Allankles
Kwisatz Haderach
Originally posted by Thiru
She said it could not be taught, only given yet its pretty much safe to assume sidious learnt it seeing that the visual guide said he learnt the dark side secrets from holocrons
Refuted
She never said it could only be given, she said it had to be experienced to be acquired. Nothing has been refuted, pLus Nihilus powers were complicated by the fact that he was a wound in the force, what Sidious did to the inhabitants of Byss, was a lot less severe.
Originally posted by Thiru
Sorry but she fails, shes fallible, she claims tulak hord uses a lightsaber and the best of the ancient sith, but ancient sith used swords and she never recovered his holocron nor ever saw any of them fight.
How does this discredit anything? Tulak Horde didn't belong to the era of Sith that fought in the Hyperspace war. Two, based on the fact that Tulak Horde canonically belonged to a different generation it can be deduced that in his era lightsabers were used by the Sith. Third, in the comic we only see one generation of Sith, so how the hell can you say the ancients only used swords?
Originally posted by Thiru
As for revan, she personally knew and witnessed everything she did which equates to you being an *******.
Don't be juvenile. Who was arguing against this?
Originally posted by Thiru
This is irrelevant to the fight so ill drop it, but the fact remains she is fallible, she claims he is the greatest saber duelist but did she ever see him fight? Was she there to witness his acomplishments? Simple answer: [b] hell no. So she is speculating[/B]
She was a historian. She would have read something about what other historians (closer to Tulak Hordes era) would have written about him. She wouldn't just be speculating without their being information on Tulak. Otherwise, why talk about some random Sith she has no idea about? It wouldn't make sense. Would you speculate over anything you have no information about?
Originally posted by Thiru
The thing is i have, the thing is sidious learning techniques via holocrons which kreia stated that it cannot be learnt pretty much proves her wrong, and due to the fact she has nothing to back her claim of tulak being the greatest saber duelist as she never saw him once nor got his holocrons.
Sidious' draining technique it can be argued wasn't the exact same thing as Nihilus'. Whereas Sidious gradually drew force energy from the inhabitants of Byss, Nihilus breached the connection between life and the force and fed on the DEATH it created. So based on that evidence, they appear to be similar techniques but very different in the way they are applied.
Sidious never actually breached force connections, Like Nihilus did, nor did he feed on the ds energy released form their deaths.
Originally posted by Thiru
Doesn't change the fact revan >>>> exile.
I like how you try to make a point, without the effort of making a point.
Originally posted by Thiru
You also have to remember that it was revans [b] strength in the force which allows him to accomplish his greatest feat of draining malachors dark side energies, And please prove up where it said because she was emotionally unstable, it destroyed her, The last i recall she herself admitted that revan could do that to malachor while it overwhelmed her despite her efforts to repel the dark energies.[/B]
"JEDI MASTER KREIA, Revan's old mentor, is still haunted by guilt, wondering whether it was her teaching that resulted in Revan's fall to the dark side, and begins to search for him. Sensing his last location, she travels to Malachor V, but is unable to shield her emotions, and is completely consumed by the dark side of the Force." --- The Chronicles
Happy! She was emotionally unbalanced, not weak. Kreia seems like someone with a lot of will power, she should have been able to resist Malachor 5's ds energy, if not for the heavy emotions she carried with her going into Malachor.
Originally posted by Thiru
No, from your perspective the exile has slightly better achievements
Equal in greateness, not strength and power.
My point is, as a Jedi she has the showing and quotes to be put on par with Revan.
Originally posted by Thiru
Uh you did, that his "hunger reacts faster than the other force user".
That's your childish assumption. My point is he's got an "ace in the hole", an edge over most force sensitives. Drawing up scenarios is pointless.
Originally posted by Thiru
Oh so me argueing for revan or exar = me being a fanboy, Your an idiot, i dont even like exar kun. How can i be labelled a fanboy when i merely argued on the characters side? ".
You reacted like a fanboy. Drawing up scenarios, listing down techniques and weapons Kun would use to disintegrate Nihilus in an instant. You should at least have recognized the advantage Nihilus has over his opponents. He's one of the few Sith who can defeat his opponents without ever needing to draw his saber.
Originally posted by Thiru
I might as well dispute you a raging hormone fanboy of the exile seeing that you claim she > revan without proof and you use speculation to back your assertions".
No proof? How about the supporting evidence I've listed down time and again? Really, you need to stop disregarding points simply because you don't like them.
Originally posted by Thiru
Nihilus would actually be at a greater disadvantages, seeing that he is always in a weakened state when he hungers".
That's only if you make the assumption that he'll be weakened when he faces any of your heroes. He's weakened when he tried to drain the Exile, and then by long delays before feeding. You'd have to assume both scenarios taking place.
Originally posted by Thiru
I guess luke and sidious would be at a disadvantage too. You cant prove it
I don't really care about Sidious and Luke. You cango ahead and think they're both indestructible except towards each other but the point is, as long as they have a connection to the force they are vulnerable.
Originally posted by Thiru
Common sense would obviously indicate a superior force user would be at an advantage. The fact weather his hunger will react or not is irrelevant
What do you mean superior? A person with force energy equal to or greater than planet draining level? You don't seem to get it, force sensitives are like magnets to Nihilus. The greater the force reserves the more he's "magnetized".
Originally posted by Thiru
Neither does he kill you with a singular technique, he tried to kill kreia with that technique and it didnt work, simply because she is stronger than him in so many aspects of the force
Yet it was stated he cuts off his victims off the force, kills them then feeds on the death it causes,
How old are you? Is this how you argue? Ignore when my arguments is refuted, and hope that I pwn him with constant repetition? I'll say it again, Nihilus never intended to kill Kreia. If Sion and Nihilus wanted her dead they would have killed her easily in her weakened state, when they had her at their mercy.
Secondly, and most importantly Kreia said that the Nihilus and Sion wanted her alive, thinking to humiliate an break her will. They wanted her broken not dead.
Originally posted by Thiru
Uh no, he feeds on the death he causes idiot, you just contradicted yourself
Who denied that? In your sorry excuse for a breakdown you mentioned that Nihilus doesn't kill you instantly and you went to break down the process inaccurately to make an irrelevant point. Nihilus does kill you instantly. He breaches/servers your connection to the force, thereby killing you. He then feeds on the residual dark side energy caused by the breach. Instead of using the word DEATH, I say 'residual dark side' energy (because 'death' is ambiguous).
Originally posted by Thiru
Wow so because he hungers and performs one feat, it means he is superior to the both of them, i guess he would >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> sidious too because sidious never planned to do that to the galaxy when he could
Man you don't know how to make a point. I said, Revan and Kun have never been shown to possess the dark side energy required to sever a planets connection with the force i.e. to drain a planets life. Because of this Nihilus possesses a greater reserve of ds energy than either Kun or Revan.
It doesn't matter if you can do as many techniques as they are colours, I'm talking about latent force power here.