Superman vs Silver surfer

Started by Papa Smurph387 pages

Because being shot with red sun isn't nearly as devastating as being shot with K-nite and something Superman could likely shrug off.

Originally posted by Soljer
Hey, man - you don't need his acceptance of your opinion. Thats one of the great things about opinions. No one need agree on them.

Stick to your guns - show some resolve.

I mean, I support the Surfer in this match, but it's nice to see someone trying to approach it from another angle.

Your right!
Thanks!

Originally posted by vlaaad12345
Hulk,thor,thing,thanos,silver has a bad track record against any brick of worth
This is incorrect. Surfer has a spectacular record against Hulk, Thing, Abomination, Champion, Wonder Man, Lunatik, and Krosakis. And neither Thor nor Thanos should really be considered bricks.

The idea that Surfer crumbles when facing bricks is a anti-fan fallacy, plain and simple. *shrugs*

Its not just k-nite or red sun radiation.
Surfer could just absorb supermans solar energy dry.
If he can absorb a whole sun im pretty sure he can absorb a far far far lesser amount of solar energy from superman.😬

Surfer never absorbed an entire star.

Originally posted by batdude123
Surfer never absorbed an entire star.

Fact still remains that absorbing the solar energy in supes is small frys compared to what he has absorbed before. Should be a walk in the park for surfer.

And that method has been tried and failed on Superman. His body absorbs solar radiation at an exponentially faster rate when he's being depleted of his energy reserves.

In other words, the more radiation Surfer would suck out of him, the more radiation Superman's body would take in directly from the sun.

Originally posted by h1a8
Your right!
Thanks!

I dunno he might be taking the piss, because saying Superman wins via speed is not an original argument.

Originally posted by batdude123
And that method has been tried and failed on Superman. His body absorbs solar radiation at an exponentially faster rate when he's being depleted of his energy reserves.

In other words, the more radiation Surfer would suck out of him, the more radiation Superman's body would take in directly from the sun.

Your acting like draining supes would take hours. He could drain him fairly fast and while weakened he could blast him dead.
Surfer has multiple options. Its not just red sun, k nite, and solar draining, its a combination of the 3 or even other options.
Just cause power cosmic blasts are not supermans weakness doesnt mean a full powered cosmic blasts wouldn't hurt or even kill supes eventually.

Originally posted by Juntai
Truth is, Superman gives pretty much everyone trouble.

😂

Superman debates always come down this this.

I doubt this fight (or any in the VS. forum involving clark) would take place in a Superman comic book writen by a Superman writer.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
I dunno he might be taking the piss, because saying Superman wins via speed is not an original argument.

Saying that Superman wins using speed against the Silver Surfer is quite original.

Originally posted by Inhuman
Its not just k-nite or red sun radiation.
Surfer could just absorb supermans solar energy dry.
If he can absorb a whole sun im pretty sure he can absorb a far far far lesser amount of solar energy from superman.😬

What's stopping Superman from absorbing it back, while beating the stuffing out of Surfer?

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
What's stopping Superman from absorbing it back, while beating the stuffing out of Surfer?
And what would stop Surfer from siphoning Superman's energy while preventing new solar power from reaching him?

Originally posted by batdude123
And that method has been tried and failed on Superman. His body absorbs solar radiation at an exponentially faster rate when he's being depleted of his energy reserves.

In other words, the more radiation Surfer would suck out of him, the more radiation Superman's body would take in directly from the sun.

Agreed. Besides..when he fought the kryptonian serial killer....the guy was amped by the strength of a planetful of beings, and using weapons specifically meant to weaken and kill kryptonians....and Superman was still able to match him blow for blow and was slowly overpowering him.

Major force also tried the same thing and got pwned. While Force is not as diverse with his energy manip..he's definitely comparable to SS in durability, and strength.

Surfer is not shrugging blows off from Superman...and while trying to do any of his pc hocus pocus...he will be ko'd.

Superman can just T-vo him as well. 🙂

Originally posted by Avlon
Agreed. Besides..when he fought the kryptonian serial killer....the guy was amped by the strength of a planetful of beings, and using weapons specifically meant to weaken and kill kryptonians....and Superman was still able to match him blow for blow and was slowly overpowering him.

Major force also tried the same thing and got pwned. While Force is not as diverse with his energy manip..he's definitely comparable to SS in durability, and strength.

Surfer is not shrugging blows off from Superman...and while trying to do any of his pc hocus pocus...he will be ko'd.

Superman can just T-vo him as well. 🙂

When was this and what were the cirumstances? Im taking what you say with a pinch of salt. You have misread scans before and when somebody says "he almost killed me" it doesnt mean that.

How many times has he used T-vo? 😬

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
When was this and what were the cirumstances? Im taking what you say with a pinch of salt. You have misread scans before and when somebody says "he almost killed me" it doesnt mean that.

How many times has he used T-vo? 😬

😆

Originally posted by Juntai
😆

Oh my god my sides are splitting hilarious!! 😂

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
When was this and what were the cirumstances? Im taking what you say with a pinch of salt. You have misread scans before and when somebody says "he almost killed me" it doesnt mean that.

How many times has he used T-vo? 😬

"He almost killed me" in which afterwards he is laughing off blasts from enraged skyfather level beings and pwning GL's.

Seriously Alfie... let it go.

Originally posted by Avlon
"He almost killed me" in which afterwards he is laughing off blasts from enraged skyfather level beings and pwning GL's.

Seriously Alfie... let it go.

Er I dont think he did that straight afterwards. From what I remember everybody was concentrating on SBP not Henshaw, he had time to recover.

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y112/avalonofthewind/Supermanv218516.jpg

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Oh my god my sides are splitting hilarious!! 😂
It is! You questioning someone elses validity and ability to interpret scans is quite funny, when most of the quality debators don't take you serious for the very same reasons.