Superman vs. Captain America's Shield

Originally posted by 753
he wont even dent it and CA would survive it. the shield apparently cant be overloaded and any kinetic energy that hits it directly will be absorbed and have its effects negated.

well taht craps on every time i see Cap knocked away while holding the shield.

Hell even once Cap was dropped off a building by Rock Python and landed on the shield. The shield absorbed most of the impact, but Cap then admitted taht he still hurt his back.

Originally posted by 753
yes, I too find its displayed defenses against area attacks a ridiculous plot device. personally, I label them all PIS

To wrest the shield from Cap you would need Batman, Reed Richards, Lex Luthor, Doctor Doom and a full month's prep time

Originally posted by Solidus Black
To wrest the shield from Cap you would need Batman, Reed Richards, Lex Luthor, Doctor Doom and a full month's prep time

Originally posted by Omega Vision
It doesn't make it better that some Cap fans act like its impossible to just wrest the shield from him and toss it aside and then commence to crushing him like a can.

Supes could likely dent the shield. He ain't breaking it, though.

If this is a *serious* question (and not just trolling...)...

As the shield is not magical (as Wonder Woman's bracers/lasso, or Dr. Strange's Eye, etc), it is possible that with *supreme*, *sustained*, the-fate-of-the-world-is-at-stake -- effort, Superman has *some* chance of being able to *dent*/otherwise deform Cap's shield... but that isn't happening casually, by any means, and he sure isn't punching a hole through it. Also, his hands/knuckles would likely be very badly hurt during/afterwards, similar to original Superman's hands after pummeling on/breaking through the crystal wall/barrier Alex Luthor made as a barrier between the Pre- and Post- Crisis realities...

Originally posted by Solidus Black
well taht craps on every time i see Cap knocked away while holding the shield.

Hell even once Cap was dropped off a building by Rock Python and landed on the shield. The shield absorbed most of the impact, but Cap then admitted taht he still hurt his back.

Dent it, yes.

Punch a hole through it, doubt it.

Ain't even denting it.

Cap's shield is the GOAT.

Originally posted by Starscream M
not impossible...but very difficult

Dent it, No.

Punch a hole through it, No.

Didn't king Thor do it with strength alone?

Originally posted by rotiart
Didn't king Thor do it with strength alone?

During the Ironman fight, there was energy surrounding the hammer when he hit it. and that energy would be magical in nature.

Originally posted by Galan007
Supes could likely dent the shield. He ain't breaking it, though.

Naah, gladiator was punching caps shield with everything he had for a long period of time and it didn't do anything to the shield.

Originally posted by carver9
Naah, gladiator was punching caps shield with everything he had for a long period of time and it didn't do anything to the shield.

Originally posted by rotiart
Didn't king Thor do it with strength alone?

Originally posted by Galan007
He put a softball-sized dent in it, yeah.

He certainly did old pal, but you and i are probably the only ones who've read the comic.

Heh.

I thought you deserted KMC, my friend.