Borbarad
Advocatus Diaboli
Originally posted by Allankles
HA! You cal it sarcasm when it's not, regardless it was irrelevant. You started by saying: "stop arguing feat wars." I'm making it clear that COMBAT feats are relevant in this assessment for obvious reasons. Are you sure you don't have some kind of reasoning deficiencies.
That bit about Ulic clearly was sarcasm as I was pointing out how feat war works. Fact: You're using the Exile's defeats of opponents that were vunerable because of the Exile's very nature and the fact that the Exile's nature as unique to put the Exile above Ulic. Why: "Because only the Exile could have done this and that" (e.g. killing Nihilus).
Now simple question for you once more: Assuming Ulic was a wound in the force and had the knowledge required to break Sion's will. Could he have repeated the Exile's feat ? Yes. Vice versa: Could the Exile have repeated Ulic's feats ? I doubt she would have managed to stalemate Kun in a fight or hold off a Jedi without any force powers.
So who's the superior combatant here ?
The Sith possessing Dovos was just some random dark spirit. There's no evidence, both in what he accomplished through Dovos and what was said about him suggest he had anywhere near as much knowledge as Atris. Atrsi was studying the generations of accumulated Jedi knowledge on Sith Lore and surrounded herself with many Sith holocrons. Dovos's spirit represents only one holocron (if at all).Yes, logic, evidence dictates that Atris had more knowledge at her disposal and therefore was more knowledgeable in the force than some unknown random Sith spirit.
Dude. How stupid are you ? Let me do it step by step for you.
a) All Ancient Sith had access to Jedi lore as they were the descendants of former Rogue Jedi.
b) All Ancient Sith had access to Sith lore as they lived in an enviroment where it was commonly used.
c) The Sith spirit that possessed Dovos belongs to the group I named as "all ancient Sith" hence points "a" and "b" also apply to him.
Logic dictates that the Sith spirit had more knowledge because he lived in an enviroment dominated by force user far longer than Atris did study the force and especially the Dark Side. If you want to go by evidence, all that Atris does is using some force lightning. I'd say that equipping somebody with the ability to understand a foreign language instantly and then turn that non-force-sensitive metallurgic student into a fighting machine capable of taking it up with several Jedi pretty much trumps some force lightning. Which, in this case, really is something that "your average nightsister can repicate".
The random Sith spirit never possessed the knowledge of generations of accumulated Sith lore, because there is simply no evidence that he possessed anything but the rudimentary knowledge. Unless you have evidence Nai, you don't have an argument.
Right. Ancient Sith. Grew up in enviroment dominated by Sith Lore. Can't possibly have anything but "rudimentary knowledge" about said Sith Lord. Holy crap. That's the equivalent of saying that somebody who spent a century in the Jedi library on Ossus would have no idea about the Jedi order or Jedi lore. And evidence ? If you call granting somebody the ability to understand some ancient writings instantly and then turn him from some nobody into a guy that take it up with several Jedi "rudimentary knowledge" I can't really help you.
The only thing this oh-so-glorious Sith spirit accomplished, was getting trapped in a sith manuscript and then giving Warb Null some clearly ineffective medieval-looking armor. Whereas Atris was a Jedi historian who did extensive study and research on the force, going as far as studying a galaxies worth of accumulated Sith Lore for 5 or more years. I would say there's greater evidence of Atris having greater knowledge.
See above and stop boring me. A "galaxies worth of Sith Lore" ? Lmao. She had what - a dozen holocrons ? I'd really like to know how long Atris needed to study the Ancient Sith language which would have been the first step to even understand what those holocrons contained. And if all somebody can do with that uber freaking huge amount of knowledge is flooring a newly trained force user with force lightning, that knowledge can't have been too impressive or can it - at least if you consider what Kun was capable of after studying some scrolls for (according to you) some weaks.
Thanks for clarifying to me that you have no firm grasp of fiction. You didn't have an argument. Who said using the force doesn't need focus? However there's nothing to suggest, that manipulating three lightsabers with TK is impossible. We've seen more difficult feats accomplished. The gist of your argument can be summarized as : "My opinion is the ultimate authority on all things Kotor 2?"
Apparently you are still not getting the point. Of course somebody can affect more than one object with TK. That wasn't my point. My point was that wielding three lightsabers around with telekinesis in a way that results in those three sabers being more dangerous then one blade wielded by the very same force user in the regular fashion is an extremely unlikely if not impossible task. Reason: The force user would have to envision movement patterns for three lightsabers simultaneously (and coordinating two lightsabers is already reserved for the most skilled duellist - simply add another). And then the force user has to apply the TK on the lightsabers to move them exactly as he thinks they should move.
If you want something compareable: Try to do one task with your left hand, one with the right and something with one of your feet. At the same time read a book, talk with somebody about a topic not related you your movement task or the book and this while writing something to a third topic. You might consider that equal to what you suggest Kreia did while I assume she did something equivalent to juggling three balls while telling a story.
If you don't even show a grasp of the concept of fiction how the hell can you form a logical argument?
Apparently you don't have a grasp of the concept called "fiction". That something is fictional doesn't mean that "anything goes" and that rules defined for a fictional universe suddenly don't apply to that universe any longer because you don't want them to. It also doesn't mean that concepts from the real world don't apply to the fictional realm.
Now. Was that all clear enough for you or do I have to find a translator who speaks fluent moron ?