Namor, The Sub-Mariner vs Wolverine

Originally posted by jinzin
the guy said namor's never written correctly.. if that's true what's he basing his position on? it's as simple as that..

Originally posted by jinzin
and as for being unfair.. you nitpick every damn post I make, almost all your arguments against me are due to semantics... don't tell me about unfair accusations you ****ing hypocrite...

Originally posted by jinzin
the one where wolverine gutted him perhaps.. 😕

Originally posted by TwisterGameX
So mel do you have anything called proof.... to back up your claims..perhaps some scans or you know proof of some sort. I must of missed some....so what was your arguement again mel ?

My position is that Namor takes this 9/10.

What sort of proof, exactly, are you looking for?

Originally posted by Melnorme
My position is that Namor takes this 9/10.

What sort of proof, exactly, are you looking for?

The ones you are not giving.

Originally posted by TwisterGameX
The ones you are not giving.

Specifically, what?

Originally posted by TwisterGameX
The ones you are not giving.

So, you're asking me to chase my tail for you? Sorry, but it's really not worth the effort.

Originally posted by Melnorme
So, you're asking me to chase my tail for you? Sorry, but it's really not worth the effort.

If it makes you feel better 🙄

No. I think chasing my tail would do little for me or my feelings, but it would likely give you some small measure of satisfaction. In this regard, I am going to tell you to get bent, and remind you that you're out of your league. 😛

Originally posted by Melnorme
No. I think chasing my tail would do little for me or my feelings, but it would likely give you some small measure of satisfaction. In this regard, I am going to tell you to get bent, and remind you that you're out of your league. 😛

Yeah clearly 🙄

When you figure it out, drop me a line.

Originally posted by Melnorme
When you figure it out, drop me a line.

It's ok if you are confused but it's not your fault. 🙁

Originally posted by Melnorme
It doesn't seem that way to me, considering that's how most knockouts happen. Are you saying he lost so much blood that he went into shock?

the healing factor doesn't negate pain.. and while wolverine thrives off pain mentally.. he wasn't wolverine at the time.. mentally of course...
the feats invalid...

Originally posted by Melnorme
Neither opponent was near his feet. Look at the panels again. He got knocked on the head, and lost his ability to stand, and fell on a sword.

Originally posted by Melnorme
If you concede that he lost the ability to stand, whether or not he remained awake on some level, my point stands. I have little interest in hair-splitting on that level with you.

so why do you?

wait.. losing balance is losing conciousness? wow I got KOed last night 10 times while ice skating.. that sucks.. 🙄

Originally posted by Melnorme
Straw man. Where is the blood? .

Originally posted by Melnorme
Why was he still conscious?.

Originally posted by Melnorme
If one blow does more obvious physical damage than the other, then why are you arguing that the other was necessarily more powerful?

Originally posted by Melnorme
I already did, in the post that your prior response was quoting. You either missed them or are disregarding them now.

you have three feats.. one doesn't count, one's not a KO.. and the other is the only feat you've got. I asked for more, you said more existed.. I have yet to see it..

Originally posted by Melnorme
A straw man. I am not arguing real world logic vs comic book logic. I realize that it really doesn't apply here. I am describing comic book PIS vs the logic used here on KMC to determine the outcome of a bout..

you said my conclussion from observing comics to make a desicion about comic book characters isn't logical..

wolverine takes hits from class 50 and up without going down 8 or 9/10 in the comics.. not the other way around... yet i'm illogical? if you're not arguing about real world biology, or comic feats.. then why is my assessment illogical?

Originally posted by Melnorme
In other words, you've run out of ways to defend your position, so you claim bias.

Disappointing...

what else can I due against a "hu-uh" argument? that's all you've given here...

Originally posted by TwisterGameX
It's ok if you are confused but it's not your fault. 🙁

Yes, my friend. I am the one who is confused. 😆

Originally posted by Melnorme
I don't think he's claimed that Namor is never written correctly, but it is not my job to champion DarkCrawler's position. He can surely do that on his own.

it's what the guy said...

Originally posted by Melnorme
Okay, yes. Is that the same one that DarkCrawler edited with the funny dialogue? 😕

new invaders 6.. wolverine stabs namor..

conclussion.. wolverine can stab namor...

Originally posted by Melnorme
Yes, my friend. I am the one who is confused.

I can't argue with you there .

namors feats count, and wolverines dont??? well that doesnt sound fair to me at all....

Originally posted by TheBig Bad Wolf
namors feats count, and wolverines dont??? well that doesnt sound fair to me at all....

that's the way it works around these parts though.. ❌

Originally posted by jinzin
that's the way it works around these parts though.. ❌

Originally posted by TheBig Bad Wolf
well the way i look at it is that wolverine is up in the tally.......and without us agent Namor wouldve been starkist.....

better be careful man.. they'll start calling you fanboy for sure.. better delete that right now.. 😂

I agree but whatchagonna do.. they say it don't count...

Originally posted by jinzin
better be careful man.. they'll start calling you fanboy for sure.. better delete that right now.. 😂

I agree but whatchagonna do.. they say it don't count...