Originally posted by Imperial_Samura
I really think you need to define "rising" and "falling" - I mean Paris Hilton and Nicole Ritchie? I laugh when a comedian does a good bit on them, I don't when they don't. Beyond that I really wish I didn't have to hear about them, and I don't think the news is really the medium for examining Paris Hilton's latest antics.What exactly has she contributed, or anything, that technically puts her in a elevated position making he capable of falling, beyond people showing interest in her? They "fell", comedians make jokes, the world moves on. I know I'm not taking joy in their "fall" and nor am I on the ground beating my chest and wailing "Oh Britney, you don't deserve this!"
What I can be heard saying is "why the hell should this be on the news? It is her life, she made her choices, she has to deal with the results, like any normal mere mortal."
From what I have seen their issue had nothing to do with the fact she was rising and wanting to see her fall, but rather the things she said in relation to writing/philosophy, and/or the way the book was written (I appreciate it for what it is, though I felt it was ponderously written).
Hence why you should justify "rise and fall" - criticism of work is not desire to see someone fall, it is saying "I have a problem with what you are writing/saying/advocating/ and/or how you are doing it."
And I imagine there were people who disliked her, but a good number of the people who didn't like her writing/philosophy where just that = people not liking her writing/philosophy. Not people with some personal lust for her failure.
And ultimately if one puts themselves out there they have to understand, and accept, that some of the things they do wont be accepted by all, and as such there will be criticism.
I just think that hearing any celeb FALL or disgrace themselves isn't for my amusement at all, it's troubling, and it's not cute. Whitney Houston, that was TERRIBLE, terrible, terrible to her in that state, I don't care if she thought she was "all that", what does that have to do with ME? Reduce her life before the world b/c someone felt she thought she was "too good", so? I had a lady tell me that, WH felt she was too good and needed someone like BB to put her in her place. I thought, WOW lady, wow. WH, Paris, T.Campbell, as long as I don't "hear" there thoughts of me in such a way that it influences my work, love life, ability to socialize, WHY DO I CARE? WHY? I DON'T CARE WHAT SHE THINKS OF HERSELF, SHE THINK SHE WAS THE QUEEN BEE OF {BLANK}, HOW DOES THAT EFFECT MY SELF ESTEEM? IT DOESN'T, THAT'S THE TRICK, IT DOESN'T. And for those who allow it to effect their self worth, I wonder about them, I really do. I can care less what Paris thinks of herself, if she's destroying her life, I may end up caring, but if she thinks she's "all that", what does her mindset have to do with my job? my life? my love? my business? my income? my raises? my friends? my abilities? Some folks really do need to get a life and stop being so negative and hurtful in the lives of others, they really do need to get a hobby. If they feel this way about celebs they don't even know, can you imagine the stuff they do to their family members, coworkers? finding out if that person thinks they are "too good" and then stabbing them as they enjoy their fall? A person can talk by me and think that they are the better then or less then, their thoughts are for themelves, it's their institution, not mine, I don't own their thoughts of themselves, nor do I feel the right to manage it for them.
If we actually had love in our hearts, we wouldn't be trying to control people and having a time when they "fall". Maybe that celeb doesn't like females or dark females or apples or oranges or peaches or those who can't tan or gays or those who can tan or those who are grey or those who aren't, i don't give a darn what they like or dislike as long as they aren't troubling my job, welfare, income, banking, property, my right to speech or my civil rights, if they leave me alone, what do i care what they claim they like or dislike?
There are all sorts of philosophies out there, but the state of our culture, esp over the past 20-30 years has been in the joy of seeing negativity in others, esp. celebs (and that includes popular philosopher like Ayn Rand, again, even if I disagree with her work).