. She can be mean and agressive. I dont care how big thor is. He still has a penis, and one boot to the nuts and its goodnight thor. 🙂

i've been thinking, if we took all their powers away, it would be

dr blake
diana prince
norin rodd
clark cent
ben grim
peter
peter parker
wally
cane marco

soooo.....

peter
ben grim
cane marco
peter parker
clark kent
wally
diana
dr blake

mwahahahaha

Thor
Diana
Ben

Originally posted by zeel
one thing ya gota love bout wonderwoman. She can be mean and agressive. I dont care how big thor is. He still has a penis, and one boot to the nuts and its goodnight thor. 🙂

No he doesn't, who told you that?

Originally posted by FrothByte
There have often been times in comics when the superhero's powers were removed and he/she had to fight as a normal human being. So who would win in an all out brawl between the following considering that ALL their super powers were removed and they had to fight as just normal human beings:

Thing
Flash
Colossus
Superman
Thor
Silver Surfer
Wonder Woman
Juggernaut
Spiderman

bump

1. Thing
2. Colossus
3. Thor
4. Wonder Woman
5. Juggernaut
6.Superman
7.Flash
8. Silver Surfer
9. Spiderman

Diana or Thor.

My first thought would be Diana because of demonstrated skill. (Thor would be close)

But, even without powers, wouldn't Thor's Asgardian physiology give him more strength and endurance?

I was wondering something along the same line as well. Amazons are naturally stronger than humans as well. When the OP said without powers, did he also include traits that are inherent to other races?

Thor
Wonder Woman
Thing