Mixed Genre & Comic Tier Reference Guide

Originally posted by Black bolt z
I am

I want proof that he weighs 700 tons.Show me proof.

Ok.I take a panetary threat to be something that can destroy the planet.Wiping out the worlds dinosaurs are within the grounds of heralds.

And was it really as strong as adamantium?Marvel adamantium?If so what proof?

Try to jump while carrying 200 pounds or so on your back. Let us see how high you get off the ground compared to your norm. Jack was able to leap hundreds of feat with huge boulders weighing him down.

2. WATCH THE CARTOON ON THE LINK.

3. You act like Heralds are not planetary threats or something. 😐 Or that Mace Windu is on Herald level. Aku would be about low Herald IMO.

4. Point out where I said it was as durable as Marvel Adamantium. Jack also routinely slices through steel, and pretty much whatever he needs to, it was blessed by the powers of three cosmic deities.

Originally posted by NemeBro
1. A statement that stupid doesn't actually warrant a response. 😐

Try to jump while carrying 200 pounds or so on your back. Let us see how high you get off the ground compared to your norm. Jack was able to leap hundreds of feat with huge boulders weighing him down.

2. WATCH THE CARTOON ON THE LINK.

3. You act like Heralds are not planetary threats or something. 😐 Or that Mace Windu is on Herald level. Aku would be about low Herald IMO.

4. Point out where I said it was as durable as Marvel Adamantium. Jack also routinely slices through steel, and pretty much whatever he needs to, it was blessed by the powers of three cosmic deities.

Ok.Whats the highest he has jumped?

Can you just post it?I wouldn't even know where to look.

They are.Mace is not a herald.Some jedi are but not mace.That sounds OK to me.And its well within reason for a mid meta to beat a low herald.Very well within reason.

You didn't.Thats what I asked.It is?I also believe its a very strong sword.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Some contridictions are anikan not being made a master in the third movie and he is a TV show.Another is anikan makes reference to the last encounter between him and douku being in AotC and in the new TV show they encountered multiple times.Thats just two. I am

He doesn't specifically say when he last encountered Dooku. He could very well be referencing an event in the show itself.

The master thing is a goof, just like them referring to Asajj Ventress as a Sith even though she clearly isn't and never will be a true Sith. It doesn't make the show non-canon, especially when the official position of George Lucas is that it IS just as canon as the earlier cartoon.

There is not one statement by anyone in any official capacity ruling the Clone Wars cartoon as Non-Canon. BB you're wrong, just admit it.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Oh wow. Yeah that completely destroys the canonicity.

He doesn't specifically say when he last encountered Dooku. He could very well be referencing an event in the show itself.

The master thing is a goof, just like them referring to Asajj Ventress as a Sith even though she clearly isn't and never will be a true Sith. It doesn't make the show non-canon, especially when the official position of George Lucas is that it IS just as canon as the earlier cartoon.

There is not one statement by anyone in any official capacity ruling the Clone Wars cartoon as Non-Canon. BB you're wrong, just admit it.

No because obi-wan says "this time we take him together" when in the show they took him together before.

Scans or something having lucas say it is as canon?To me it definitly seems less canon then the other cartoon but what lucas says is law so...

Can you show something saying it is canon?

Ok mabye it is canon but to me it just seems like it should be at least one magnitude less canon then the original TV show.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
It doesn't destroy it but it does contridict it.

No because obi-wan says "this time we take him together" when in the show they took him together before.

Scans or something having lucas say it is as canon?To me it definitly seems less canon then the other cartoon but what lucas says is law so...

Can you show something saying it is canon?

Ok mabye it is canon but to me it just seems like it should be at [b]least one magnitude less canon then the original TV show. [/B]

Didn't you read what I posted? That is the evidence of its canonicity. The fact George Lucas made a new level of canon (above books and comics) just for the show demonstrates that it is canon. Those little contradictions don't make the entire show non-canon, just those little parts non-canon.

No. It is entirely equal in canonicity to the original show, in fact it is intended to fill in the gaps between seasons of the original cartoon.

Remember the golden rule: if it doesn't clash directly with the movies, it's canon mother****er.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Why must you refer to any kind of evidence regardless of medium as "scans"?

Didn't you read what I posted? That is the evidence of its canonicity. The fact George Lucas made a new level of canon (above books and comics) just for the show demonstrates that it is canon. Those little contradictions don't make the entire show non-canon, just those little parts non-canon.

No. It is entirely equal in canonicity to the original show, in fact it is intended to fill in the gaps between seasons of the original cartoon.

Remember the golden rule: if it doesn't clash directly with the movies, it's canon mother****er.

He made it for the original show.

😂 And some of that show does clash.So do we just throw those out as non-canon?

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Because saying scans/videos/bios etc... is longer then just scans.I don't like wasting time.

He made it for the original show.

😂 And some of that show does clash.So do we just throw those out as non-canon?

He made it for all three shows, the old cartoon, the CGI toon, and the future live action show.

That's what I said isn't it? Just pretend that no one called Anakin Master and everything will be right as rain.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Yet you waste time on this futile argument against logic and hard facts?

He made it for all three shows, the old cartoon, the CGI toon, and the future live action show.

That's what I said isn't it? Just pretend that no one called Anakin Master and everything will be right as rain.

Future live action show?Never heard of that one.But he made it for the original then it would have carried on to the new show.

So throw asoka tano out as non-canon?Fine with me.Don't like her.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
What facts?Can you just post a scan/video/bio etc...happy?

Future live action show?Never heard of that one.But he made it for the original then it would have carried on to the new show.

So throw asoka tano out as non-canon?Fine with me.Don't like her.

Read this: http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Canon

Ahsoka doesn't contradict anything in the films even if she's never mentioned. She's fully canon as far as Lucas and Co are concerned. Deal with it fanboys.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
The statement I posted that is supported by George Lucas.

Read this: http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Canon

Ahsoka doesn't contradict anything in the films even if she's never mentioned. She's fully canon as far as Lucas and Co are concerned. Deal with it fanboys.

Its says that the live action series and the 2003 series is canon.Not the current TV show.The movie but not the TV show.Thats directly from the link you posted.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
T-canon,[2] or Television Canon[3], refers to the canon level comprising the feature film Star Wars: The Clone Wars and the two television shows Star Wars: The Clone Wars and the Star Wars live-action TV series.[4][5] It was devised recently in order to define a status above the C-Level canon, as confirmed by Chee[6].

Its says that the live action series and the 2003 series is canon.Not the current TV show.The movie but not the TV show.Thats directly from the link you posted.

As a matter of fact it doesn't mention the original at all.

Perhaps the original cartoon is the non-canon one? vin

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Read again. The name of the CGI series is "Star Wars: THE Clone Wars" the original was named "Star Wars: Clone Wars."

As a matter of fact it doesn't mention the original at all.

Perhaps the original cartoon is the non-canon one? vin

It just has many more contridictions then the first TV show.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Sorry I misread it.Your right.

It just has many more contridictions then the first TV show.

it's being built as the real bridge between the last two movies, showing anakin's fall in more depth, so it was bound to have them. this is lucas after all; he has one trilogy contradicting another...

one of my favorite ****ups is him making anakin create a protocol droid to help his mom with housework.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
one of my favorite ****ups is him making anakin create a protocol droid to help his mom with housework.

Originally posted by Creshosk
How is that a quadruple asterisk up?

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Because why would you need a protocol droid for house work?Wouldn't a maid or cleaning droid or something like that be more effective?

Can we get an updated list soon?

hi

Update in progress.