Mixed Genre & Comic Tier Reference Guide

Started by Black bolt z307 pages

Why is Goku SS4 only high herald?I would put him as like cube being level.Kid buu was able to blow up a planet in about 5 sec.Goku SS4 is multiple tiers above him.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Why is Goku SS4 only high herald?I would put him as like cube being level.Kid buu was able to blow up a planet in about 5 sec.Goku SS4 is multiple tiers above him.

😆

No one in DBZ can destroy more than a planet by feats.

Cube Beings are universe - level reality warpers.

Re: Updated Listing

Originally posted by illadelph12

(Votes/Still in discussion)

[b]Sub-Skyfather (Transcendent):

Dark Schneider (1) **, KOS MOS (2), Ideon (1), Belldandy (1), Pyron (1)

High Herald:
KOS MOS (2), Alucard (1), Kain from Legacy of Kain (1) Dark Scneider (1), Pyron (2), Guyver Dreadnaught (1), Nono Diebuster (4)*

Mid Herald:
Alucard (1), Kelthuzad (1), Kain from Legacy of Kain (2), Lina Inaverse (1), Anubis and Jehuty (1), Aku (1)

Low Herald:
Alucard (1), Darth Nihilus (2), Ganondorf (3)*, Gouki (1, Kratos GOW1 (2), KOS MOS (Weakest)(2), ), Mega Man (1)**, Rugal Bernstein (1), Master Asia (2), Sephiroth (2), Kratos (1), SDF-1 (Macross)(1), Hancock(1),

Against Mega Man (1)

High Meta:
Sora (2), Cutie Honey (1), Rugal Bernstein (1), Aizen Sousuke (2), Mega Man (2), Naruto (2), Gouki (2), Sephiroth (1), Hayabusa (all equip) (1) Naruto (1), Master Asia (2). Dante (DMC) (1), Samus (1), Guyver (1), Crocodile (1), Dio Brando (1), K' (1), Kain(1), Skull Knight (2), Veritech Fighter (Macross)(1)

Against Naruto (1), Against K (1)

Mid Meta:
Legato (2), Seras (2), Cutie Honey (1), Aizen Sousuke (1), Sephiroth, (1), Mega Man (1), Link (4)*, Alucard (2), Ryu Hayabusa (1) Naruto (2) K' (1), Itachi Uchiha (3)*, Dante (DMC)(1), Alita (1), Recca (1), Kain (3)*, Goku (Base Form)(2), Agent (Crackdown, Max Stats)(1), Mr. Incredible (1)

Low Meta:
Ryu Hayabusa (3)*, Alita (BAA) (1), Vash the Stampede (3)*, K' (3) *, Gara (BASTARD!!) (1), Dune Freman (1), Ed (FMA)(1), Killua (1), Caerula Sanquis (1), Kenshiro (2), Afro Samurai (1), Rurouni Kenshin (1), Master Chief (1), Paladin Anderson (1), Samurai Jack (1), Kull Warriors (SG1) (1), Mace Windu (1) , Lu Bu (2), Makoto Shishio (1)

High Street:
Spike Spiegel (3)*, Cyrano d’Begerac (2), Dune Sardaukar (1), Lone Wolf and Cub (1), Dune Fremen (1), Data (2), Boba Fett (1), Brock Sampson (1)

Mid Street:
Chewbacca (1), Worf (1), D’Artagnian (1), El Zorro (1), Alan Quartermain (1), Dune Sardaukar (1), Teal'c (1),

Low Street:
Lone Ranger (1), Athos (2), Porthos (2), Aramis (2)

Notes:

* = Enough votes for placement (3+). [/B]


For:
Seras to Mid Meta
Chewbacca to Mid Street
Master Chief to Low Meta
Rurouni Kenshin to Low Meta
Kain to High Meta
Alan Quartermain to Mid Street
El Zorro to Mid Street
Worf to Mid Street

Against:
Naruto to High Meta
Samus Aran to High Meta
Kain to Mid Herald, High Herald
Alucard to High Herald, Mid Herald, and Low Herald

Propose:
Alucard to High Meta
Samus Aran to Mid Meta
Disney's Hercules to Mid Meta

Amend:
Change my proposal of Mace Windu from Low to Mid Meta.
Change my proposal of Paladin Anderson from Low to Mid Meta.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Yeah. He wiped out a civilization of billions with just an angry thought and was able to create sentient constructs out of nothingness.

That was one of my favorite episodes. I always wished they'd explored the Douwd race further, particularly whether they had any interactions with the Q Continuum and were on or around the same power level. I also wish they'd have explained more about that race that made Barcley into a super-genius and had him transport the Enterprise to the center of the universe.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
😆

No one in DBZ can destroy more than a planet by feats.

Cube Beings are universe - level reality warpers.

Not like entire galaxys but kid buu was able to destroy a dozen planets a minute.SS4 Goku is many tiers above him.If not cube being I would at least put him like on odin level.Considering he fought someone on the same power level as shenron who could grant any wish.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Not like entire galaxys but kid buu was able to destroy a dozen planets a minute.SS4 Goku is many tiers above him.If not cube being I would at least put him like on odin level.Considering he fought someone on the same power level as shenron who could grant any wish.

GT is not canon.

I'm also for dropping Naruto from High Meta

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
GT is not canon.

I'm also for dropping Naruto from High Meta

Then why is a GT character on the list ?!?!

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Then why is a GT character on the list ?!?!

Because I put him there to tease you.

GT is canon, just not canon to the Manga. It's only canon to the cartoon version of Goku. People just like claiming that since Toriyama didn't personally script all the happenings in the DBZ and DBGT episodes that they don't count, but that's not the case.

Toriyama scripted manga is canon to the Manga version of Goku.

Toriyama inspired cartoon adaptation version of Goku as depicted in Dragonball through Dragonball GT is a different character and the whole of it (DB to DBGT) is canon to that specific adaptation.

They're mutually exclusive but people like to mix them up in debates to hamstring their opposition. Particularly when arguing Goku vs. a comic character.

I guess we'll need to distinguish which version of a character we're placing as well for clarity.

Originally posted by illadelph12
Voltron (5 lions) for Mid Herald.

Feats that make him past low herald?

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Not like entire galaxys but kid buu was able to destroy a dozen planets a minute.SS4 Goku is many tiers above him.If not cube being I would at least put him like on odin level.Considering he fought someone on the same power level as shenron who could grant any wish.

...and this doesn't help...

^ sorry if this makes me sound stupid but all of that besides "decide which version of goku" went way over my head...

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Because I put him there to tease you.
ha-som

Originally posted by Bentley
Feats that make him past low herald?

I'll post some clips when I get home from work. Behind a firewall here. But basically Voltron slays some pretty high end Robeasts on a regular basis, and it could be argued that these Robeasts are at least Mid to High Herald tier (planetary threats). There's no matter manipulation or anything like that, but Voltron is exponentially more powerful than, say, Ironman.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
^ sorry if this makes me sound stupid but all of that besides "decide which version of goku" went way over my head...

facepalm

Ok.

Here it is in crayon:

Cartoon canon to cartoon.

Comic canon to comic.

Cartoon Goku no equal Comic Goku.

Cartoon Goku different character.

While were on the subject of character versions, can I make a suggestion regarding Link?

Link is many different people, but you've put them all under one name on the list in the same tier. I suggest we split them up into thier individual selves.

OoT/MM Link
WW/PH Link
LoZ/LoZ II Link
aLttP Link
TP Link

ect, with an "Omni Link" as well, for when people don't feel like specifying one game, and/or making Link extremely broken for his tier.

Originally posted by illadelph12
facepalm

Ok.

Here it is in crayon:

Cartoon canon to cartoon.

Comic canon to comic.

Cartoon Goku no equal Comic Goku.

Cartoon Goku different character.

So at the beginning
of the match decide if we are allowed to use the goku canon to just the magna or just the anime?

If you make a match using Goku specify which version. You can say, for example:

Goku (Manga) Vs.

or

Goku (Cartoon) Vs.

Goku (Manga) is the Toriyama version from the comic.

Goku (Cartoon) is the version of Goku as depicted in the televised cartoon series from DragonBall through DragonBall GT, which is "inspired" by the Manga version but is a different adaptation.

Got it.Thanks.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
While were on the subject of character versions, can I make a suggestion regarding Link?

Link is many different people, but you've put them all under one name on the list in the same tier. I suggest we split them up into thier individual selves.

OoT/MM Link
WW/PH Link
LoZ/LoZ II Link
aLttP Link
TP Link

ect, with an "Omni Link" as well, for when people don't feel like specifying one game, and/or making Link extremely broken for his tier.

I like this idea. I think we should do it for Megaman as well.

Sounds about right, Megaman and Megaman X have a wide gap between them.