Originally posted by Accel
Which was much more than what you posted. You keep viewing this as PIS. Did it ever occur to you that the Thor fight was the defining moment of how Juggernaut's shield works?Otherwise, if it doesn't directly contradict any thing, it can't possibly be PIS.
I somewhat view it as this way, if the Godblast isn't mystical, Juggernaut would survive uninjured without the shield. Basically if it is just energy hitting him, then he would be okay. If it is mystical(they type to harm Juggernaut through magic) then he would need his shield to come out unscathed.
By the way there are comic labeling him as invincible. One time beast even said that he is still invulnurable without his shield.